Battle of the Seasons: Brooklyn - Chet, JD, Sarah, Devyn

Kajun;318381 wrote:
I thought the purpose of this challenge was a fresh cast? So Sarah wasn't needed. I think Baya would have been a great addition. However, I know nothing about who was available/willing.

You can't have an all "fresh cast" though because lots of people watch the challenges and not the Real World. Alton, Trishelle, Wes, Danny, Melinda, Sarah, etc are important to keep some viewers. Clearly not you but if those people weren't on I'd have no reason to watch. They have a good mix of old & new. No clue who Baya is though--didn't realize there were 8 on that cast.

kvm1977;318384 wrote:
They have a good mix of old & new. No clue who Baya is though--didn't realize there were 8 on that cast.

Brooklyn was the first season with 8 roommates... she was usually dubbed as the invisible one though.:meh:

arilicious;318385 wrote:
Brooklyn was the first season with 8 roommates... she was usually dubbed as the invisible one though.:meh:

Thanks--that could be why I don't even recall her name ever being mentioned

kvm1977;318384 wrote:
You can't have an all "fresh cast" though because lots of people watch the challenges and not the Real World. Alton, Trishelle, Wes, Danny, Melinda, Sarah, etc are important to keep some viewers. Clearly not you but if those people weren't on I'd have no reason to watch. They have a good mix of old & new. No clue who Baya is though--didn't realize there were 8 on that cast.

I am super excited for Trishelle, Alton, Melinda (Danny just because of Mel though). If it were up to me the show would be filled with RW/RR from Austin and earlier. There would be no Fresh Meat or Sarah repeats or JEK. I get they need a mix, I just don't think Sarah is a fan-favorite high demand. Hopefully, they are introducing rookies so they can weed her out of future challenges.

I'm joping Zach, Nany, Jemmye, Frank & Knight really prove themselves & after Sarah inevitably loses this challenge, BMP will realize aside from her few fans, she is just not needed or wanted & that there are much more interesting people to take her slot.

TSPKM2;318329 wrote:
If you are tryin to win $250,000 and are completely capable athletically of doing so, but you have a person on your team, who is compeltely worthless physically and doesnt even try...you would probably talk crap on Devyn too. It is called being competitive and wanting to win. Aint no shame in that.

How would you or my team know that I wouldn't even try? That's called assuming. It's also call unintelligent. Watch the show.. then make an educated comment.

arilicious;318356 wrote:
Were people calling Devyn fat? Cause I don't think so, at least not from what I see in that picture...her ***** though, that's a whole different story, but the rest of her body I don't see much of a problem with it.

Hahha thank you. Since when did a size 4 become fat? If 34DD's and a 26 inch waist is fat then I'll take it!!

So Devyn is it safe to assume you and Sarah aren't bff's anymore? And where is Baya hiding! Tell her to pull a Lacey and randomly show up to a challenge!

Kajun;318393 wrote:
So Devyn is it safe to assume you and Sarah aren't bff's anymore? And where is Baya hiding! Tell her to pull a Lacey and randomly show up to a challenge!

Baya and I had discussed doing a challenge together.. it would have been so great to do one with her. She's doing well and has her own matchmaking service in Utah. I'll tell her you said hi :acute:

Good for her. Sucks she wasn't picked over shady Sarah. I can't wait to see you prove the haters wrong. Please make me lol and last longer than Sarah! Thanks for the Baya update!

DSsquared;318392 wrote:
Hahha thank you. Since when did a size 4 become fat? If 34DD's and a 26 inch waist is fat then I'll take it!!

I think your sexy Devynn....I heard you have a thing for QBs well I'll have you know I was QB for my 6th grade team that went undefeated, just saying.

Kajun;318350 wrote:
You are in the minority, she adds nothing.

Sarah adds a whole lot to the game. You may not like Sarah, but to say she's a bad competitor is crazy. Sarah is a very good player. I'm glad she's back on another challenge. I knew she would be back and she won't dissapoint. Just because someone supports Sarah dosen't mean they are in the minority. It just means their opinion differs from yours.

I never said Sarah is a bad competitor, she's decent she isn't so good that its fun to watch her compete. I am interested to see how she does without JEK protecting her. I just don't see her as a standout character that needs to be brought back 100x like Katie and Veronica were. It is my opinion that she sucks at life, but it is fact that she is not a dynamic personality. Hopefully she as well as the Fresh meat cast have a QUICK exit.

Kajun;318350 wrote:
You are in the minority, she adds nothing.

Actually you are in the minority. Most people on this site are in the minority with their opinions. Super fans like us want to see new fresh faces, whereas many of the comments on mtv and twitter want to see some regular faces...some people are only watching for Wes and Sarah becasue they are the only regulars of the bunch.

DSsquared;318391 wrote:
How would you or my team know that I wouldn't even try? That's called assuming. It's also call unintelligent. Watch the show.. then make an educated comment.

Nah Dev, it isn't called unintelligent. My point was you didn't workout before the challenge. I'm also going to assume you knew what challenges were and knew that they were competitve and take a lot of physical strength and endurance to win one. To me if you don't workout and get yourself in shape, then you aren't trying to win. I'm sorry for offending you, that wasn't my intention. I actually think you have a good body and a build that, if you did decide to workout, could be an athlete.

“I can’t weight for this season”. Oh God. I don't know if that was intentional (if it was, that’s really mean, Devyn’s not fat), if it wasn’t, hahahah I’m laughing at their poor spelling. I seem to be one of the few who loves Chet. I don’t mind seeing Sarah but I agree with tjhallow, the girls were all supposed to be close at their reunion. But then again, it’s been 4 years, so… And Sarah’s probably had it with partners that lose it for her (Shauvon twice, Katelynn, and Vinny). I don't think they have the ability to win like San Diego or Vegas, but I am still rooting for them.

Kajun;318378 wrote:
Useless as in entertainment factor which is what matters to mtv. Who cares if you make finals? Paula, I despise because she is an attention seeking loser, but I do get she has fans. I know a lot of casual fans, when I informed them Sarah was back they had no idea who she was. Besides a successful rookie story on Ruins name one thing she has contributed to the show besides being Kenny/Evan's puppet.

Exactly...It's not the fact that she's done so many...it's that she's done so many but yet adds absolutley NOTHING to any of the challenges she's done....Except plant herself firmly in JEK's ***. I also didn't like that she and Chet were badmouthing Devyn behind her back. Chet and Sarah aren't all that good either and probably didn't work out all that much themselves.

This team is like Team Hipster

Hey Devyn, I don't condone violence but could you do me a favor and kick Chet right in his c***.

Kajun;318412 wrote:
I never said Sarah is a bad competitor, she's decent she isn't so good that its fun to watch her compete. I am interested to see how she does without JEK protecting her. I just don't see her as a standout character that needs to be brought back 100x like Katie and Veronica were. It is my opinion that she sucks at life, but it is fact that she is not a dynamic personality. Hopefully she as well as the Fresh meat cast have a QUICK exit.

See Cutthroat--she doesn't need JEK on her team to make a final. The only times she hasn't made a final is with Vinny & Katelynn--shocking that she didn't. Sarah's not Evelyn, Rachel, Laurel or Emily obviously but she's solid--that's a lot better than most of the people (guys & girls) that do these. You may just be looking for drama and stuff which Sarah doesn't add a lot of but to say she adds nothing is false--just to YOU she adds nothing. I don't care about a dynamic personality at all. I care about game play only Again, I'm not in the minority. I may be in the minority of the people that post about it but not in the world. There's a reason she's back. I'm excited to see Devyn since I don't know anything about her but they have to keep bringing back some people that have done challenges. Sarah's one of those that people that those who don't watch the Real World any more have gotten used to seeing and want to watch. She's not JEK--she doesn't "control" the game so she can come back every time as far as I'm concerned.

I'm only rooting for this team because of Devyn, I had been wanting her on a challenge since her season ended.

kvm1977;318450 wrote:
See Cutthroat--see doesn't need JEK on her team to make a final The only times she hasn't made a final is with Vinny & Katelynn--shocking that she didn't Sarah's not Evelyn, Rachel, Laurel or Emily obviously but she's solid--that's a lot better than most of the people (guys & girls) that do these. You may just be looking for drama and stuff which Sarah doesn't add a lot of but to say she adds nothing is false--just to YOU she adds nothing. I don't care about a dynamic personality at all. I care about game play only Again, I'm not in the minority. I may be in the minority of the people that post about it but not in the world. There's a reason she's back. I'm excited to see Devyn since I don't know anything about her but they have to keep bringing back some people that have done challenges. Sarah's one of those that people that those who don't watch the Real World any more have gotten used to seeing and want to watch. She's not JEK--she doesn't "control" the game so she can come back every time as far as I'm concerned.

No, I have taken a poll of challenge watchers, majority dislike Sarah, others don't remember her, many are indifferent, and a very few like her.

Kajun;318469 wrote:
No, I have taken a poll of challenge watchers, majority dislike Sarah, others don't remember her, many are indifferent, and a very few like her.

LOL--I'd love to see the validity of this poll. You're being absolutely ridiculous

Oh and all the people that liked Sarah were related to her.

Kajun;318474 wrote:
Oh and all the people that liked Sarah were related to her.

LOL

Kajun;318474 wrote:
Oh and all the people that liked Sarah were related to her.

Cool story bro. Anyway, I couldn't help but cringe everytime Chet opened his mouth about Devyn. Uh, buddy, you're not exactly in CT-like shape yourself.

Gucci Mane;318489 wrote:
Cool story bro.

Thank you.

kvm1977;318317 wrote:
I don't understand the Sarah hatred at all. Chet can be annoying but maybe he was worse during his season--he wasn't awful on the Ruins or Cutthroat. Also, Sarah & Chet are better competitors than Devyn and JD--let's be real.

How would you know? This is Devyn's first challenge-let's be real.

TSPKM2;318329 wrote:
If you are tryin to win $250,000 and are completely capable athletically of doing so, but you have a person on your team, who is compeltely worthless physically and doesnt even try...you would probably talk crap on Devyn too. It is called being competitive and wanting to win. Aint no shame in that.

If Sara is so 'capable athletically' of winning, why hasn't she? Hope you have to eat your words about Devyn being worthless physically.

analogdog;318494 wrote:
If Sara is so 'capable athletically' of winning, why hasn't she? Hope you have to eat your words about Devyn being worthless physically.

Sarah's not elite but there's a long list of "capable" or even "elite" players that haven't won or needed more than 5 to win. It took Brad 8 tries to win. CT's failed 8 times, Derrick failed his first 5 times like Sarah, Aneesa still hasn't won, Diem hasn't won, Jenn hasn't won. Hell, even Emily & Laurel haven't won yet. The word "capable" means "having the ability to achieve something"--Sarah does have it. We'll see if she ever does. I have no idea what to expect from Devyn but I don't think she's going to be a liability that some are suggesting.