I love that Boston rob, this "best player ever" to a lot of causals, needed to take two complete goats to the end because he was so hated by the jury. I fully believe Ashley beats him tbh. 

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Boston rob is extremely overrated. In gameplay and entertainment. Production and causals just cream their pants anytime they see him so they edited the season to be the Boston rob show, look how amazing Rob is, 

All Stars boston rob will always be the best boston rob to me. He was basically a mob boss that entire season and it was awesome him run the game vs actual game players. One of the best games ever played  but jury management cost him.......They had to on RI!! Without him and special agent phillip shepherd there was not 1 memorable character. I for the life of me have no idea why Andrea has been asked to return over and over. She brings nothing to the table. 

When they edit the season to only show him and do everything they can to give him a win, it's easy to think he's entertaining. 

they really did have to. Just think how worse that season would be without him. It was already gutter trash. That was the worst casting job ever done by a mostly stellar casting department. The rest of the people were total duds.  It is pretty bad when Matt Elrod aka Wyatt Nash was the third most "memorable" character that season.

Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

Wendell or Domenick are definitely winning so I hope its Wendell

I love that Boston rob, this "best player ever" to a lot of causals, needed to take two complete goats to the end because he was so hated by the jury. I fully believe Ashley beats him tbh. 

I do not think he is the GOAT. But he is so overrated that he has become underrated now. He is 2 for 4 at getting to the end. He is a good player just not great. He is well rounded and has few weaknesses. The rare triple threat of a  strategic, social and physical threat.  I think the person who is the GOAT and who played the best first time game ever was Kim Spradlin. Unfortunately because she was so good that season was so damn boring and the quality suffered.

Challenge 17 wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Boston rob is extremely overrated. In gameplay and entertainment. Production and causals just cream their pants anytime they see him so they edited the season to be the Boston rob show, look how amazing Rob is, 

All Stars boston rob will always be the best boston rob to me. He was basically a mob boss that entire season and it was awesome him run the game vs actual game players. One of the best games ever played  but jury management cost him.......They had to on RI!! Without him and special agent phillip shepherd there was not 1 memorable character. I for the life of me have no idea why Andrea has been asked to return over and over. She brings nothing to the table. 

When they edit the season to only show him and do everything they can to give him a win, it's easy to think he's entertaining. 

they really did have to. Just think how worse that season would be without him. It was already gutter trash. That was the worst casting job ever done by a mostly stellar casting department. The rest of the people were total duds.  It is pretty bad when Matt Elrod aka Wyatt Nash was the third most "memorable" character that season.

You think those people would make the cast on a normal season? Honey it was clear as crystal they picked them to make Russell and Rob stand out more. Redemption island was necer supposed to be won by a newbie

I love that Boston rob, this "best player ever" to a lot of causals, needed to take two complete goats to the end because he was so hated by the jury. I fully believe Ashley beats him tbh. 

And on top of that needed 4 tries to win the ******* show. If he was so good he wouldn't need all those chances that he got...

Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

I’ve watched every season of this show and there are plenty that I just do not remember for any reason. To me that is much worse than being liked or hated. This is TV the least you could do is make me hate you so much it sticks with me 

Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

Challenge 17 wrote:

Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Rewatched Guatemala a few months ago and completely agree. The cast is full of characters and people I would like to see in a Second Chances season

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Guatemala had the worst cast on survivor ever. If that’s your middling season then Ghost Island must be Borneo/Micronesia Tier lol 

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Rewatched Guatemala a few months ago and completely agree. The cast is full of characters and people I would like to see in a Second Chances season

EDDIE! probst gave this season the shaft for no reason.  It has been a awhile since I have rewatched this season. Who would you like to see come back from it?

Danni was the reason Guatemala was middle of pack. She saved it. That's a real winner but she wasn't obnoxious in confessionals and didn't do whatever production wanted so people discredit her. 

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Guatemala had the worst cast on survivor ever. If that’s your middling season then Ghost Island must be Borneo/Micronesia Tier lol 

WOW that is a scalding hot take. How long have you been waiting to fire that one out?! Omgsh. That is the most random opinion I have ever seen someone have on survivor AND SO OUT THERE! lol We are just NEVER going to agree on anything. There is no words right now.  My tier would go 1. Cagayan 2. Pearl Islands 3. Borneo 4. HvV  5.  Amazon 6. Phillipines and 7. China. That is my top tier. I am not as high on micronesia as 99% of people. I am afraid to ask but what you got jay tea?! lol

Eddie1378 wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Rewatched Guatemala a few months ago and completely agree. The cast is full of characters and people I would like to see in a Second Chances season

EDDIE! probst game this season the shaft for no reason.  It has been a awhile since I have rewatched this season. Who would you like to see come back from it?

Judd,Jamie,Rafe,Brian,and Amy. Brandon was a fun character too

Danni was the reason Guatemala was middle of pack. She saved it. That's a real winner but she wasn't obnoxious in confessionals and didn't do whatever production wanted so people discredit her. 

Didn't her and earl cole almost come back for game changers? I remember redmond or whoever the guy is who does survivor spoilers said they were. That would of been amazing. Those are 2 of my favorite winners ever. Would of been so much better than some of the shit cast we got for game changers.

DNC_Empire wrote:

Eddie1378 wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Rewatched Guatemala a few months ago and completely agree. The cast is full of characters and people I would like to see in a Second Chances season

EDDIE! probst game this season the shaft for no reason.  It has been a awhile since I have rewatched this season. Who would you like to see come back from it?

Judd,Jamie,Rafe,Brian,and Amy. Brandon was a fun character too

YES JAMIE!!! lol. Omgsh yes his and Bobby Johns rivalry was so fun and entertaining. I dig it eddie. Thanks man! I am def going to rewatch this season soon. You gave me the motivation.

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Guatemala had the worst cast on survivor ever. If that’s your middling season then Ghost Island must be Borneo/Micronesia Tier lol 

WOW that is a scalding hot take. How long have you been waiting to fire that one out?! Omgsh. That is the most random opinion I have ever seen someone have on survivor AND SO OUT THERE! lol We are just NEVER going to agree on anything. There is no words right now.  My tier would go 1. Cagayan 2. Pearl Islands 3. Borneo 4. HvV  5.  Amazon 6. Phillipines and 7. China. That is my top tier. I am not as high on micronesia as 99% of people. I am afraid to ask but what you got jay tea?! lol

it’s funny we actually agree on a bit of the top I’d say mine goes 1. Borneo 2. Micronesia 3. HvV 4. Cagayan 5. Amazon 6. Cambodia 7. Pearl Islands 

Cagayan is still one of the best seasons with a 100% new cast 

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Guatemala had the worst cast on survivor ever. If that’s your middling season then Ghost Island must be Borneo/Micronesia Tier lol 

WOW that is a scalding hot take. How long have you been waiting to fire that one out?! Omgsh. That is the most random opinion I have ever seen someone have on survivor AND SO OUT THERE! lol We are just NEVER going to agree on anything. There is no words right now.  My tier would go 1. Cagayan 2. Pearl Islands 3. Borneo 4. HvV  5.  Amazon 6. Phillipines and 7. China. That is my top tier. I am not as high on micronesia as 99% of people. I am afraid to ask but what you got jay tea?! lol

it’s funny we actually agree on a bit of the top I’d say mine goes 1. Borneo 2. Micronesia 3. HvH 4. Cagayan 5. Amazon 6. Cambodia 7. Pearl Islands Cagayan is still one of the best seasons with a 100% new cast 

Tony Vlachos is a national treasure. To me he is the most fun survivor winner ever. What did you love about micro so much? 

Ugh Tony speaking of overrated, but I've done enough rants about how Trish should have won instead to start on that can of worms 

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Guatemala had the worst cast on survivor ever. If that’s your middling season then Ghost Island must be Borneo/Micronesia Tier lol 

WOW that is a scalding hot take. How long have you been waiting to fire that one out?! Omgsh. That is the most random opinion I have ever seen someone have on survivor AND SO OUT THERE! lol We are just NEVER going to agree on anything. There is no words right now.  My tier would go 1. Cagayan 2. Pearl Islands 3. Borneo 4. HvV  5.  Amazon 6. Phillipines and 7. China. That is my top tier. I am not as high on micronesia as 99% of people. I am afraid to ask but what you got jay tea?! lol

it’s funny we actually agree on a bit of the top I’d say mine goes 1. Borneo 2. Micronesia 3. HvH 4. Cagayan 5. Amazon 6. Cambodia 7. Pearl Islands Cagayan is still one of the best seasons with a 100% new cast 

Tony Vlachos is a national treasure. To me he is the most fun survivor winner ever. What did you love about micro so much? 

I think it was just well casted, the favorites had a good mix of good guys and bad guys, quality blindsides, good strategy

an overall top season from beginning to end 

Ugh Tony speaking of overrated, but I've done enough rants about how Trish should have won instead to start on that can of worms 

Trish will have her chance. She will be back. Perfect candidate for second chances 2.

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

JayTea wrote:

DNC_Empire wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Thailand was worse, the fake merge, the least likeable final 5 ever, the forgotten season for very good reason

lol guatemala says hold my beer on being the forgotten season. No new player has ever returned from that season. I do not get it. I mean it was not a bad season at all. Not great but middle of the pack. Solid season. 

DNC you can not be serious...Guatemala?? Rafe on rope obstacles is the only takeaway from that season. We might be on here disagreeing forever lol

I WOULD LOVE rafe to come back. He has more merit to come back than frickin wentworth and others who have! THAT is a middling season. Not ghost island which is down right detestable lol. Shoot I would of loved Judd, Gary and Rafe to of come back off the top of my head from guatemala. It certainly looks like it.

Guatemala had the worst cast on survivor ever. If that’s your middling season then Ghost Island must be Borneo/Micronesia Tier lol 

WOW that is a scalding hot take. How long have you been waiting to fire that one out?! Omgsh. That is the most random opinion I have ever seen someone have on survivor AND SO OUT THERE! lol We are just NEVER going to agree on anything. There is no words right now.  My tier would go 1. Cagayan 2. Pearl Islands 3. Borneo 4. HvV  5.  Amazon 6. Phillipines and 7. China. That is my top tier. I am not as high on micronesia as 99% of people. I am afraid to ask but what you got jay tea?! lol

it’s funny we actually agree on a bit of the top I’d say mine goes 1. Borneo 2. Micronesia 3. HvH 4. Cagayan 5. Amazon 6. Cambodia 7. Pearl Islands Cagayan is still one of the best seasons with a 100% new cast 

Tony Vlachos is a national treasure. To me he is the most fun survivor winner ever. What did you love about micro so much? 

I think it was just well casted, the favorites had a good mix of good guys and bad guys, quality blindsides, good strategyan overall top season from beginning to end 

I think it just rubbed me the wrong way because 2 of my favorites Penner and James had to be med evac'd and the other one Yau Man went out REALLY early. But yah I cannot lie what you said is all true. You made some good points. Though the fans are never that great or memorable on these seasons. but At least the fans on micro were sooooooooo much better than FvF2. yuuuuuuuuuuuck. 

CBS must be paying TMZ for advertising bc they have posted multiple stories about Survivor and the Amazing Race/Big Brother in the last few days.

this saga continues:

http://www.tmz.com/2018/05/17/survivor-contestant-punished-breaking-nda-contract-spoiler/

Alec has been stripped of his $10,000 apperance fee and has been banned from the reunion. 

He was probably irrelevant and she’s an icon which is why she wasn’t punished. 

Oop

He was probably irrelevant and she’s an icon which is why she wasn’t punished. 

That's what I was thinkin, she must have had a bigger impact