The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculation Thread

Latoya and Marie keep declining...

I believe they're not casting Marie. If that's the case, thank you.

X100...she's the worst

IMO, alternates should be:

MJ (agreed) / Ace (agreed) or Cohutta / Jodi or Katie (and I love them both) / Casey, Jasmine or Melinda, but preferably Casey.

Cohutta IMO deserves the second chance the most. He was totally screwed out of AS2.

And I think Casey was playing a masterful political/strategic game on AS2 before...

Cohutta was screwed on almost every season

Island: Terrible format no chance of any rookie making it

Ruins: Went in to elimination 3 times becuase of his bank account

Bloodlines: Male/Female team.  Was eligible for elimination every round

AS2: Casey

Okay fine. We agree on all your picks for alts except for Carley. I need her to rekindle her beef with Laurel.

I really am dreaming thinking all of Sarah/Susie/Julie/Tori would be on here. I think we'd get lucky to get 2.

So which other female champ would you have on the cast just in case?

I would say Kendall or Roni? Anyone but Rachel lol.

Gtfo here, this cast is fiire!

I was trolling lol 

Gtfo here, this cast is fiire!

I was trolling lol 

Good, IMO this is a good baseline. You can definitely tweak here and there. If someone exciting comes out of the woodwork that hasn't been on in 15 years, I have no problems bumping Jay or Brad or Tori...

Amanda is from ATYO and is too new, keep her off All Stars. I'll always take her on the main show though (even though I'm not a fan). 

Amanda filmed her first season 10 years ago. Idk how anyone can say she doesn't belong on All Stars.

There's not going to be a massive influx of oldheads on these shows. Not everyone wants to be doing these shows at 45+. Hell, a lot of the actual OG's (Alton, Teck, Jisela) have been turned off by production and will probably never return. And you have others that are in great physical shape (Kefla, Darrell, Derrick) whose bodies are simply not holding up anymore. And the casual fans hate it when there's too many carnival games.

You are gonna have to get younger to film a watchable show...

false. Their age means nothing when it comes to it being a watchable show or not, that is all in the perspective of the viewer. IMO the OG's coming back have provided way more entertainment than the new generation could hope to do. 

I don't want it to be cancelled. We would never get Shane, Frank, Flora, Kefla, and other gems on a flagship season. So even if All Stars casts non-OGs who shouldn't be on, it's still worth it.

Agreed but if it would go back to RW/RR and even FM that would be a win

100%

How dare you make Carley an alternate again.

I think there's like a 99% chance one of Tori/Julie/Sarah/Susie wouldn't show up so she'd make the cast!

susie has been vocal about wanting to be on all stars and was vocal about wanting to be on 40. Susie and Sarah both were in to do I think All Stars 4 but were passed up which makes absolutely no sense to me

In my opinion, this is my cast for Champs vs Contenders.

With MJ, Ace, Carley, and Melinda being the alternates.

Collage_2025-03-15_21_41_11.jpg

Collage_2025-03-15_22_01_18.jpg

Collage_2025-03-15_21_49_53.jpg

Collage_2025-03-15_21_59_58.jpg

Ooooo, that sounds terrible- 

Gtfo here, this cast is fiire!

get rid of Fessy, Kam, Nurys, & Melissa and replace with other rw/rr/fm and yes it is! 

I know for some reason this site went Anti Rachel but she's still my queen - I'd love to see her Tina and Veronica play again together. Marie would be so refreshing to see either on all stars or the flagship - she's one of my favs from era 3.  She owned 30-32. (Shared the spotlight with Queen V on 30)

I'm still shocked Julie hasn't been cast. Susie too. Both want to come back and both passed up.  And Genesis, Tara, and Dan deserve a chance.  

sorry for all the posts I just caught up - been a long day lol

Would love to see Dan Renzi, Julie, and Jenn G again. 

I'm still waiting for Elka & Anne - and I want Cynthia to get another shot at it 

Susie and Julie are must. The fact that haven't been on it absolutely ridiculous.

Irulan & Coral would be my top choices if I could have anyone.

I know for some reason this site went Anti Rachel

She played a strategic game that was best for her and aligned with a person they don't like. 

What do yall think about casting Robin or do you think that's risky for her sobriety journey?

My All-Stars Rivals 2 Dream Cast:

1. Sophia and Mark

2. Ruthie and Aneesa

3. Josh and Ashley M

4. Ryan K and Katie

5. Tori H and Nia

6. Amber B and Esther

7. Piggy and Susie

8. Frank and Nany

9. Brad and Darrell

10. Jonna and Ayiiia

11. Beth and Norman

12. Derrick K and Derek C

My All-Stars Rivals 2 Dream Cast:

1. Sophia and Mark

2. Ruthie and Aneesa

3. Josh and Ashley M

4. Ryan K and Katie

5. Tori H and Nia

6. Amber B and Esther

7. Piggy and Susie

8. Frank and Nany

9. Brad and Darrell

10. Jonna and Ayiiia

11. Beth and Norman

12. Robb and Derek C

Crossed out all your trash picks.

My All-Stars Rivals 2 Dream Cast:

1. Sophia and Mark

2. Ruthie and Aneesa

3. Josh and Ashley M

4. Ryan K and Katie

5. Tori H and Nia

6. Amber B and Esther

7. Piggy and Susie

8. Frank and Nany

9. Brad and Darrell

10. Jonna and Ayiiia

11. Beth and Norman

12. Robb and Derek C

Crossed out all your trash picks.

I replaced Robb with Derrick K.

I think my cast is perfect the way it is. 

I think my cast is perfect the way it is. 

It's the perfect cure for insomnia. However people with depression shouldn't watch as your cast will increase symptoms.

Irulan & Coral would be my top choices if I could have anyone.

I forgot about Irulan! The story was she was on AS4 and she dropped days before, right? Hope they can get her on!!!

What do yall think about casting Robin or do you think that's risky for her sobriety journey?

This is a show of triggers. The slightest fight/trigger could send her down the final spiral. Let her stay happy and healthy far, far away from here.

https://x.com/themarklong/status/1902374360092225553?s=46&t=8kZj3ZfcI4hIlV77bp4pWQ

She's such a tease knowing she'll never do it.

Why coral playing with our hearts like that?

I love Coral but she looks...fragile? Vulnerable? Maybe even ill?

I don't want this chaos to ruin her....

I love Coral but she looks...fragile? Vulnerable? Maybe even ill?

I don't want this chaos to ruin her....

I didn't get that vibe from her. I think she looks great. Traitors is a WAY better fit for her where she'll be pampered and treated well.

I love Coral but she looks...fragile? Vulnerable? Maybe even ill?

I don't want this chaos to ruin her....

I didn't get that vibe from her. I think she looks great. Traitors is a WAY better fit for her where she'll be pampered and treated well.

I guess she looks okay but she doesn't sound anything like she did 15 years ago.

I love Coral but she looks...fragile? Vulnerable? Maybe even ill?

I don't want this chaos to ruin her....

I didn't get that vibe from her. I think she looks great. Traitors is a WAY better fit for her where she'll be pampered and treated well.

THIS. I need someone to get into her ear about how thats much more suited for her