Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

richjoe92wrote:Debut Albumwrote:TeamLandonwrote:Nostalgicwrote:Debut Albumwrote:nevidcmwrote:AlwaysAMesswrote:Debut Albumwrote:Jenn or Theresa...

— richjoe92

Jonna Mannion or Christina LeblancJonna. All day Every Day...

— Debut Album

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: This or That?

richjoe92 ·
richjoe92 wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:
Nostalgic wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
nevidcm wrote:
AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Jenn or Theresa?

Theresa. Jenn reminded me of a chihuahua that never shut up.Fresh Meat or Bloodlines?

Queen Theresa <3Fresh Meat when it comes to the actual season and Bloodlines for the people it produced. Overall I'd say Bloodlines cause FM produced Kenny/Evan who are scum. Gauntlet 2: Rookies or Veterans?

Rookies. Derrick(X-TREME) or Landon?

Derrick. Landon's a *************** or Fresh Meat?

Fresh MeatAneesa vs Trishelle(Rivals 2) or Aneesa vs KellyAnne(Bloodlines) 

Aneesa/Trishelle.Backpack vs CT or Backpack vs Wes.

CT vs Backpack. It gave us the classic nickname "Backpack". Wes vs Kenny was much better than Backpack vs Wes.Would you rather have Aviv (FM1 winner) come back or Carley (FM2 winner) come back?Would you rather go against CT in hall brawl or Zach in Hall brawl?Would you rather have Parissa pull a Lacey and magically appear or Trisha and magically apear on a Challenge?

Aviv.ZachParisa.Marlon or Ty?

Mmm... Ty.

Best show for me is Real World.

Susie or Sarah?

Who would you rahter as a partner Melinda or Casey?

Who would you rather as a partner Danny (Austin) or Nick (Hollywood)?

Jessica or Bird?

30 Comments
richjoe92#152
richjoe92 wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:
Nostalgic wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
nevidcm wrote:
AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Jenn or Theresa?

Theresa. Jenn reminded me of a chihuahua that never shut up.Fresh Meat or Bloodlines?

Queen Theresa <3Fresh Meat when it comes to the actual season and Bloodlines for the people it produced. Overall I'd say Bloodlines cause FM produced Kenny/Evan who are scum. Gauntlet 2: Rookies or Veterans?

Rookies. Derrick(X-TREME) or Landon?

Derrick. Landon's a *************** or Fresh Meat?

Fresh MeatAneesa vs Trishelle(Rivals 2) or Aneesa vs KellyAnne(Bloodlines) 

Aneesa/Trishelle.Backpack vs CT or Backpack vs Wes.

CT vs Backpack. It gave us the classic nickname "Backpack". Wes vs Kenny was much better than Backpack vs Wes.Would you rather have Aviv (FM1 winner) come back or Carley (FM2 winner) come back?Would you rather go against CT in hall brawl or Zach in Hall brawl?Would you rather have Parissa pull a Lacey and magically appear or Trisha and magically apear on a Challenge?

Aviv.ZachParisa.Marlon or Ty?

Mmm... Ty.

Best show for me is Real World.

Susie or Sarah?

Who would you rahter as a partner Melinda or Casey?

Who would you rather as a partner Danny (Austin) or Nick (Hollywood)?

Jessica or Bird?

Jake.challenge#153

Jonna Mannion or Christina Leblanc

Debut Album#154
Jonna Mannion or Christina Leblanc

Jonna. All day Every Day.

The Real World or Road Rules?

LucciVee#155
Jake.challenge wrote:

Jonna Mannion or Christina Leblanc

Jonna. All day Every Day.The Real World or Road Rules?

The Real World. Smile

Which one would you like the show to soley be: Competition or Drama

Debut Album#156
Debut Album wrote:

Jake.challenge wrote:Jonna Mannion or Christina Leblanc

Jonna. All day Every Day.The Real World or Road Rules?

The Real World. :)Which one would you like the show to soley be: Competition or Drama

Competition.  Drama can come from that plus that pointless drunken fights is hardly interesting.

Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

AlwaysAMess#157
 Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.

Briana or Christina?

LucciVee#158
Debut Album wrote:

 Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina Sad

Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Debut Album#159
AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote: Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina :( Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Kailah.

Jenna or Briana.

LucciVee#160
LucciVee wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote: Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina :( Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Kailah.Jenna or Briana.

Briana. I like Jenna but she bland af.

Who *** you beating first, who you eliminating and who you friends with out of: Simone/Jasmine and Laurel.

MTV Junky#161
LucciVee wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote: Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina :( Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Kailah.Jenna or Briana.

Which Brianna are we talking about here?  If Lacuesta then I'll take her over Jenna.  If you're talking about Jenna's cousin, then Jenna.

Thomas or Vinny Pineapples?

Debut Album#162
Debut Album wrote:

LucciVee wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote: Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina :( Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Kailah.Jenna or Briana.

Which Brianna are we talking about here?  If Lacuesta then I'll take her over Jenna.  If you're talking about Jenna's cousin, then Jenna.Thomas or Vinny Pineapples?

I'm talking about Jenna's cousin.

MTV Junky#163
MTV Junky wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

LucciVee wrote:
AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote: Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina :( Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Kailah.Jenna or Briana.

Which Brianna are we talking about here?  If Lacuesta then I'll take her over Jenna.  If you're talking about Jenna's cousin, then Jenna.Thomas or Vinny Pineapples?

I'm talking about Jenna's cousin.

Jenna then.

El Scorcho#164
El Scorcho wrote:

richjoe92 wrote:

El Scorcho wrote:
nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Well it was the first time Coral was sent home. But yeah, I loved Fresh Meat. Most people hated the concept, I liked it because we got good challengers from the first one. The Ruins or Cutthroat? That is a good one.With a second Ruins challenge, I don't think they could cast 7-8 former female Champions. I feel like females move on from challenges faster than guys do. Camila, Cara Maria, and Sarah are the only shoo-ins. Any other former female champion has either moved on from challenges or we haven't heard from them in years.Cutthroat would be a little easier to cast as they could either do a RW vs. AYTO vs. Challenge or just random teams like the first installment.So I guess I'll say Cutthroat if we're being realistic and The Ruins ideally.

you know, I might get shot saying this in Vevmo, but what if they adopt the Ruins format with a RealWorld/Challenge alumni vs AYTO? That sure would be a shit show.

I don't really care to see a RW vs. AYTO format. There are few good AYTO cast members but I don't care to see a challenge with 14-16 AYTO cast members. 10 is more than enough on this current season. I'd be fine with seeing Nelson, Amanada, Devin, Cheyenne, Dario, and Briana again. That's about it.

TeamLandon#165
Debut Album wrote:

LucciVee wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote: Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina :( Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Kailah.Jenna or Briana.

Which Brianna are we talking about here?  If Lacuesta then I'll take her over Jenna.  If you're talking about Jenna's cousin, then Jenna.Thomas or Vinny Pineapples?

Thomas

Best Season: X-treme or South Pacific 

bluehatchet2#166

RW:GBGH or AYTO?3

Smile

MTV Junky#167
RW:GBGH or AYTO?3:)

The shade is real

AYTO?3 obv.

Debut Album#168
MTV Junky wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

LucciVee wrote:
AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote: Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina :( Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Kailah.Jenna or Briana.

Which Brianna are we talking about here?  If Lacuesta then I'll take her over Jenna.  If you're talking about Jenna's cousin, then Jenna.Thomas or Vinny Pineapples?

ThomasBest Season: X-treme or South Pacific 

South Pacific.

Ex-plosion or Skeletons.

LucciVee#169
TeamLandon wrote:

MTV Junky wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
LucciVee wrote:
AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote: Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina :( Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Kailah.Jenna or Briana.

Which Brianna are we talking about here?  If Lacuesta then I'll take her over Jenna.  If you're talking about Jenna's cousin, then Jenna.Thomas or Vinny Pineapples?

ThomasBest Season: X-treme or South Pacific 

South Pacific.Ex-plosion or Skeletons.

Explosion. Smile

Kaylen or Cheyenne. ✌

TeamLandon#170
Debut Album wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:

MTV Junky wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
LucciVee wrote:
AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote: Frank(San Diego 2) or Tyler.

Frank. Both were annoying, but at least Frank's dramatic *** could be entertaining at times.Briana or Christina?

Briana. Sorry Thotlina :( Who's more likable: Kailah or Jenna C.

Kailah.Jenna or Briana.

Which Brianna are we talking about here?  If Lacuesta then I'll take her over Jenna.  If you're talking about Jenna's cousin, then Jenna.Thomas or Vinny Pineapples?

ThomasBest Season: X-treme or South Pacific 

South Pacific.Ex-plosion or Skeletons.

Explosion. :)Kaylen or Cheyenne. ✌

Kaylen

Jenny or Madison

anon4981298798#171

Katelynn from RW: Brooklyn or Nicole from Bloodlines?

Debut Album#172
Katelynn from RW: Brooklyn or Nicole from Bloodlines?

Katelynn.

Derrick(X-treme) or Cohutta.

MTV Junky#173
LurkerNoMore wrote:

Katelynn from RW: Brooklyn or Nicole from Bloodlines?

Katelynn.Derrick(X-treme) or Cohutta.

Derrick - one of my all time favorites.

Timmy or Theo?

Debut Album#174
Debut Album wrote:

LurkerNoMore wrote:Katelynn from RW: Brooklyn or Nicole from Bloodlines?

Katelynn.Derrick(X-treme) or Cohutta.

Derrick - one of my all time favorites.Timmy or Theo?

Timmy. He was corny but it worked for him. 

Fresh Meat or AYTO.

MTV Junky#175
MTV Junky wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

LurkerNoMore wrote:Katelynn from RW: Brooklyn or Nicole from Bloodlines?

Katelynn.Derrick(X-treme) or Cohutta.

Derrick - one of my all time favorites.Timmy or Theo?

Timmy. He was corny but it worked for him. Fresh Meat or AYTO.

So far FM has brought more to the show.

Coral or Veronica?

anon333334#176
Debut Album wrote:

MTV Junky wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
LurkerNoMore wrote:Katelynn from RW: Brooklyn or Nicole from Bloodlines?

Katelynn.Derrick(X-treme) or Cohutta.

Derrick - one of my all time favorites.Timmy or Theo?

Timmy. He was corny but it worked for him. Fresh Meat or AYTO.

So far FM has brought more to the show.Coral or Veronica?

Coral.

Rachel or Evelyn?

Debut Album#177
Debut Album wrote:

MTV Junky wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
LurkerNoMore wrote:Katelynn from RW: Brooklyn or Nicole from Bloodlines?

Katelynn.Derrick(X-treme) or Cohutta.

Derrick - one of my all time favorites.Timmy or Theo?

Timmy. He was corny but it worked for him. Fresh Meat or AYTO.

So far FM has brought more to the show.Coral or Veronica?

Coral.

Debut Album#178
MTV Junky wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

MTV Junky wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
LurkerNoMore wrote:Katelynn from RW: Brooklyn or Nicole from Bloodlines?

Katelynn.Derrick(X-treme) or Cohutta.

Derrick - one of my all time favorites.Timmy or Theo?

Timmy. He was corny but it worked for him. Fresh Meat or AYTO.

So far FM has brought more to the show.Coral or Veronica?

Coral.Rachel or Evelyn?  

Rachel. **** Evelyn.

Danny(New Orleans 1) or Danny(Austin)

anon3895345345345#179

The Inferno 2 or The Gauntlet 2? 

anon333334#180
The Inferno 2 or The Gauntlet 2? 

Damn this is hard.....but Inferno 2.

Jenna (Plank) or Ashley K.?

anon3895345345345#181
justintime wrote:

The Inferno 2 or The Gauntlet 2? 

Damn this is hard.....but Inferno 2.

Jenna (Plank) or Ashley K.?

Right, both are amazing sequels. I enjoyed Gauntlet 2 more though cause of Beth's reign of terror lol 

And Ashley K. all day every day.

The better blonde who actually finished her first final >>>>>>

Related Topics

The Challenge