Big Brother All-Stars 2

Both Will and Janelle said they would not return.

The only pre-All Stars people I could see returning are Amy, Danielle, Alison, and James

That would be freaking awesome if they brought back Alison!!!!

Nobody that appeared on the 1st All-Stars should come back.

I see why you think that but I disagree, there are some great players and characters that participated in AS1 including Will, Janelle, Danielle, Alison, Nakomis and Diane. There have been some great people since then but not a lot have been as good of players as those 6 people.

They probaly should bring back old school contestants, cuz BB12 cast were all idiots

RuffBuff;232940 wrote:
They probaly should bring back old school contestants, cuz BB12 cast were all idiots

Not true. The Brigade was, but some others were not. I could see Brit and Rachel being cast. All others didn't perform up to par, but you have to ATLEAST put them into contention. Rachel brought drama and we all know drama = Ratings! Brit won many POV's and played the game very well considering she made Final 4 without knowing about the Brigade. If you have a reason why none of them should be on, do tell.

Rachel is pretty much the only person I would say is forsure going to be on if the do another one. Everyone else is pretty up in the air.

BB wise i can easily see Rachel and Britney AND Matt since all three brought a lot to the show be it drama, lies, *****yness or all three. On the side, Enzo and Brendan. Other than them its either 'Booted too early to consider ala Monet/Annie/Andrew', 'Irritating in a bad way like Ragan' or 'Boring like Hayden' Yes I do consider Hayden boring in BB12 because while he had a good strategy, he wasnt exactly the most 'exciting' to watch.

Kathy HAS to be on! She was the breakout star ;)

Spinner554;232941 wrote:
Not true. The Brigade was, but some others were not. I could see Brit and Rachel being cast. All others didn't perform up to par, but you have to ATLEAST put them into contention. Rachel brought drama and we all know drama = Ratings! Brit won many POV's and played the game very well considering she made Final 4 without knowing about the Brigade. If you have a reason why none of them should be on, do tell.

Yeah no dought Brit Rachel and maybe even mat will be considered...The Bragade aliance only worked becuase everyone else was cluless. That aliance would not have work well in any other season cast. They all thought everyone was freinds and its the house aginst brenchel. If they were BB fans they should of know there were going to be other aliances beside the aliance of 2.... Yeah Britany won 2 Pov's & HOH but so did Brendon... My opinion last season would of been really boring w/O Rachel.

salt&vinegar;232945 wrote:
Kathy HAS to be on! She was the breakout star ;)

Agreed! Plus Monet and Lane (I literally had to check if the name was right, because I originally wrote Lance, and it didn't feel correct). All of them were bordering on amazing. Not just there personality, but everything they brought to the show.

RuffBuff;232940 wrote:
They probaly should bring back old school contestants, cuz BB12 cast were all idiots

I completely agree. I just don't think any of them played the game well at all, like people in the pase have. Most seemed to play out of spite and dislike for others. I would even go as far as saying the Brigade was WAY smarter than the others because they actually made an alliance early on.

Spinner554;232941 wrote:
Not true. The Brigade was, but some others were not. I could see Brit and Rachel being cast. All others didn't perform up to par, but you have to ATLEAST put them into contention. Rachel brought drama and we all know drama = Ratings! Brit won many POV's and played the game very well considering she made Final 4 without knowing about the Brigade. If you have a reason why none of them should be on, do tell.

Sure they deserve to be on, I'd just rather not see any of them on my television anytime soon. And if those two are in contention you can pretty much put every single person up for contention. So I'm hoping it's not an All-Star season. I'd like some decent players on an All-Star season.

The only people I think they'd consider from BB12 to be on All Stars is Brendon, Rachel, Matt, Brittany, and MAYBE Ragan. I'm only throwing Ragan in there because he was actually a pretty popular cast member with the viewers (I've read that his eviction episode got the highest ratings of the season AND he almost won Favorite Male Reality Star of the year at the ONTD awards but was narrowly beat by Fabio (Survivor) and Pauly D (Jersey Shore)). So I could see them asking him back based on his popularity. Matt, Brittany, and Brendon all played interesting games and in my opinion were actual "all star" players. So I hope they will be included. Rachel will be included for drama.

what a great pic. Bacc. you did a great job.

What?

Spinner554;234889 wrote:
What?

I'm thinking sofrito was talking about the pic of Evel **** and James on page 1 of the thread. I could be wrong though.

If I was to cast a season starting with season 8 I would do... **** (shudder) Jen Jessica Sheila Natalie Dan Renny Jessie (I know many would not like him on... for more reasons than it being his 3rd time. But I think he has his moments) Jeff Kevin Enzo Brendan Rachel Britney I would almost say you could guarantee Jessica a spot in the final 2 with this cast since that's how all star games usually go. I would love a cast similar to season 10 in terms of age diversity, I feel the strategy was bigger and better. Huge moves made in the first week. And huge power shifts and comebacks as well (in terms of Dan) It was a predictable finale, but I feel most of them are.

Males 1. **** (BB8) 2. Eric (BB8) 3. James (BB9) 4. Dan (BB10) 5. Jeff (BB11) 6. Russell (BB11) 7. Ragan/Matt (BB12) Females 1. Daniele (BB8) 2. Jen (BB8)/Laura (BB11) 3. Sheila (BB9)/ Libra (BB10) 4. Keesha (BB10) 5. Jordan (BB11) 6. Britney (BB12) 7. Rachel (BB12)

I think if they did another all stars they should do something to spice it up like steal the challenge's idea and pair everyone with their worst enemy from their season.

kinafan2012;253292 wrote:
I think if they did another all stars they should do something to spice it up like steal the challenge's idea and pair everyone with their worst enemy from their season.

That would suck. BB is an individual game and should stay that way.

kinafan2012;253292 wrote:
I think if they did another all stars they should do something to spice it up like steal the challenge's idea and pair everyone with their worst enemy from their season.

It's not completely out of the question but I just can't see that happening.

RMD1;253296 wrote:
That would suck. BB is an individual game and should stay that way.

...and the first half of BB9 was an epic fail because they wanted to switch it up. I agree, it's better when they come in alone. Even when they pair/group them up, it's over after week 3.

BB9 sucked because the casting sucked. They could've made the concept work if they put any effort into proper casting.

kinafan2012;253468 wrote:
BB9 sucked because the casting sucked. They could've made the concept work if they put any effort into proper casting.

I think anyone that goes on a game show "looking to hookup" like they did with that season, can easily make the game play and season really bad. :-( I think a bunch of psychology and political science majors could really spice up the game. I feel they are generally the most intelligent in terms of social experiments and social gaming.

kinafan2012;253468 wrote:
BB9 sucked because the casting sucked. They could've made the concept work if they put any effort into proper casting.

It's actually not just BB9. It's since BB9 that they have had less than mediocre casting and I don't see how they will be able to cast 12 or 13 sane people for an All-Star season.

I love how they casted season 10. But I agree that every other season it's been pretty much trashy psychos and... "Veeeeeeeeeeeeeeegaaaaaaaaaaaaas, woooooooo!"

SkylarGuy23;253498 wrote:
I think anyone that goes on a game show "looking to hookup" like they did with that season, can easily make the game play and season really bad. :-( I think a bunch of psychology and political science majors could really spice up the game. I feel they are generally the most intelligent in terms of social experiments and social gaming.

Psychology and political science majors are also good at mind ******* other people. It'd be the most paranoid house ever.

here's my list of people that they would consider. i think for all stars 2 they should bring back 16 house guests. considering certain all stars were chosen for big brother 13 the alternates are in parentheses bb 8 **** jen daniele (eric) bb9 matt natalie chelsia bb 10 dan keesha libra bb 11 jeff jordan jesse (natalie) bb 12 rachel brendon britney enzo (ragan) bb 13 dominic kalia adam/ porsche

1-7: Howie Danielle (3) Jun and Janelle (highly doubt she would do it, but she would be asked) 8: ****, Daniele, Jen, Eric (Maybe Nick due to all the BB girlfriends he's had) 9:Natalie (maybe james) 10: Dan Memphis Keesha Renny Libra 11. Jeff Jordan Russell Jessie Natalie Lydia 12: Britany Lane Brendon Rachel Ragan (Maybe Kristen if Nick is asked) 13: Porsche Shelly (maybe Dom or Cassie