Behind the Screen: The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculat

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

@Psypotato @CML come back me the heck up...

— OS Kajun

Amanda filmed her first season 10 years ago. Idk how anyone can say she doesn't belong on All Stars...

— CaraMariaLover

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculation T with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculation Thread

OS Kajun ·

@Psypotato @CML come back me the heck up!

30 Comments
OS Kajun#212

@Psypotato @CML come back me the heck up!

CaraMariaLover#213

Amanda filmed her first season 10 years ago. Idk how anyone can say she doesn't belong on All Stars.

Because she doesn't, there ya go Kiss 2

CaraMariaLover#214

Wait 2016 was almost 10 years ago? Sad

CaraMariaLover#215

Like I said, cancel this shit. Go back to two seasons a year and SHORTEN THE FILMING TIME! That way, we can get the likes of Da'Vonne, Frank, and Kam back. 

It makes no sense to me to not shorten filming time because it's cheaper AND makes for better TV like wtf?????????? 

OS Kajun#216

Alright, looks like it's just me and Potato in this fight!

UKLover1#217

I don't want it to be cancelled. We would never get Shane, Frank, Flora, Kefla, and other gems on a flagship season. So even if All Stars casts non-OGs who shouldn't be on, it's still worth it.

Sportsman180#218

Wait 2016 was almost 10 years ago?

Rivals 3 started filming December 2015...

CaraMariaLover#219

I don't want it to be cancelled. We would never get Shane, Frank, Flora, Kefla, and other gems on a flagship season. So even if All Stars casts non-OGs who shouldn't be on, it's still worth it.

Y'know what, Frank's return is definitely worth this shit getting ruined. 

kvm1977#220

I'm not buying that at all. Not sure how tha makes her son "more vulnerable"   I don't think that should or would play into Amanda's decision.  We all know I can't stand Amanda but there's zero reason she can't return.  By all accounts, her son is in very safe hands while mom earns money.  Now if she follows that up with a vacation so she can bang some loser then it's a different story.  

What do you mean "you're not buying it"? Her son's like a kindergardener and his teenage brother was just slain two months ago. It was clearly the reason she dropped from 41.

Do you really see her taking off in April/May/June for a few months to film a tv show while her five/six year old son is in that vulnerable of a state? 

No, that is not "clearly" the reason she dropped from 41.

Yes, I 100% see her leaving for a few months for the income the show provides while knowing her son is safe.

kvm1977#221

I don't want it to be cancelled. We would never get Shane, Frank, Flora, Kefla, and other gems on a flagship season. So even if All Stars casts non-OGs who shouldn't be on, it's still worth it.

Agreed but if it would go back to RW/RR and even FM that would be a win

Sportsman180#222

Emily broke her spine...T3 through T7...

null#223

wtf

entrepreneur#224

wtf

entrepreneur#225

Emily broke her spine...T3 through T7...

darrell was out there breaking backs...or Brad was

CaraMariaLover#226

Bring back Preston, LaToya, Marie, Ellen, Brianna Taylor, and Shauvon! 

Sportsman180#227

Bring back Preston, LaToya, Marie, Ellen, Brianna Taylor, and Shauvon! 

Latoya and Marie keep declining...

CaraMariaLover#228

Latoya and Marie keep declining...

I believe they're not casting Marie. If that's the case, what ******* idiots! 

UKLover1#229

Latoya and Marie keep declining...

I believe they're not casting Marie. If that's the case, thank you.

Sportsman180#230

In my opinion, this is my cast for Champs vs Contenders.

With MJ, Ace, Carley, and Melinda being the alternates.

Image from The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculation Thread
Image from The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculation Thread
Image from The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculation Thread
Image from The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculation Thread
CosmicDiva#231

How dare you make Carley an alternate again.

Sportsman180#232

How dare you make Carley an alternate again.

I think there's like a 99% chance one of Tori/Julie/Sarah/Susie wouldn't show up so she'd make the cast!

entrepreneur#233

Yuck @ ace and adam

Sportsman180#234

Yuck @ ace and adam

Adam is obnoxious but great on AS5. Ace was enjoyable (to me) on AS4, enough to get an alt spot!

CosmicDiva#235

IMO, alternates should be:

MJ (agreed) / Ace (agreed) or Cohutta / Jodi or Katie (and I love them both) / Casey, Jasmine or Melinda, but preferably Casey.

CaraMariaLover#236

In my opinion, this is my cast for Champs vs Contenders.

With MJ, Ace, Carley, and Melinda being the alternates.

Collage_2025-03-15_21_41_11.jpg
Collage_2025-03-15_22_01_18.jpg
Collage_2025-03-15_21_49_53.jpg
Collage_2025-03-15_21_59_58.jpg

Ooooo, that sounds terrible- 

Sportsman180#237

In my opinion, this is my cast for Champs vs Contenders.

With MJ, Ace, Carley, and Melinda being the alternates.

Collage_2025-03-15_21_41_11.jpg
Collage_2025-03-15_22_01_18.jpg
Collage_2025-03-15_21_49_53.jpg
Collage_2025-03-15_21_59_58.jpg

Ooooo, that sounds terrible- 

Gtfo here, this cast is fiire!

Sportsman180#238

IMO, alternates should be:

MJ (agreed) / Ace (agreed) or Cohutta / Jodi or Katie (and I love them both) / Casey, Jasmine or Melinda, but preferably Casey.

Cohutta IMO deserves the second chance the most. He was totally screwed out of AS2.

And I think Casey was playing a masterful political/strategic game on AS2 before...

CosmicDiva#239

Okay fine. We agree on all your picks for alts except for Carley. I need her to rekindle her beef with Laurel.

Sportsman180#240

Okay fine. We agree on all your picks for alts except for Carley. I need her to rekindle her beef with Laurel.

I really am dreaming thinking all of Sarah/Susie/Julie/Tori would be on here. I think we'd get lucky to get 2.

CosmicDiva#241

Okay fine. We agree on all your picks for alts except for Carley. I need her to rekindle her beef with Laurel.

I really am dreaming thinking all of Sarah/Susie/Julie/Tori would be on here. I think we'd get lucky to get 2.

So which other female champ would you have on the cast just in case?

Related Topics

The ChallengeThe Amazing RaceCast Spoilers