Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Who would’ve won Back Up Off Me had the heavy hitters not been brought in—Theresa or Tori. TheresaAneesa or KellyAnne...

— hardbitten

Rivals 1 by default cause Exes 1 was trashNany or Theresa (if you chose Nany you're wrong)Better competitor- TheresaHotter- TheresaLess annoying- TheresaWho I would rather never see again- NanySo my v...

— El Scorcho

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: This or That?

hardbitten ·
Seems more fun.Pete or Trey.

Trey

30 Comments
hardbitten#92
Seems more fun.Pete or Trey.

Trey

hardbitten#93
Who would’ve won Back Up Off Me had the heavy hitters not been brought in—Theresa or Tori?

Theresa

Aneesa or KellyAnne

hardbitten#94
Dustin or Leroy?

Dustin. Hands down.

El Scorcho#95

Rivals 1! 100%!

El Scorcho#96
Rivals 1 by default cause Exes 1 was trashNany or Theresa (if you chose Nany you're wrong)

Better competitor- Theresa

Hotter- Theresa

Less annoying- Theresa

Who I would rather never see again- Nany

So my vote is Theresa.

El Scorcho#97
rideordie95 wrote:

 X Battle or Handcuffs? 

Handcuffs because there are more rounds and it allows for people to wrestle around more.The Duel format or Free Agents format?

Thats a good one! Both could use more individual challenges but I like the Duel selection process better, so I'll go with The Duel.

El Scorcho#98
TeamLandon wrote:

richjoe92 wrote:Would you rather listen to Cara Maria cry and whine or Paula cry and whine?

Paula!! I love the baby voice. Most Dysfunctional Couple(during their seasons):Tony and Madison or Brian and Jenny

Brian and Jenny. Which Duel Season was better.Duel 1 or Duel 2?

The Duel 1 no questions asked.

JayTee#99

Who would you rather have as a male partner: Darrell or Derrick (in their primes of course)

El Scorcho#100
Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. 

Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

El Scorcho#101

Cutthroat II- RW vs. AYTO vs. FM/Bloodlines/Camila or Cutthroat II with random teams like the first one?

timster3#102

Y'all dun already ****** up this thread.

richjoe92#103
nevidcm wrote:

Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.

what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Undisclosed Desires#104
El Scorcho wrote:

nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!

Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

RobbKingo#105
richjoe92 wrote:

El Scorcho wrote:

nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

Mr. Beautiful I guess. Who the **** is that other Mr.?

Jonna or Averey? (My top 2)

Debut Album#106
El Scorcho wrote:

nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat.

TeamLandon#107
Undisclosed Desires wrote:

richjoe92 wrote:

El Scorcho wrote:
nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

Mr. Beautiful I guess. Who the **** is that other Mr.? 

Jonna or Averey? (My top 2)

Nate (AYTO2) goes by Mr. Wonderful on twitter... so maybe him? 

Avery. Jonna was too passive. 

Best non challenge moment? Puck's Wedding or Devyn's Weave Funeral.

richjoe92#108
RobbKingo wrote:

Undisclosed Desires wrote:

richjoe92 wrote:
El Scorcho wrote:
nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

Mr. Beautiful I guess. Who the **** is that other Mr.? Jonna or Averey? (My top 2)

Nate (AYTO2) goes by Mr. Wonderful on twitter... so maybe him? Avery. Jonna was too passive. Best non challenge moment? Puck's Wedding or Devyn's Weave Funeral. 

Pcuk's Wedding, more drama involved with it.

Debut Album#109
RobbKingo wrote:

Undisclosed Desires wrote:

richjoe92 wrote:
El Scorcho wrote:
nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

Mr. Beautiful I guess. Who the **** is that other Mr.? Jonna or Averey? (My top 2)

Nate (AYTO2) goes by Mr. Wonderful on twitter... so maybe him? Avery. Jonna was too passive. Best non challenge moment? Puck's Wedding or Devyn's Weave Funeral. 

Puck's Wedding.

Marlon or Brandon(Fresh Meat 2).

MTV Junky#110
TeamLandon wrote:

RobbKingo wrote:

Undisclosed Desires wrote:
richjoe92 wrote:
El Scorcho wrote:
nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

Mr. Beautiful I guess. Who the **** is that other Mr.? Jonna or Averey? (My top 2)

Nate (AYTO2) goes by Mr. Wonderful on twitter... so maybe him? Avery. Jonna was too passive. Best non challenge moment? Puck's Wedding or Devyn's Weave Funeral. 

Puck's Wedding.Marlon or Brandon(Fresh Meat 2).

Marlon

Sylvia or Violetta

TeamLandon#111
Debut Album wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:

RobbKingo wrote:
Undisclosed Desires wrote:
richjoe92 wrote:
El Scorcho wrote:
nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

Mr. Beautiful I guess. Who the **** is that other Mr.? Jonna or Averey? (My top 2)

Nate (AYTO2) goes by Mr. Wonderful on twitter... so maybe him? Avery. Jonna was too passive. Best non challenge moment? Puck's Wedding or Devyn's Weave Funeral. 

Puck's Wedding.Marlon or Brandon(Fresh Meat 2).

MarlonSylvia or Violetta

Sylvia

Favorite "Nerd"? Mike (Vegas 2) or Frank (Vegas 1)

RobbKingo#112
MTV Junky wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:
RobbKingo wrote:
Undisclosed Desires wrote:
richjoe92 wrote:
El Scorcho wrote:
nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

Mr. Beautiful I guess. Who the **** is that other Mr.? Jonna or Averey? (My top 2)

Nate (AYTO2) goes by Mr. Wonderful on twitter... so maybe him? Avery. Jonna was too passive. Best non challenge moment? Puck's Wedding or Devyn's Weave Funeral. 

Puck's Wedding.Marlon or Brandon(Fresh Meat 2).

MarlonSylvia or Violetta

SylviaFavorite "Nerd"? Mike (Vegas 2) or Frank (Vegas 1)

Mike Mike.

Hard one: Beth or Coral?

MTV Junky#113
TeamLandon wrote:

MTV Junky wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
TeamLandon wrote:
RobbKingo wrote:
Undisclosed Desires wrote:
richjoe92 wrote:
El Scorcho wrote:
nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

Mr. Beautiful I guess. Who the **** is that other Mr.? Jonna or Averey? (My top 2)

Nate (AYTO2) goes by Mr. Wonderful on twitter... so maybe him? Avery. Jonna was too passive. Best non challenge moment? Puck's Wedding or Devyn's Weave Funeral. 

Puck's Wedding.Marlon or Brandon(Fresh Meat 2).

MarlonSylvia or Violetta

SylviaFavorite "Nerd"? Mike (Vegas 2) or Frank (Vegas 1)

Mike Mike.Hard one: Beth or Coral?

CORAL

Ryan L. or Knight

AlwaysAMess#114
Ryan L. or Knight

Ryan L.

Free Agents Cara Maria or Bloodlines Cara Maria?

MTV Junky#115
MTV Junky wrote:

Ryan L. or Knight

Ryan L.Free Agents Cara Maria or Bloodlines Cara Maria?

Free Agents hands down. 

Johnny Bananas or Vinny Pineapples?

hardbitten#116
Ryan L. or Knight

Ryan L. Ryan L. Ryan L. Ryan L. Ryan L. Ryan L. Ryan L. Ryan L. Ryan L. Ryan L. Ryan L.

hardbitten#117
Free Agents Cara Maria or Bloodlines Cara Maria?

Battle of the Exes-Cara Maria LOL.

AlwaysAMess#118
AlwaysAMess wrote:

Free Agents Cara Maria or Bloodlines Cara Maria?

Battle of the Exes-Cara Maria LOL.

She was such a flop on Exes. Emily's she-hulk *** almost snapped her neck lmaooo.

Debut Album#119
RobbKingo wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:

MTV Junky wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
TeamLandon wrote:
RobbKingo wrote:
Undisclosed Desires wrote:
richjoe92 wrote:
El Scorcho wrote:
nevidcm wrote:Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1 is personally my favorite challenge of all time. There were more twists, turns, and unexpected things that happened before the days of production and TJ throwing in premeditated twists like the Ex-ile (Exes II), the White/Black skull (Rivals III), the location changes, etc. Fresh Meat 1 saw so many first time moments; Theo being eliminated, Coral being eliminated, Darrell being in an elimination round, among many other things. At the beginning of the season, no one called the final teams and that is what made that challenge the best. 

She was not eliminated. She was medevac. BUt FM1 is fuego man. It's an awesome challenge.what would you rather see back? Ruins or Cutthroat?

Cutthroat!!!Mr. Beautiful or Mr. Wonderful? 

Mr. Beautiful I guess. Who the **** is that other Mr.? Jonna or Averey? (My top 2)

Nate (AYTO2) goes by Mr. Wonderful on twitter... so maybe him? Avery. Jonna was too passive. Best non challenge moment? Puck's Wedding or Devyn's Weave Funeral. 

Puck's Wedding.Marlon or Brandon(Fresh Meat 2).

MarlonSylvia or Violetta

SylviaFavorite "Nerd"? Mike (Vegas 2) or Frank (Vegas 1)

Mike Mike.Hard one: Beth or Coral?

CORALRyan L. or Knight

I don't like him at all but Knight.

Fresh Meat Cast or Bloodlines Cast.

hardbitten#120
hardbitten wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:Free Agents Cara Maria or Bloodlines Cara Maria?

Battle of the Exes-Cara Maria LOL.

She was such a flop on Exes. Emily's she-hulk *** almost snapped her neck lmaooo.

Now that I think about it, I'm not sure why I was ever chill with Cara Maria there. She definitely annoyed me on every season, including Exes.

I hope Emily does it again tho, lool.

AlwaysAMess#121
Now that I think about it, I'm not sure why I was ever chill with Cara Maria there. She definitely annoyed me on every season, including Exes.I hope Emily does it again tho, lool.

Cara's one of my faves, however, I'm not a delusional stan and can realize when she's annoying. Her appearances on Free Agents and Cutthroat/Rivals are probably my favorite, though.

Related Topics

The Challenge