The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculation Thread

Last 13 Challenges + Spinoffs' Formats:

36: Pairs

AS1: Individual with a Pairs Part

AS2: Individual with a Pairs Part

37: Pairs, then 3 Teams, then Individual, then Pairs

AS3: Individual

USA1: Pairs, then Individual

38: Pairs

USA2: 3 Teams, then Individual

39: Individual

AS4: Individual

40: 4 Teams, then Individual

AS5: Pairs

41: Starting Pairs

I'm ready for a good ol' majority team vs team challenge.

Same! A team vs team is needed! And with Katie and Veronica owning AS5 with old school moves - let's do a true old school real world / road rules challenge! 

i know they'd never do it and i get why but i wish they did an all womens season

Ok now that I know the cast for 41... I can get kinda excited for this

Not to just pull from The Ruins constantly lol, but there's a scene of them at the beach and it's honestly so refreshing. Please get them out of the house more and doing stuff!!!

i know they'd never do it and i get why but i wish they did an all womens season

I'd love it! The men never do much for me - the ladies have made this franchise what it is since day one 

Trying to imagine what the casting pool for Champions vs Contenders would look like. Obviously not including ANYONE from 41 or people that have said no over and over again while not being on in 15 years, or are pregnant/post-partum.

For the women:

For the men:

Trying to imagine what the casting pool for Champions vs Contenders would look like. Obviously not including ANYONE from 41 or people that have said no over and over again while not being on in 15 years, or are pregnant/post-partum.

For the women:

Collage_2025-03-13_13_28_14-min.jpg

Collage_2025-03-13_13_28_31-min.jpg

Champs: Amber, Veronica, Kendal, Roni, Carley, Susie, Tori, Julie Alt Katie

Contenders: Tina, Kellyanne, Melissa, Jasmine, Casey, Ravyn, Marie Cooke Alt Kam

BUT..... id put Ayanna in the mix because her on a team would cause some ****.

I saw Amber and quit paying attention.

Sam McGinn is most likely than 90% of the girls in the "winners pool"

I saw Amber and quit paying attention.

Yet you commented because you are a miserable *****.

I saw Amber and quit paying attention.

I'm not putting her on the cast, I'm saying she's likely "in the pool". I have 60 people here.

Sam McGinn is most likely than 90% of the girls in the "winners pool"

I have loved Sam's return so I'm okay with that.

Sam McGinn is most likely than 90% of the girls in the "winners pool"

That's ridiculous. She should not return. It's a nice story that she's doing better as the season goes on but she's not needed, her inclusion actively hurts the show's "brand".

BUT..... id put Ayanna in the mix because her on a team would cause some ****.

I don't think even if her health rebounds they'd ever include her again after the drama of AS4...

I actually had Sam on my pool of 15 at one point and took her off because the idea of her being on back to back All Star seasons was legit crazy to me. It's not even like she's a big personality. She's a nice person who's quite bland and grossly out of shape and heavy. We don't need her taking a valuable spot on a girls Champs lineup of max 8, more likely 7 spots.

I saw Amber and quit paying attention.

Yet you commented because you are a miserable *****.

I think misery is having a meltdown over some harmless Ambore shade.

I saw Amber and quit paying attention.

Yet you commented because you are a miserable *****.

I think misery is having a meltdown over some harmless Ambore shade.

Define meltdown?  

From my pool, I think my personal (and likely) preference on a cast of 28 (7 of each) is:

Male Champs:

Frank, Darrell, Kefla, Adam, Zach, Brad, Dan 

Alts: Yes & MJ (I would put Hunter and Landon on the cast but I think they're both likely no's)

Female Champs:

Laurel, Jodi, Emily, Sarah, Susie, Julie, Tori H

Alts: Carley & Kendall (I 100% expect Veronica and Katie to show up on Traitors 4)

Male Contenders:

Shane, LT, Dario, Kyle, Teck, Marlon, Raphy

Alts: Cohutta & Fessy

Female Contenders:

Tina, Kam, Kellyanne, Averey, Jasmine, Nurys, Casey

Alts: Ravyn & Melissa (I really don't expect Amanda to come back for this, or Kailah, Marie, or Cooke to return at all)

Sam McGinn is most likely than 90% of the girls in the "winners pool"

I have loved Sam's return so I'm okay with that.

The number of Sam-aritans growing each day <33333

The number of Sam-aritans growing each day <33333

Y'all must be eating too much Buffalo Wild Wings.

Sam has been an amazing addition to All Stars 5.

The number of Sam-aritans growing each day <33333

Y'all must be eating too much Buffalo Wild Wings.

It's Wendy's frosties and burgers, *****.

I can't believe how much I am loving Sam on this. She's been so refreshing and great.

Sam is such a refreshing lesbian. She's great.

The number of Sam-aritans growing each day <33333

Y'all must be eating too much Buffalo Wild Wings.

It's Wendy's frosties and burgers, *****.

Same difference. All the grease and fat going to your head.

The number of Sam-aritans growing each day <33333

Y'all must be eating too much Buffalo Wild Wings.

It's Wendy's frosties and burgers, *****.

Same difference. All the grease and fat going to your head.

Well excuse me Miss bougie Whole Foods, what do you like to eat then? Please outline the nutritional plan you will prepare for Sam.

Damn, I just realized there are a mess of lesbians on AS5: Big T, Nany, Veronica, Nicole, Aneesa, Sam. I'm not including Melissa because I don't think she's ever been in a long term relationship with a woman.

Tula is a lesbian?