Behind the Screen: Challenge Rookie Prospects

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

I was actually referring to the comment that mentioned how the BGC girls were deemed a liability, the comment above my post, and how I thought that was a bs ruling by production. I specifically refere...

— GoldenRing

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about Challenge Rookie Prospects with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

Challenge Rookie Prospects

GoldenRing ·

I was actually referring to the comment that mentioned how the BGC girls were deemed a liability, the comment above my post, and how I thought that was a bs ruling by production.

I specifically referenced two BGC girls, Angela and Janelle, which is also why I brought up Camila, who was on MTV right before their debut. I was never talking about why Baddies wasn't on here, I know why, even though I do think there are a few of them that wouldn't be an issue if they were cast. 

30 Comments
GoldenRing#152

I was actually referring to the comment that mentioned how the BGC girls were deemed a liability, the comment above my post, and how I thought that was a bs ruling by production.

I specifically referenced two BGC girls, Angela and Janelle, which is also why I brought up Camila, who was on MTV right before their debut. I was never talking about why Baddies wasn't on here, I know why, even though I do think there are a few of them that wouldn't be an issue if they were cast. 

GoldenRing#153

Garbi Denteh see you on The Challenge 42

Image from Challenge Rookie Prospects
OS Kajun#154

How do we all feel about rookie men from the UK? 

Give me Ben from this recent season of love island UK and then we can cut ties with that country when it comes to rookie men
IMG_1219.jpeg

looks like a weirdo

gabbydawn#155

How do we all feel about rookie men from the UK? 

Give me Ben from this recent season of love island UK and then we can cut ties with that country when it comes to rookie men
IMG_1219.jpeg

looks like a weirdo

but hes messy and that's all that matters to me

Tvandcoffee#156

Garbi Denteh see you on The Challenge 42

Screenshot 2025-09-30 at 10.27.14 PM.jpg

queen

Nonja#157
Image from Challenge Rookie Prospects

Lexi should be a LOCK for next season

Sportsman180#158
maxresdefault.jpg

Lexi should be a LOCK for next season

I'LL ALLOW IT. 

Sportsman180#159

Given that Will is the likeliest to earn vet status, it seems logical that Skye might dive into the dead/dying MTV reality shows one more time.

Is there anyone from AYTO or EOTB that can still make the last minute/Hail Mary/Titanic life boat/Last Chopper out of Saigon jump to Challenge 42?

entrepreneur#160

Given that Will is the likeliest to earn vet status, it seems logical that Skye might dive into the dead/dying MTV reality shows one more time.

Is there anyone from AYTO or EOTB that can still make the last minute/Hail Mary/Titanic life boat/Last Chopper out of Saigon jump to Challenge 42?

I heard they called Kassius from bad blood for this current season 

TwoStrikes#161

The whole bad blood cast 

Challenge 17#162

God survivor 48 and 49 have such little people to choose from for this lol. 

Flopnanas#163

I kinda would be here for eva from survivor 48 like she would rub so many people in the wrong way.... she would give what we thought sydney would ☕️

entrepreneur#164

I kinda would be here for eva from survivor 48 like she would rub so many people in the wrong way.... she would give what we thought sydney would ☕️

never wanna see that sympathy magnet ever again... and by again I mean for the first time. I only watched clips of survivor 48 because I don't care about the franchise... aside from returnee seasons 

Challenge 17#165

I kinda would be here for eva from survivor 48 like she would rub so many people in the wrong way.... she would give what we thought sydney would ☕️

She'd cry and have a breakdown as soon as she has to do something not physical

OS Kajun#166

Eva being on would be the worst thing to happen to the franchise. If Amanda or Ashley slightly raised their voice to her Eva would cry, they'd be booted and banned. Fans would go crazy on both sides. The show would be canceled. No thanks.

Flopnanas#167

My takes are ALWAYS critically panned! Sad

Sportsman180#168

God survivor 48 and 49 have such little people to choose from for this lol. 

Outside of Sai, there's absolutely NO ONE from 48 I could see on the flagship. Charity is the only other one that's close-ish, but she's 35, so nah.

I don't see anyone from 49 as a remotely good fit for the flagship. Maybe MC will surprise me??? And I could see Sophi, Rizo, and Savannah as one timers on like a USA-ish spinoff, but definitely NOT on the flagship.

Challenge 17#169

God survivor 48 and 49 have such little people to choose from for this lol. 

Outside of Sai, there's absolutely NO ONE from 48 I could see on the flagship. Charity is the only other one that's close-ish, but she's 35, so nah.

I don't see anyone from 49 as a remotely good fit for the flagship. Maybe MC will surprise me??? And I could see Sophi, Rizo, and Savannah as one timers on like a USA-ish spinoff, but definitely NOT on the flagship.

Rizo is a twig, we don't need people that ben could beat in hall brawl lol

Flopnanas#170

God survivor 48 and 49 have such little people to choose from for this lol. 

Outside of Sai, there's absolutely NO ONE from 48 I could see on the flagship. Charity is the only other one that's close-ish, but she's 35, so nah.

I don't see anyone from 49 as a remotely good fit for the flagship. Maybe MC will surprise me??? And I could see Sophi, Rizo, and Savannah as one timers on like a USA-ish spinoff, but definitely NOT on the flagship.

Sai was just as ANNOYING as eva lol but without the athleticism eva has

Flopnanas#171

would yall like to see this absolute LEGEND on 42? Smile

Image from Challenge Rookie Prospects
Challenge 17#172

I dont know this man but from the looks of him, no.

Sportsman180#173

Tucker is the ONLY Big Brother man needed.

killakashhh#174

Tucker is the ONLY Big Brother man needed.

he wouldn't pass the drug test

Sportsman180#175

Outside of Sai, there's absolutely NO ONE from 48 I could see on the flagship. Charity is the only other one that's close-ish, but she's 35, so nah.

I don't see anyone from 49 as a remotely good fit for the flagship. Maybe MC will surprise me??? And I could see Sophi, Rizo, and Savannah as one timers on like a USA-ish spinoff, but definitely NOT on the flagship.

Sai was just as ANNOYING as eva lol but without the athleticism eva has

Sai was a pot-stirrer. I could see her being fun for half a season.

Eva is a NO NO NO. Boring, loyal gameplay and will melt down at the first taste of adversity.

Sportsman180#176

Tucker is the ONLY Big Brother man needed.

he wouldn't pass the drug test

Let him come drugged. Even high as fecal he'll compete better than Derrick and Leroy.

TheKonquerer#177
Image from Challenge Rookie Prospects
Big Sav. 
Challenge 17#178

God survivor 48 and 49 have such little people to choose from for this lol. 

Outside of Sai, there's absolutely NO ONE from 48 I could see on the flagship. Charity is the only other one that's close-ish, but she's 35, so nah.

I don't see anyone from 49 as a remotely good fit for the flagship. Maybe MC will surprise me??? And I could see Sophi, Rizo, and Savannah as one timers on like a USA-ish spinoff, but definitely NOT on the flagship.

Sai was just as ANNOYING as eva lol but without the athleticism eva has

Sai is confrontational chaotic annoying, not power of friendship annoying like eva

KChallenge10#179

Sai would be soooo fun. She's gonna come on and cause chaos and play hard af day 1. Give me her and Q for mass chaos. 

Sportsman180#180

No excuse for Reilly to not be on 42:

Hot, athletic, bubbly, 26 years old, and seemingly no boyfriend. Plus, there's no American blondes in the rotation!

Image from Challenge Rookie Prospects
Challenge 17#181

You know what I don't even care, put star from 48 on here lol. 

Related Topics

The ChallengeContestant Discussion