Behind the Screen: The Challenge: Shouldn't/Should Have Been in Final

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Challenge 17wrote:schaboszczakwrote:ibeedevinyowrote:schaboszczakwrote:Challenge 17wrote:schaboszczakwrote:ibeedevinyowrote:I think Nany 100% deserved the Free Agents final. she won the most daily cha...

— Challenge 17

Tonya over Sophia BoSexes2Rachel over Arissa BoSexes2Julie over Jamie Inferno 2Jillian over Ibis Gauntlet 2Derrick/Diem over Tina/Kenny FM2Beth over Svetlana Duel 1Melinda over Rachel Gauntlet 3KellyA...

— Lola88

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: Shouldn't/Should Have Been in Final with 20 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: Shouldn't/Should Have Been in Final

Challenge 17 ·
Challenge 17 wrote:

schaboszczak wrote:

ibeedevinyo wrote:
schaboszczak wrote:
Challenge 17 wrote:
schaboszczak wrote:
ibeedevinyo wrote:I think Nany 100% deserved the Free Agents final....she won the most daily challenges out of anyone that season which, if you didn't know, is the goal of the show lmao. Ms. Fail was always crying in deliberation hoping she didn't get voted in....

Jessica won same amount of mission in FA as Nany. And she was for shorter period. Where is final for Jessica Im asking?

again with this crap, Jessica barley did shit in the missions she won. 

 And what spectacular Nany did during missions?

 well in the giant soccer mission, her and Laurel trapped Issaac . In the wall one above water, she was the only girl to help move the pegs. in the one she won with Theresa she got knocked down and got a concussion and still went on to get back up and win. in the one where they had to hang off the ground she was the first one to be placed and never fell. 

LOLdidn't Jonna and Laurel moved the pegs too? And Jess won that mission  :*ok...omg she can hold a rope... ya know, she was sitting there. It wasn't hard to hang there. 

jess won by doing nothing..... nany completely out preformed jess in the tbone type challenge. Jessica's freeagenrs performance is completely overrated.  Aside from the first mission she barley did anything to help her teams win. She literally just got lucky. 

i guess she did something... like she won over nany, laurel and other females. OK she outperformed her in this and what? Jess' performance is similar to nany's. And FA were 50%  about luck. Nany got lucky too. ***** never pulled a kill card.

the huge difference is Nany won 2 partner missions which is better than being a irrelevant person on a team barley doing anything like pretty much all of Jessica's wins.  

20 Comments
Challenge 17#392
Challenge 17 wrote:

schaboszczak wrote:

ibeedevinyo wrote:
schaboszczak wrote:
Challenge 17 wrote:
schaboszczak wrote:
ibeedevinyo wrote:I think Nany 100% deserved the Free Agents final....she won the most daily challenges out of anyone that season which, if you didn't know, is the goal of the show lmao. Ms. Fail was always crying in deliberation hoping she didn't get voted in....

Jessica won same amount of mission in FA as Nany. And she was for shorter period. Where is final for Jessica Im asking?

again with this crap, Jessica barley did shit in the missions she won. 

 And what spectacular Nany did during missions?

 well in the giant soccer mission, her and Laurel trapped Issaac . In the wall one above water, she was the only girl to help move the pegs. in the one she won with Theresa she got knocked down and got a concussion and still went on to get back up and win. in the one where they had to hang off the ground she was the first one to be placed and never fell. 

LOLdidn't Jonna and Laurel moved the pegs too? And Jess won that mission  :*ok...omg she can hold a rope... ya know, she was sitting there. It wasn't hard to hang there. 

jess won by doing nothing..... nany completely out preformed jess in the tbone type challenge. Jessica's freeagenrs performance is completely overrated.  Aside from the first mission she barley did anything to help her teams win. She literally just got lucky. 

i guess she did something... like she won over nany, laurel and other females. OK she outperformed her in this and what? Jess' performance is similar to nany's. And FA were 50%  about luck. Nany got lucky too. ***** never pulled a kill card.

the huge difference is Nany won 2 partner missions which is better than being a irrelevant person on a team barley doing anything like pretty much all of Jessica's wins.  

Lola88#393

Tonya over Sophia BoSexes2

Rachel over Arissa BoSexes2

Julie over Jamie Inferno 2

Jillian over Ibis Gauntlet 2

Derrick/Diem over Tina/Kenny FM2

Beth over Svetlana Duel 1

Melinda over Rachel Gauntlet 3

KellyAnne over Ryan Island

Diem over Brittani Duel 2

Evelyn/Luke over Jenn/Noor FM2

Wes/Mandi over Jillian/Pete FM2

Paula over Tori Cutthroat

Rob/Marie over JD/Devyn BoSeasons2

Theresa over Devyn FA

Camila over Nany FA

hardbitten#394

Free Agents Finale should have been:

CTZachBananas

LaurelTheresaCara Maria

Battle of the Exes 2 Finale should have been:

Jordan/SarahLeroy/NiaWes/Theresa

Bloodlines Finale should have been:

Cory/MitchCara Maria/JamieAneesa/Rianna

Oblivion#395

Eric Nies shouldn't have been in the final of Battle of the Sexes 2. Dan, Theo, Mark, Brad and Steven (who was kicked off the season) all outperformed him overall in the missions.

boncat23#396

CT/Adam on Rivals I. 

kvm1977#397
Tonya over Sophia BoSexes2Rachel over Arissa BoSexes2Julie over Jamie Inferno 2Jillian over Ibis Gauntlet 2Derrick/Diem over Tina/Kenny FM2Beth over Svetlana Duel 1Melinda over Rachel Gauntlet 3KellyAnne over Ryan IslandDiem over Brittani Duel 2Evelyn/Luke over Jenn/Noor FM2Wes/Mandi over Jillian/Pete FM2Paula over Tori CutthroatRob/Marie over JD/Devyn BoSeasons2Theresa over Devyn FACamila over Nany FA  

Ummm--Brittini beat Diem head to head and outperformed her all season

kvm1977#398
Free Agents Finale should have been:CTZachBananasLaurelTheresaCara MariaBattle of the Exes 2 Finale should have been:Jordan/SarahLeroy/NiaWes/TheresaBloodlines Finale should have been:Cory/MitchCara Maria/JamieAneesa/Rianna

This I agree with--at least, this is what would have been best as a viewer

Challenge 17#399
Lola88 wrote:

Tonya over Sophia BoSexes2Rachel over Arissa BoSexes2Julie over Jamie Inferno 2Jillian over Ibis Gauntlet 2Derrick/Diem over Tina/Kenny FM2Beth over Svetlana Duel 1Melinda over Rachel Gauntlet 3KellyAnne over Ryan IslandDiem over Brittani Duel 2Evelyn/Luke over Jenn/Noor FM2Wes/Mandi over Jillian/Pete FM2Paula over Tori CutthroatRob/Marie over JD/Devyn BoSeasons2Theresa over Devyn FACamila over Nany FA  

Ummm--Brittini beat Diem head to head and outperformed her all season

not just Diem,  hell Brittini out performed Rachel at times.

v123#400

Brittani only outperformed Rachel once by a hair. The rest of the times it was all Landon. Rachel was the best girl there 

El Scorcho#401
Free Agents Finale should have been:CTZachBananasLaurelTheresaCara MariaBattle of the Exes 2 Finale should have been:Jordan/SarahLeroy/NiaWes/TheresaBloodlines Finale should have been:Cory/MitchCara Maria/JamieAneesa/Rianna

Free Agents. YES!Exes 2. YES!Bloodlines. NO!

El Scorcho#402

Danny over Eric on The Gauntlet III

JayTee#403
Free Agents Finale should have been:CTZachBananasLaurelTheresaCara MariaBattle of the Exes 2 Finale should have been:Jordan/SarahLeroy/NiaWes/TheresaBloodlines Finale should have been:Cory/MitchCara Maria/JamieBananas/Vince
hawks08#404

My picks

Inferno: Honestly unsure about this but I think Mallory could have had the chance at the finals or Real World team could have been all dudes in the finals. Coral talked to Julie and Mallory about volunteering because she knew she was screwed if it was her and Leah for the Inferno. Mallory volunteered then change her mind and her and Julie wanted a vote. Then David who yelled at the ladies to step up which I think was disrespectful. Ultimately Mallory change her mind again to volunteer. Road Rules should have voted in Coral not Mallory.

Gauntlet 2: I agree it should have been Jillian and not Ibis though unsure if would have been different if the team voted as opposed Kina voting. The Guys minus Randy (who was dating Kina) would have voted for Ibis. Ladies minus Jillian probably would have voted in Jillian (I know Susie and Ibis for sure) Jodi would have supported her friend. Alton might have been the wildcard because would he do what's best for the team or his fellow team Captain (Kina).

Cutthroat: Believe or not I think Camila should have at least outlast Paula and maybe made it to the finals and winning it.  Granted Camila made a rookie mistake in telling Brad she voted for him but him and Tori I think took it a little too personally plus Camila hanging out Bananas didn't help either. I like Brad and I like Tori but I strongly disagree in senting in Camila into the Gulag especially for personal BS.

hawks08#405
Danny over Eric on The Gauntlet III

I thought Eric was safe because I think the rookies picked Eric to be safe in the final mission. Now Banana over Eric I agree with.

AlwaysAMess#406

The female side for the Rivals 1 final would have been the best competitively had it been

Evelyn & Paula

Laurel & Cara Maria

Camila & Theresa

Debut Album#407
The female side for the Rivals 1 final would have been the best competitively had it beenEvelyn & PaulaLaurel & Cara MariaCamila & Theresa

A bunch of Non-castmembers and Paula? No thanks.

AlwaysAMess#408
AlwaysAMess wrote:

The female side for the Rivals 1 final would have been the best competitively had it beenEvelyn & PaulaLaurel & Cara MariaCamila & Theresa

A bunch of Non-castmembers and Paula? No thanks.

It's not like the original final 3 teams had any other non-Fresh Meat girls besides Jenn. But I know you're trolling with your non-castmember crap, so I'll just ignore it.

Daddy DAF#409
El Scorcho wrote:

Danny over Eric on The Gauntlet III

 I thought Eric was safe because I think the rookies picked Eric to be safe in the final mission. Now Banana over Eric I agree with.

yeah rookies were protecting eric at that point. and they had a chance to throw big sleazy into elimination and threw backpack in there instead. good job evan!

Challenge 17#410
hawks08 wrote:

El Scorcho wrote:Danny over Eric on The Gauntlet III

 I thought Eric was safe because I think the rookies picked Eric to be safe in the final mission. Now Banana over Eric I agree with.

yeah rookies were protecting eric at that point. and they had a chance to throw big sleazy into elimination and threw backpack in there instead. good job evan!

they didn't want to risk losing Evan incase it was something like reverse tug of war where you could be a lot stronger but that wouldn't matter 

rwportland2#411

Ruthie/Robin/Tina over Arissa on Sexes 2

Brad over Jump Rope on Sexes 2

Derrick over David on The Gauntlet 2

Johnny over Easy on Gauntlet 3

Camila over Tori on Cutthroat

Jasmine/Jonna over Jenn/Mandi on Rivals

Vegas having a full team over Brooklyn on Seasons 2

Cara Maria over Devyn on Free Agents

Wes/Theresa over Jay/Jenna on Exes 2

Mike/Abram over Jenna/Brianna on Bloodlines

Related Topics

The ChallengeElimination Spoilers