Behind the Screen: The Challenge: Battle Of The Eras - Season 40 (Spoilers

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

AlternatesEra 1 (1-10)Ruthie AlcaideSyrusEra 2 (11-20)Big Easy (The Challenge: Fresh Meat)Carley Johnson (The Challenge: Fresh Meat 2)Era 3 (21-30)Derrick Henry (Are You The One. )Jasmine Reynaud (The...

— PinkRose

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: Battle Of The Eras - Season 40 (Spoilers) with 25 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: Battle Of The Eras - Season 40 (Spoilers)

PinkRose ·

Season: 40

Departure: Saturday March 9th

Location: Vietnam

Theme: "Best of the best" from different Eras

1st Place: $400k each 2nd Place: $75k each 3rd Place: $25k each

Spoiler Duscussion Thread: https://vevmo.com/forums/challenge-season-40-spoilers-discussion

Host: TJ Lavin

Season: 40

Cast 

Era 1 (Season 1-10) - Navy Blue

Aneesa Ferreira (The Real World: Chicago)

Brad Fiorenza (The Real World: San Diego)
Christopher “CT” Tamburello (The Real World: Paris)
Darrell Taylor (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)
Derrick Kosinski (Road Rules: Extreme)
Jodi Weatherton (Road Rules: Extreme)
Katie Cooley (Road Rules: The Quest)
Mark Long (Road Rules: First Adventure)
Rachel Robinson (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)
Tina Bridge (Road Rules: South Pacific)

Era 2  (Season 11-20)- Army Green

Aviv Melmed (The Challenge: Fresh Meat)

Brandon Nelson (The Challenge: Fresh Meat 2)
Cara Maria Sorbello (The Challenge:Fresh Meat 2)
Derek Chavez (The Real World: Cancun)
Emily Schromm (The Real World: DC)
John “Johnny Bananas” Devenanzio (The Real World: Paris)
Kellyanne Jude (The Real World: Sydney)
Laurel Stucky (The Challenge: Fresh Meat 2)
Nehemiah Clark (The Real World: Austin)
Ryan Kehoe (The Challenge: Fresh Meat)

Era 3 (Season 21-30)- Baby Blue

Amanda Garcia (Are You The One?)

Averey Tressler (The Real World:Portland)
Cory Wharton (The Real World: Explosion)
Devin Walker (Are You  The One?) 
Jonna Mannion (The Real World: Cancun)
Jordan Wiseley (The Real World: Portland)
Leroy Garret (The Real World: Las Vegas 2)
Nia Moore (The Real World: Portland)
Tony Raines (The Real World: Skeletons)
Tori Deal (Are You The One?)

Era 4 ( Season 31- Current) - Hot Pink

Horacio Gutierrez (Exatlon USA Telemundo)

Jenny West (Survival of the Fittest UK)
Josh Martinez (Big Brother)
Kaycee Clark (Big Brother)
Kyland Young (Big Brother)
Michele Fitzgerald (Survivor)
Nurys Mateo (Are You The One?)
Olivia Kaiser (Love Island US)
Paul Calafiore (Big Brother)
Theo Campbell (Love Island UK)

Note: I will be updating this thread as more information becomes available. Moving and removing people in case they are alternates or drop.

25 Comments
PinkRose#2

Alternates

Era 1 (1-10)

Ruthie Alcaide

Syrus

Era 2 (11-20)

Big Easy (The Challenge: Fresh Meat)

Carley Johnson (The Challenge: Fresh Meat 2)

Era 3 (21-30)

Derrick Henry (Are You The One?)

Jasmine Reynaud (The Real World: Cancun)

Jay Mitchell (The Real World: Explosion) 

Era 4 (31- Current)

Big T (ShipwreckedUK)

Faysal "Fessy" Shafaat (Big Brother)

PinkRose#3

 If you don't want to read any possible elimination spoilers don't read below this post:

PinkRose#4

Jordan Wiseley joins The Challenge cast as the 40th member, a week after departure day, due to having a race.

Initial format

In the first challenge of the season, each team competed separately to determine which 8 people from each era would advance to the next round of the game to play as a team. The 2 people from each gender that finished last in each era was sent directly to elimination, while the ones from each gender that finished first got to choose their opponent. The ones going into elimination had to pick between Kill cards to decide which elimination set up they were going to do. Each elimination represented a different era.

- Teams portion: The elimination winner chooses who the targets are from each era two from each. The winning team’s targets are captains, and the losing team’s targets go straight to elimination. The winning team captains then vote a pair from one of the 2 remaining eras to go into elimination

- Individual portion: Once the game became individual, the last place goes into elimination, and the person who wins gets to pick between the people that the last elimination winner targeted.

-  Karma points (Advantage for the final):

On the first day, TJ advised the cast to make friends since it can be helpful later on. Every eliminated player awards karma points to every remaining player in the game, with the lowest being 1 and the highest being 5. The final contestants' karma points will be tallied up at the end of the game for advantages.

Last place on each Era:

Era 1- Mark & Katie 

Era 2- Ryan & Kelly Anne 

Era 3- Leroy & Nia

Era 4- Theo & Nurys

Voted In:

Era 1- CT & Rachel voted in Aneesa & Derrick 

Era 2- Johnny Bananas & Laurel voted in Brandon & Cara Maria

Era 3- Cory & Tori voted in Amanda & Tony

Era 4- Horacio & Michele voted in Paulie & Olivia

Elimination Matchups

Nurys Mateo eliminated by Olivia Kaiser in Hall Brawl

Paul Califiore eliminated by Theo Campbell in Hall Brawl

Amanda garcia eliminated by Nia Moore (Balls in)

Leroy Garret eliminated by Tony Raines (Balls in)

Katie Cooley eliminated by Aneesa Ferreira (Pole Wrestle)

Mark Long eliminated by Derrick Konsinski (Pole Wrestle)

Kellyanne Judd eliminated by Cara Maria Sorbello (Knot so Fast)

Brandon Nelson eliminated by Ryan Kehoe (Knot so fast)

Jodi Weatherton eliminated by Averey Tressler 

Tony Raines eliminated by Darrell Taylor 

Horacio Gutierrez eliminated by Derrick Konsinski 

Aneesa Ferreira eliminated by Jenny West

Emily Schromm eliminated by Tina Barta

CT Tamburello eliminated by Nehemiah Clark

Brad Fiorenza eliminated by Cory Wharton

Jonna eliminated by Rachel Robinson

Darrell Taylor eliminated by Kyland Young

Derrick Kosinski eliminated by Cory Wharton 

Tina Barta eliminated by Michelle Fitzgerald

Averey Tressler eliminated by Rachel Robinson

Kaycee Clark eliminated by Tori Deal

Devin Walker eliminated by Kyland Young

Ryan Kehoe eliminated by Johnny Bannanas

Nia Moore eliminated by Michele Fitzgerald

Laurel/Nehemiah purged out

Theo Campbell eliminated by Johnny bananas

Olivia Kaiser eliminated by Michelle Fitzgerald

Josh Martínez eliminated by Cory Wharton

Aviv Melmed eliminated by Jenny West

Cory Wharton eliminated by Derek Chavez

Cara Maria Sorbello eliminated by Tori Deal

PinkRose#5

People Eliminated or DQ

- Brandon Nelson

- Nurys Mateos

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#6

People Eliminated or DQ

- Brandon Nelson

- Paulie Calafiore

- Mark Long

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#7

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#8

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#9

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#10

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#11

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

- Jonna Mannion

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#12

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 - Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#13

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 - Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#14

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 - Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#15

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#16

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

- Nia Moore

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#17

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

- Nia Moore

- Laurel Stucky 

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#18

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nehemiah Clark

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

- Nia Moore

- Laurel Stucky

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#19

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nehemiah Clark

- Theo Campbell

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

- Nia Moore

- Laurel Stucky

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#20

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nehemiah Clark

- Theo Campbell

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

- Nia Moore

- Laurel Stucky

- Olivia Kaiser

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#21

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nehemiah Clark

- Theo Campbell

- Josh Martinez

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

- Nia Moore

- Laurel Stucky

- Olivia Kaiser

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#22

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nehemiah Clark

- Theo Campbell

- Josh Martinez

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

- Nia Moore

- Laurel Stucky

- Olivia Kaiser

- Aviv Melmed

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#23

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nehemiah Clark

- Theo Campbell

- Josh Martinez

- Cory Wharton

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

- Nia Moore

- Laurel Stucky

- Olivia Kaiser

- Aviv Melmed

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#24

People Eliminated or DQ

- Paulie Calafiore

- Brandon Nelson

- Marks Long

- Leroy Garret

- Tony Raines

- Horacio Gutierrez

- CT Tamburello

- Brad Fiorenza

- Darrell Taylor

- Derrick Kosinski

- Devin Walker

- Ryan Kehoe

- Nehemiah Clark

- Theo Campbell

- Josh Martinez

- Cory Wharton

- Nurys Mateos 

- Katie Cooley

- Kellyanne Judd

- Amanda Garcia

- Jodi Weatherton  

- Aneesa Ferreira

- Emily Schromm

 -Jonna Mannion

- Tina Barta

- Averey Tressler

- Kaycee Clark

- Nia Moore

- Laurel Stucky

- Olivia Kaiser

- Aviv Melmed

- Cara Maria Sorbello

DISCLAIMER: This is not an official order of who has been sent home, merely an observation based on social network activity & spotting. THIS LIST IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AS MORE INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE

PinkRose#25

Final Location: Singapore 

Final 4 Guys:
Final 4 Girls:
PinkRose#26

Males

Fourth Place: Kyland Young

Third Place: Johnny Bananas

Second Place: Derek Chavez

First Place: Jordan Wiseley

Females

Fourth Place/Third Place: TBA Tori Deal 

Third Place/Second Place? TBA: Michele Fitzgerald

Update: Due to their Karma points, Rachel and Jenny are tied on first place. I'm unsure if they will split the first place money or what will happen to break the tie at the reunion.

First/Second Place? : Rachel Robinson & Jenny West -TBA

Related Topics

The ChallengeCast SpoilersElimination Spoilers