Behind the Screen: The Island II Fantasy/Discussion

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

It would get the series cancelled...

— Klounsnax2.0

It would get the series cancelled...

— InterFan

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Island II Fantasy/Discussion with 11 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Island II Fantasy/Discussion

ChallengeFan.402 ·

We got a tiny glimpse of how some of the newer  cast would be in an "Island-like" situation during The Invasion...

But how would you picture a new season of The Island going? Who do you think would be a good cast selection and just your general thoughts. Maybe who you think would quit because of the surroundings and limited supplies?

My own opinion: I think Ashley would quit, after seeing her throw a fit on Invasion over the toilet seat, and that was after they were already in the oasis. Sure there were other things that led up to that fit but I can imagine it being worse on The Island.

11 Comments
Klounsnax2.0#2

It would get the series cancelled. Goodbye.

InterFan#3
It would get the series cancelled. Goodbye.
kvm1977#4

Where to start...they need to focus on making concentrate on making condition better not worse.  They should want to entice people to come back.  Lots of people would quit.

hardbitten#5
It would get the series cancelled. Goodbye.
White Skull#6

Drop off Johnny, leave him, never return.

Hotboiswag#7

Isnt there already a thread for this

Kryptic241#8

10 Guys

Bananas, Cory, Dunbar, Tyrie, Nelson, Tony, Dario, Leroy, Jamie Banks, Vince 

10 Girls

Laurel, Camila, Cara Maria, Latoya, Jenna, Simone, Sarah Rice, Anessa, Ashley K, Christina L

Is probably the only entertaining group that wouldn't get the Island 2 cancelled. Maybe switch Dunbar and Tyrie for Hunter and another Nelson if dunbar/tyrie are too old school. 

badladjj#9

Dunbar and Tyrie......

Likeeeeee who even remembers those two?

Kryptic241#10
Dunbar and Tyrie......Likeeeeee who even remembers those two?

Real fans of the show. 

Tyie is one of the most OVER rated fan favorites i've ever seen. Look at his track record.

1st eliminated on Inferno 3, Quit Gauntlet 3, Voted off the island after Bananas called him out, Sent home 1st with the guys with Davis, Sent home by Rachel and Anessa on Exes, Sent home first with Dunbar. And his memories include getting ****** on after passing out with **** in his butt on the toilet, making out with Jasmine, being out for sleeping with his sneakers on by Kenny and crying that Dunbar got more meat than him. 

kvm1977#11
Dunbar and Tyrie......Likeeeeee who even remembers those two?

Stop playing dumb--we know you remember both

Kryptic241#12
badladjj wrote:

Dunbar and Tyrie......Likeeeeee who even remembers those two?

Stop playing dumb--we know you remember both

I had him...  I had him....

Dunbar: If there was TWO Tyrie's he would have lost twice as fast. 

Related Topics

The ChallengeGeneral DiscussionCast Spoilers