Most Satisfying/Dissapointing Challenge Winners

CT probably would have gassed out just like Zach did? they have really similar builds and CT did gas out on Exes 1...

And if backpack had been in the lead and had to plow the path up that mountain for the others to use like CT did, HE would have gased out.

you missed the point. zach gassed out on FA and his explanation was something like "I have way more muscles and couldn't get oxygen to all of them at that altitude" Well... CT is built pretty much exactly the same, so he would have had a similar or the same problem. Johnny would have still won FA 

I wouldnt say that beacuse you cant really judge someone performance on how they did 2 or 3 seasons ago . Everytime they come back they do better and better . Backpack was no where near the shape he was during rivals 2 . Alot of people thought he was losing it . But then he came back and did good on free agents.

You mean he was carried by his alliance . He was like jay and jenna . If the game turned on him at any point he would have been sent home. He didnt get to the final on his own game. Just saying all he did great really was hooking up with nany and not picking a draw card

He was no where near Jay/Jenna...People specifically kept them around because they knew they would beat them. No one kept him around because they thought they would beat him in the final. I don't see how his alliance carried him in anyway when he won a challenge and was on the winning team numerous times. 

Johnny R is a good competitor, he proved that going up against Leroy. He put up  a fight to a dude who is a beast at eliminations.

not really he lost in perhaps 30 minutes approx. in that type of elimination where you have to attack the back of someone it would be hard to beat anyoone faster than say 20-30 minutes.

now i will say Avery put up a fight against Nia.

Most Satisfying Recent Challenges:

3) The Ruins: The outcome actually sucked. But all things considered, KellyAnne and Sarah were super impressive in the final, and it was one of the best set up finals and a true nail-biter. I actually really like the format too, if the teams weren't so lop-sided. If KA and Sarah would've pulled of the win, it would've been the greatest Challenge upset ever. Even though they lost, it was still really entertaining watching them come so close.

2) Battle of the Bloodlines: First off, like Ruins, this season was a disaster. The format was random, because apparently they figured out pairs wasn't gonna work when you have male/male pairs and female/female pairs (duh), so they kept switching it up. The eliminations were weird and a lot of them didn't require any skill. I'll probably get some hate for this, but I actually like Cara Maria. Seeing her Challenge history start so rough with FMII and Cutthroat to her actually getting a backbone and becoming a force to be reckoned with, I think she deserved this. And for the first time in as long as I could remember, I actually liked everyone in the final. Jenna/Bri performed really well until day 2, which was surprising.

1) Fresh Meat 2: It's been said before, but Landon pulling off the W here is probably the single most impressive thing in Challenge history. And after being robbed by Brad on Duel 2, this was a nice redemption win that he definitely earned.

Least Satisfying Recent Challenges:

3) Rivals: I think this was the first season with "2 day finals", which I'm still not a fan of. But on top of the two day final, the lead from the first day was diminished to like 5 minutes. I get that they want it to be close for the drama, but Kenny/Wes were like an hour ahead, and to have that taken away was highway robbery.

2) Cutthroat: Loved this format, however, seeing Brad, Tori, and Dunbar walk away with a win really, really sucked when they didn't do anything, and they screwed over Brandon, Camila, and Paula in the process. I already disliked Brad because of the Duel 2 and Ruins, but then on Cutthroat he was annoying as shit with Tori, and officially has no balls anymore.

1) Rivals III: Everyone knows why this sucks. Bananas handed a win with an amazing partner in a season full of scrub teams, and on top of it, production decides to give him the option to royally **** Sarah for "revenge". Did it cause a stir? Sure. But it just made it so much more obvious how much they cater to this guy.

Kenny/Wes whether we like to admit it or not, got absolutely screwed on that final.

Most satisfying:

1.) Fresh Meat 2 - Still the most satisfying win because Landon is such a great competitor and great guy. Plus I hated Kenny and Laurel and it would have been so boring if they won it all. The most impressive challenge win ever. I want to see Backpack have to carry a partner like that. 

2.) The Inferno 3 - Derrick's first win. Always was a Derrick fan and it was great finally seeing him win one. I actually found the Bad ***** more tolerable that season than the Good Guys too. 

3.) Rivals 2 - CT's first win and it was great seeing Backpack's two biggest rivals beat him. Plus Frank was annoying to me too.

Least satisfying:

1.) Rivals 3 - Hate Backpack and Sarah and they had no competition all season. And the twist just made it so much worse. Unfortunately that moment got a lot of buzz online so it gives MTV an excuse to bring that nonsense back for another challenge. 

2.) The Ruins - JEK + Susie. All terrible people to root for. 

3.) Evan (The Duel 2) - Evan is a horrible person and it sucked seeing him win over Landon and Brad.

Honorable mention - Cutthroat: Tyler was the only one I was happy for, but Brad, Tori, and Dunbar were all awful people and useless.

Most Satisfying Challenge Winers.

Challenge 2000

Both Battle of the Sexes Seasons.

Gauntlet 1 and The Inferno 1

The Inferno 2 and Gauntlet 2

Fresh Meat 2

Battle of the Exes 2.

Most Disapointing Winners.

The Duel 1 and 2

Cuttthroat

Rivals 1

Battle of The Seasons 2

Rivals 2

Bloodlines

Rivals 3

Most Satisfying Wins:

Exes II

Fresh Meat II

Duel II  (Rachel)

Most Disappointing Wins:

Rivals III

Free Agents (Bananas)

Seasons 2

Exes 1

Rivals 1

Cutthroat 

Ruins

Most Satisfying Wins:

Exes II

Fresh Meat II

Duel II  (Rachel)

Most Disappointing Wins:

Rivals III

Free Agents (Bananas)

Seasons 2

Exes 1

Rivals 1

Cutthroat 

Ruins

I will only include Inferno II forward

Most Satisfying

1. Inferno 2 - SQUAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAD

2. Rivals II - Seeing CT finally get that win was great and long overdue

3. The Duel - Overall a terrific finale, and Wes deserved it the moment be beat Derrick K.

Most Disappointing

1. Rivals III - **** everything about that season

2. The Ruins - terrible just ******* terrible

3. Cutthroat - I love everything about this season except who won it.

Most satisfying challenge wins for me

1-  Duel 1 - Wes/Jodi

2- Inferno II - Good guys (Mike/Landon/Jamie/Darrell

3-FM2 -  Landon/Carley (i was also rooting for Kenny/Laurel)

Most dissapoiting

1- Rivals 1 - Johnny/Tyler AND Paula/Ev (was rooting for Kenny/Wes or Mike/Leroy)

2- Rivals 2 - Paula/Emily (if only CM wouldnt have cost Cooke that win) 

3- Cutthroat - red team sucked and i wanted the Grey team to win after what red did to Brandon/Camila

4-Rivals 3 - ******* predictable and honestly sucked

5-Gauntlet 2 - shitty final (but at least Alton,Landon and Jodi got that W )

6-Island was this even a race? lol

7-Exes 1 - really wanted CT/Diem to win that

8-Seasons 2 - hated seeing San Diego ********** get the W 

Basically the last wins i actually enjoyed were from a decade ago lol (FM2 - 2006) the rest of the winners are either "villains" or "Meh" winners like Sarah/Jordan on Exes 2 and CM on Bloodlines.

Glad I'm not the only one that loves the Inferno 2 Good Guys final team. Had Brad been part of that group too, it would have been everything!

Glad I'm not the only one that loves the Inferno 2 Good Guys final team. Had Brad been part of that group too, it would have been everything!

Yeah i guess if he did won that one i dont think we would have miserable/shady Brad on Ruins 2/Cutthroat trying so hard to get his win :/ 

Most Satisfying:

1. Inferno 2

2. Fresh Meat 2

3. Rivals 2

Least Satisfying:

1. Battle of the Exes

2. The Ruins

3. The Island

Glad I'm not the only one that loves the Inferno 2 Good Guys final team. Had Brad been part of that group too, it would have been everything!

 a lot of people like that win. 

Most Satisfying:

1. Battle of the Exes: Fantastic final, close finish

2. Free Agents: Bananas really earned this one, Laurel's first win

3. Rivals 2: Hated this final, wasn't a big fan of the season but CT's first win was awesome to see.

Least Satisfying:

1. Cutthroat: My favorite format they've done, but cannot stand that the Red Team won.

2. Battle of the Exes 2: Really wanted to see Leroy win.

3. Gauntlet 3: Was really rooting for CT, Brad and Kenny, I only liked Jillian on the rookies.. Would have seen Diem win a challenge. In the end, it was their fault for keeping Easy around. Crazy to think if Evan called Easy into the Gauntlet, Evan would have easily won in sliders because the whole team was helping him. I know there was no way of knowing which game would have been played but it would have played out that way in the end.