Behind the Screen: The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Finally came up with what I think would be the best Duel 3 cast while staying within the realm of possibilities (ex. no Miz, no Beth, no Timmy)Men- Abram (Road Rules South Pacific) - Alton (Real Worl...

— Nightwolf

Nightwolf;231982 wrote:Finally came up with what I think would be the best Duel 3 cast while staying within the realm of possibilities (ex. no Miz, no Beth, no Timmy)Men- Abram (Road Rules South Pacif...

— saltvinegar

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

Nightwolf ·
Finally came up with what I think would be the best Duel 3 cast while staying within the realm of possibilities (ex. no Miz, no Beth, no Timmy) Men - Abram (Road Rules South Pacific) - Alton (Real World Las Vegas) - Brad (Real World San Diego) - CT (Real World Paris) - Darrell (Road Rules Campus Crawl) - Derrick (Road Rules X-Treme) - Evan (Fresh Meat 1) - Frank (Real World Las Vegas) - Johnny (Real World Key West) - Kenny (Fresh Meat 1) - Landon (Real World Philadelphia) - Mark (Road Rules 1) - Wes (Real World Austin) Women - Coral (Real World Back 2 New York) - Diem (Fresh Meat 1) - Emily (Real World D.C.) - Evelyn (Fresh Meat 1) - Jodi (Road Rules X-Treme) - KellyAnne (Real World Sydney) - Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) - Rachel (Road Rules Campus Crawl) - Ruthie (Real World Hawaii) - Sarah (Real World Brooklyn) - Susie (Road Rules Down Under) - Svetlana (Real World Key West) - Veronica (Road Rules Semester At Sea) I picked these people based off performance (and since most of the new girls suck, it made finding a few girl slots difficult). I think it would be interesting to watch since it could literally end up being anyone.
30 Comments
Nightwolf#422
Finally came up with what I think would be the best Duel 3 cast while staying within the realm of possibilities (ex. no Miz, no Beth, no Timmy) Men - Abram (Road Rules South Pacific) - Alton (Real World Las Vegas) - Brad (Real World San Diego) - CT (Real World Paris) - Darrell (Road Rules Campus Crawl) - Derrick (Road Rules X-Treme) - Evan (Fresh Meat 1) - Frank (Real World Las Vegas) - Johnny (Real World Key West) - Kenny (Fresh Meat 1) - Landon (Real World Philadelphia) - Mark (Road Rules 1) - Wes (Real World Austin) Women - Coral (Real World Back 2 New York) - Diem (Fresh Meat 1) - Emily (Real World D.C.) - Evelyn (Fresh Meat 1) - Jodi (Road Rules X-Treme) - KellyAnne (Real World Sydney) - Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) - Rachel (Road Rules Campus Crawl) - Ruthie (Real World Hawaii) - Sarah (Real World Brooklyn) - Susie (Road Rules Down Under) - Svetlana (Real World Key West) - Veronica (Road Rules Semester At Sea) I picked these people based off performance (and since most of the new girls suck, it made finding a few girl slots difficult). I think it would be interesting to watch since it could literally end up being anyone.
saltvinegar#423
Nightwolf;231982 wrote:
Finally came up with what I think would be the best Duel 3 cast while staying within the realm of possibilities (ex. no Miz, no Beth, no Timmy) Men - Abram (Road Rules South Pacific) - Alton (Real World Las Vegas) - Brad (Real World San Diego) - CT (Real World Paris) - Darrell (Road Rules Campus Crawl) - Derrick (Road Rules X-Treme) - Evan (Fresh Meat 1) - Frank (Real World Las Vegas) - Johnny (Real World Key West) - Kenny (Fresh Meat 1) - Landon (Real World Philadelphia) - Mark (Road Rules 1) - Wes (Real World Austin) Women - Coral (Real World Back 2 New York) - Diem (Fresh Meat 1) - Emily (Real World D.C.) - Evelyn (Fresh Meat 1) - Jodi (Road Rules X-Treme) - KellyAnne (Real World Sydney) - Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) - Paula (Real World Key West) - Rachel (Road Rules Campus Crawl) - Sarah (Real World Brooklyn) - Susie (Road Rules Down Under) - Svetlana (Real World Key West) - Veronica (Road Rules Semester At Sea) I picked these people based off performance (and since most of the new girls suck, it made finding a few girl slots difficult). I think it would be interesting to watch since it could literally end up being anyone.
Replace Paula, Emily and Sarah with Kimberly, Ruthie, and Tonya and you've got a near perfect cast IMO. :)
Nightwolf#424
salt&vinegar;231983 wrote:
Replace Paula, Emily and Sarah with Kimberly, Ruthie, and Tonya and you've got a near perfect cast IMO. :)
Damnit I KNEW I forgot someone. I couldn't remember Ruthie for some reason. Have to figure out who she should replace now.
denise#425
salt&vinegar;231983 wrote:
Replace Paula, Emily and Sarah with Kimberly, Ruthie, and Tonya and you've got a near perfect cast IMO. :)
I understand replacing Paula and Sarah, but why replace Emily? She has the size and muscle mass to take out the majority of those girls on weight alone and based on Cutthroat she seems to at least have decent endurance.
saltvinegar#426
denise;232052 wrote:
I understand replacing Paula and Sarah, but why replace Emily? She has the size and muscle mass to take out the majority of those girls on weight alone and based on Cutthroat she seems to at least have decent endurance.
Ehhh, Emily is a solid competitor, but she doesn't really bring much to the show in terms of entertainment. Similar to Brittini.
denise#427
salt&vinegar;232053 wrote:
Ehhh, Emily is a solid competitor, but she doesn't really bring much to the show in terms of entertainment. Similar to Brittini.
Makes sense. I was actually thinking about Britt too
Clarke#428
The Challenge: "Frenemies" So I found this cast on wikipedia on different pages of Real World seasons so I made a list and found it to be pretty entertaining. It looks like a believable cast (Besides Joey), but it looks pretty boring on the male side, and they only had 11 males to the 15 females. (I know it's not the real cast for the next challenge nor the correct format. It's just for entertainment) Brandon (Fresh Meat II) Mike (DC) Ty (DC) Joey (Cancun) J.D. (Brooklyn) Johnny (Key West) * Tyler (Key West) * Eric (Fresh Meat) Danny (Austin) Adam (Paris) * CT (Paris) * Cara Maria (Fresh Meat II) Carley (Fresh Meat II) Laurel (Fresh Meat II) * Mandi (Fresh Meat II) Callie (DC) * Jonna (Cancun) Jasmine (Cancun) Ayiiia (Cancun) Katelynn (Brooklyn) Paula (Key West) WINNER Evelyn (Fresh Meat) Melinda (Austin) Tonya (Chicago) Aneesa (Chicago) Veronica (Semester at Sea) Apparently Paula was the sole winner, and those with the * are runner ups. I'm guessing you could be "Frenemies" with any sex so I made my guesses. > I couldn't find a pair for Mike and Callie, and they're good friends so I know they aren't a pair. >Apparently NOLA 2 and B2LV wasn't listed, but I could see a Ryan v Preston or Sahar v Mckenzie as good pairs.
RuffBuff#429
Girls: Kendal(RR) Cameran (RW San Diego) Jamie (RW San Diego) Emily (RW DC) Robin (RW San Diego) Coral (RW BTNY) Angela (RR) Melinda (RW Austin) Svetlana (RW Key West) Brynn (RW Las Vegas) Irulan (RW Las Vegas) Cara (RR) Guys: Jeremy (RR) Brad (RW San Diego) Brandon (FM2) Wes (RW Austin) Landon (RW Philly) Steven (RW Las Vegas) Randy (RW San Diego) C.T (RW PARIS) Ace (RW Paris) Jose (RW Key West) Joey (RW Hollywood) Will (RW Hollywood)
Teamrocket#430
Here's a realistic but entertaining cast for a «frenemies» type challenge 21. Guys 1- Tyler/Johnny 2- Ryan/Preston (NOLA) 3- Kenny/Wes 4- Brandon/Ty 5- Adam K./C.T. 6- Pete/Danny 7- Davis/Evan Girls 1- Jenn/Mandi 2- Jonna/Jasmine (Cancun) 3- Cara Maria/Laurel 4- Paula/Aneesa 5- Camila/Theresa 6- Diem/Tina 7- Sarah/Shauvon
VCR14#431
Looks good
JEKandWes#432
I wouldn't call Danny/Pete and Davis/Evan enemies.
JAB88#433
Guys: Theo (RR: Maximum Velocity Tour) Brad (RW: San Diego) Landon (RW: Philadelphia) Alton (RW: Las Vegas) Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl) Jamie (RW: New Orleans) Abram (RR: South Pacific) Timmy (RR:2) Yes (RR: Semester at Sea) CT (RW: Paris) Mike (RW: Back to NY) Wes (RW: Austin) Karamo (RW: Philadelphia) Puck (RW: San Francisco) Girls: Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea) Beth (RW: Los Angeles) Coral (RW: Back to NY) Emily (RR: 2) Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) Julie (RW: New Orleans) Kendal (RR: Campus Crawl) Kimberly (RW: Hollywood) Ruthie (RW: Hawaii) Ellen (RR: The Quest) Jodi (RR: Xtreme) Sarah (RR: Campus Crawl) Tina (RR: South Pacific) Holly (RR: Latin America)
saltvinegar#434
The Ruins 2. Champions: Coral Tonya Katie Rachel(CC) Carley Veronica Jillian Jamie Wes Alton Landon Darrel Dunbar Frank Tyler Abram Challengers: Preston Isaac Noor Chet Davis Ty Ryan Pete Bri Ayiiia Laurel Kim Trishelle Camilla Jasmine Irulan
jesses_girl#435
salt&vinegar;235218 wrote:
The Ruins 2. Champions: Coral Tonya Katie Rachel(CC) Carley Veronica Jillian Jamie Wes Alton Landon Darrel Dunbar Frank Tyler Abram Challengers: Preston Isaac Noor Chet Davis Ty Ryan Pete Bri Ayiiia Laurel Kim Trishelle Camilla Jasmine Irulan
That's such a lopsided team on the guys side haha, i like the players i'd just switch the teams up in a different format. And which "Ryan" is that? Kehoe, Leslie, or Conkiln?
Trinidad055#436
Here's a cast of the format Duel style with all challengers. Males: Ryan Leslie:RW Back to New Orleans Preston Charles:RW Back to New Orleans Andrew Woods:RW DC Mike Manning:RW DC Vinny Foti: Fresh Meat 2 Scott Herman: RW Brooklyn Derek Chavez RW: Cancun Jeff Barr: Fresh Meat 2 Alex Smith: RW: Denver Luke Wolfe: Fresh Meat 2 Davis Mallory: RW Denver Ryan Kehoe: Fresh Meat 2 Eric Banks: Fresh Meat Females: Kellyanne Judd: RW Sydney Jenn Grijalva: RW Denver Angel Turlington RR: Viewer's Revenge Jemmye Carroll RW: Back to new orleans Callie Walker: RW DC Ashley Lindley: RW DC Jasmine Renaud: RW Cancun Casey Cooper: Fresh Meat Shauvon Torres: RW Sydney Baya Voce: RW Brooklyn Katelynn Cusanelli: RW Brooklyn Colie Edison: RW: Denver Sandy Kang: Fresh Meat 2
dylan76#437
In reaction to the unempressive cast for this new (perhaps, enemy-paired) challenge, I made a list of who would be a dream cast for this type of format. What would be yours? GIRLS Elka/Trishelle Veronica/Tonya Coral/Julie Kina/Cara Tina/Beth KellyAnn/Johanna Robin/Aneesa Ev/Susie GUYS Abram/Adam L Shane/Ryan CT/Adam K Wes/Kenny Nehemiah/Danny Dunbar/Johnny Puck/David E Vinny/Derek
El Scorcho#438
The Challenge: Cutthroat 2 Red Team: Aneesa (RW: Chicago) Callie (RW: D.C.) Coral (RW: Back to New York) Danny (RW: Austin) Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl) Evelyn (Fresh Meat) KellyAnne (RW: Sydney) Knight (RW: New Orleans) Mark (RR: USA- First Adventure) Wes (RW: Austin) Gray Team: Carley (Fresh Meat II) CT (RW: Paris) Dan (RR: Viewer's Revenge) Jemmye (RW: New Orleans) Jonna (RW: Cancun) Landon (RW: Philadelphia) Mandi (Fresh Meat II) Pete (Fresh Meat II) Ryan (Fresh Meat) Tina (RR: South Pacific) Blue Team: Bronne (RW: Cancun) Camila (Spring Break Challenge) Casey (Fresh Meat) Eric (RW: New Orleans) Evan (Fresh Meat) Johnny (RW: Key West) Katelynn (RW: Brooklyn) Kenny (Fresh Meat) Mckenzie (RW: New Orleans) Theresa (Fresh Meat II)
Debut Album#439
20 people, 4 Teams of 5. Veterans Mark(RR 1) Brad(RW San Diego) Syrus(Boston) Rachel(RR Campus Crawl) Jenn(RW Denver) Rookies Emily(DC) Joey(Hollywood) Kendall(RR Campus Crawl) CJ(Cancun) Ashlee(New Orleans 2) Good Guys Ace(Paris) Callie(DC) Dave(South Pacific) Holly(Latin America) Landon(Philly) Bad ***** Tonya(Chicago) Abram(South Pacific) Emily(Second Adventure) Wes(Austin) Jisela(The Quest)
Debut Album#440
Same Format Diffrent teams and people. Real World Cohutta(Sydney) Trishelle(Las Vegas 1) David(Seattle) Sarah(Brooklyn) Will(Hollywood) Road Rules Piggy(Down Under) Patrick(X-TREME) Roni(Northern Trail) James(Maxumum Velocity Tour) Raquel(Campus Crawl) Champions Derrick(X-TREME) Susie(Down Under) Wes(Austin) Coral(Back to New York) Darrell(Campus Crawl) Challengers Jenn(Denver) Ryan(Brooklyn) Tina(South Pacific) Vince(Islands) Sarah(Philly)
Benfiquista#441
The Challenge: Duel 3 Guys Syrus (RW: Boston) Frank (RW: Las Vegas) CT (RW: Paris) Wes (RW: Austin) Tyler (RW: Key West) CJ (RW: Cancun) Leroy (RW: B2 Las Vegas) Mark (RR: First Adventure) Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl) Abram (RR: South Pacific) Derrick (RR: X-Treme) Evan (FM) Kenny (FM) Pete (FMII) Noor (FMII) Girls Ruthie (RW: Hawaii) Janelle (RW: Key West) Jenn (RW: Denver) Kelly-Anne (RW: Sydney) Brittni (RW: Hollywood) Sarah (RW: Brooklyn) Emily (RW: DC) Suise (RR: Down Under) Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea) Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) Ibis (RR: X-Treme) Ev (FM) Diem (FM) Laurel (FMII) Carley (FMII)
burythestar3#442
Guys: Alton Landon Abram Miz Frank Evan Kenny Johnny Tyler CT Darrell Derrick Girls: Rachel Ruthie Jenn Susie Ev Laurel Diem Brittini Kelly Anne Sarah Rice Tori Paula
RandomGay#443
Round 2 (I found out about it after round 1 closed) Landon CT Evan Darrell Long Johnny B (only because I hate him slightly less than Kenny) Derrick Brad Sarah Jenn Jodi Ruthie Jillian Ev Coral Johanna
RWRRULES#444
Mine would be DUEL 3 CHAMPIONS.... only best of best everyone has won before..an absolutely stacked competiton Male: Darrel Taylor (RR Campus Brawl) Kenny Santucci(Fresh Meat) John Devaninzio(RW Key West) Alton Williams(RW Las Vegas) Landan Lucek (RW Philadelphia) Derrick Kosinski (RR:X-Treme) Mark Long( RR First Adventure) Abe Boise (RR South Pacific) Evan Starkman (Fresh Meat) Tyler Duckworth (RW Key West) Brad Fiorenza (RW San Diego) Wes Bergman (RW Austin) Female: Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat) Rachel Robinson (RR Campus Brawl) Tonya Cooley (RR Chicago) Veronico Portillio (RR semester at Sea) Susie Miester (RR Down Under) Paula Meronek (RW Key West) Jodi Weatherton (RR Extreme) Tori Fiorenza (RR Viewers Revenge) Carley Johnson (Fresh Meat 2) Ibis Nieves (RR X-Treme) Kina Dean (RR X-treme) Johana Barta (Rw Austin) I think that caast would be stacked and the elimiations will never be boring...the girls side is a bit soft in depth, but not that many differet girls win the challenge recently
blackinwhite#445
This is the best challengers team I can think of and people who I think who can handle the physical and mental drain of these challenges. Hopefully next time when there is a challenge like the Ruins we can see a stronger Rookie/challengers team as good as the Gauntlet 2. I think this team can possibly take on the stacked champions team that we all know. Challengers Girls: Laurel Cara Maria Emily Kelly Anne Baya Jenn Janelle Diem Kim Guys Leroy CJ Pete Noor Scott CT Joey Will Jose
RWRRULES#446
blackinwhite;243052 wrote:
This is the best challengers team I can think of and people who I think who can handle the physical and mental drain of these challenges. Hopefully next time when there is a challenge like the Ruins we can see a stronger Rookie/challengers team as good as the Gauntlet 2. I think this team can possibly take on the stacked champions team that we all know. Challengers Girls: Laurel Cara Maria Emily Kelly Anne Baya Jenn Janelle Diem Kim Guys Leroy CJ Pete Noor Scott CT Joey Will Jose
Nice cast, not to nitpick but Janelle from rw Key West, wouldnt be a challenger, she won the Inferno 3
Kayla99#447
RWRRULES;242007 wrote:
Mine would be DUEL 3 CHAMPIONS.... only best of best everyone has won before..an absolutely stacked competiton Male: Darrel Taylor (RR Campus Brawl) Kenny Santucci(Fresh Meat) John Devaninzio(RW Key West) Alton Williams(RW Las Vegas) Landan Lucek (RW Philadelphia) Derrick Kosinski (RR:X-Treme) Mark Long( RR First Adventure) Abe Boise (RR South Pacific) Evan Starkman (Fresh Meat) Tyler Duckworth (RW Key West) Brad Fiorenza (RW San Diego) Wes Bergman (RW Austin) Female: Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat) Rachel Robinson (RR Campus Brawl) Tonya Cooley (RR Chicago) Veronico Portillio (RR semester at Sea) Susie Miester (RR Down Under) Paula Meronek (RW Key West) Jodi Weatherton (RR Extreme) Tori Fiorenza (RR Viewers Revenge) Carley Johnson (Fresh Meat 2) Ibis Nieves (RR X-Treme) Kina Dean (RR X-treme) Johana Barta (Rw Austin) I think that caast would be stacked and the elimiations will never be boring...the girls side is a bit soft in depth, but not that many differet girls win the challenge recently
That would be sick, guy's cast is a homerun. Every single one of them are great competitors.
Debut Album#448
The Duel 3. No experience Necessary. This Challenge will consist only of Rookies who have 1 or 0 challenges. Here is the cast Mike(DC) Adam(Las Vegas 2) Knight(New Orleans 2) Scott (Brooklyn) Joey(Hollywood) Eric(Campus Crawl) Antoine(Europe) Blair(The Quest) Patrick(X-TREME) Chris(South Pacific) Devyn(Brooklyn) Jemmye(New Orleans 2) Brianna(Hollywood) Mckenzie(New Orleans 2) Nany(Las Vegas 2) Roni(Northern Trail) Mary Beth(South Pacific) Angela(X-TREME) Raquel(Campus Crawl) Belou(Europe)
hlthydstrst#449
Derrick K. Wes Landon CT Coral Evelyn Rachel Kelly Ann
Blue123#450
Guys: (even though I dont like some of these guys I wana see em loose (JKE) ) Wes Landon CT Brad Abram Danny Johnny Kenny Evan Mark Derrick Derrell Girls: Evelyn Rachel Coral Kelly Anne Veronica Diem Svetlana Kina man I cant really finish the girls list, I dont really like most of them girls on the show most of them suck, but Ev, Rachel and Coral are the top so if they could all be on a challenge that would be cool.
realworld#451
Well this upcoming challenge got me thinking about a same sex Battle of the Seasons Guys Real World Philadelphia-Landon and MJ Real World San Diego-Brad and Randy Real World Paris-CT and Ace Real World Las Vegas-Alton and Frank(or Steven) Real World Austin-Wes and Nehemiah Real World Key West-Johnny and Tyler Real World Brooklyn-Scott and Chet Real World Cancun-CJ and Bronne Possible 9th Team-RW Las Vegas 2 Leroy and Dustin Girls Real World Key West-Svetlana and Janelle Real World D.C.-Emily and Ashley Real World NOLA2-Jemmye and Ashlee Real World Brooklyn-Sarah and Devyn Real World Hollywood-Brittini and Brianna(or Kim) Real World Sydney-KellyAnne and Trisha(or Parisa) Real World San Diego-Robin and Jamie Real World Las Vegas-Arissa and Irulan Possible 9th Team RW Chicago-Tonya and Aneesa

Related Topics

The ChallengeEntertainmentCast Spoilers