Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

El Scorchowrote:AlwaysAMesswrote:Debut Albumwrote:Balls in or Hall Brawl. Hall Brawl, but the Seasons 2 version...

— El Scorcho

Tami vs David or Nia vs JordanTami vs David. because IT WASN'T NOT FUNNY...

— Debut Album

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: This or That?

El Scorcho ·
El Scorcho wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Balls in or Hall Brawl.

Hall Brawl, but the Seasons 2 version. The Exes 2 version was such bullshit.

What was the difference?

It wasn't done in separate heats for both genders like on Seasons 2, but instead as a relay race. Because of this, Nia got a major head start against Theresa both times and it wasn't fair IMO.

Oh thats right. I lost interest while watching Exes II. To be honest, I don't even think I watched that elimination round.

30 Comments
El Scorcho#242
El Scorcho wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Balls in or Hall Brawl.

Hall Brawl, but the Seasons 2 version. The Exes 2 version was such bullshit.

What was the difference?

It wasn't done in separate heats for both genders like on Seasons 2, but instead as a relay race. Because of this, Nia got a major head start against Theresa both times and it wasn't fair IMO.

Oh thats right. I lost interest while watching Exes II. To be honest, I don't even think I watched that elimination round.

TeamLandon#243

Tami vs David or Nia vs Jordan

Debut Album#244
Tami vs David or Nia vs Jordan

Tami vs David...because IT WASN'T NOT FUNNY!

RW Las Vegas 1 or Las Vegas 2.

TeamLandon#245
TeamLandon wrote:

Tami vs David or Nia vs Jordan

Tami vs David...because IT WASN'T NOT FUNNY!RW Las Vegas 1 or Las Vegas 2.

Vegas 1 by far! 

Who would you like to see as a surprise cast member on The Challenge: Trisha (Sydney) or Adam R (Vegas2)?

richjoe92#246
Debut Album wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:Tami vs David or Nia vs Jordan

Tami vs David...because IT WASN'T NOT FUNNY!RW Las Vegas 1 or Las Vegas 2.

Vegas 1 by far! Who would you like to see as a surprise cast member on The Challenge: Trisha (Sydney) or Adam R (Vegas2)?

Trisha, since she hasnt debut yet.

Debut Album#247
Debut Album wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:Tami vs David or Nia vs Jordan

Tami vs David...because IT WASN'T NOT FUNNY!RW Las Vegas 1 or Las Vegas 2.

Vegas 1 by far! Who would you like to see as a surprise cast member on The Challenge: Trisha (Sydney) or Adam R (Vegas2)?

Adam. 

Cutthroat or Free Agents?

Daddy DAF#248

Cutthroat

rwportland2#249

Cutthroat for me too. 

rwportland2#250

Who had funnier commentary, Coral or Katie?

AshtonMartin#251
Who had funnier commentary, Coral or Katie?

Coral. Who had the funniest injury Shauvon's busted implant or Simon's torn ********

hardbitten#252
Debut Album wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:Tami vs David or Nia vs Jordan

Tami vs David...because IT WASN'T NOT FUNNY!RW Las Vegas 1 or Las Vegas 2.

Vegas 1 by far! Who would you like to see as a surprise cast member on The Challenge: Trisha (Sydney) or Adam R (Vegas2)?

AdamAdam​​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​Adam​AdamAdam

Daddy DAF#253
rwportland2 wrote:

Who had funnier commentary, Coral or Katie?

Coral. Who had the funniest injury Shauvon's busted implant or Simon's torn ********

Shauvons was funny. Nothing is funny about Simone at all. 

Landon or Darrell?

Debut Album#254
AshtonMartin wrote:

rwportland2 wrote:Who had funnier commentary, Coral or Katie?

Coral. Who had the funniest injury Shauvon's busted implant or Simon's torn ********

Shauvons was funny. Nothing is funny about Simone at all.  Landon or Darrell?

Agree with Shavoun and Landon.

Jay or Brandon(AYTO)

AlwaysAMess#255
Jay or Brandon(AYTO)

Jay. He’s a cutie and at least he didn’t quit for a stupid reason.

Cara Maria or Camila?

rwportland2#256

Landon, probably would take him over anyone tbh.

Jay because at least he contributed something to Exes 2. The only Brandon's I remember are Drake Nelson and Swift. 

Cara Maria but I would take Camila if she left that extra drunk stuff at home.

Debut Album#257
Debut Album wrote:

Jay or Brandon(AYTO)

Jay. He’s a cutie and at least he didn’t quit for a stupid reason.Cara Maria or Camila?

Good Lord. That's like Choosing between Herpes and the clap.

Cara Maria.

Derrik(X-TREME) or Derek(Viewer's Revenge)

rwportland2#258
AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Jay or Brandon(AYTO)

Jay. He’s a cutie and at least he didn’t quit for a stupid reason.Cara Maria or Camila?

Good Lord. That's like Choosing between Herpes and the clap.Cara Maria.Derrik(X-TREME) or Derek(Viewer's Revenge)

Derrick in every aspect lol. 

Cohutta or Ace?

hardbitten#259
Diamonds are Forever wrote:

AshtonMartin wrote:

rwportland2 wrote:Who had funnier commentary, Coral or Katie?

Coral. Who had the funniest injury Shauvon's busted implant or Simon's torn ********

Shauvons was funny. Nothing is funny about Simone at all.  Landon or Darrell?

Agree with Shavoun and Landon.Jay or Brandon(AYTO)

BrandonBrandonBrandonBrandonBrandonBrandonBrandonBrandonBrandonBrandonBrandonBrandonBrandon

Debut Album#260
Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Jay or Brandon(AYTO)

Jay. He’s a cutie and at least he didn’t quit for a stupid reason.Cara Maria or Camila?

Good Lord. That's like Choosing between Herpes and the clap.Cara Maria.Derrik(X-TREME) or Derek(Viewer's Revenge)

Derrick in every aspect lol. Cohutta or Ace?  

Ace. Love Cohutta but Ace was the first so gotta give it to him.

Evelyn or Laurel.

LucciVee#261
rwportland2 wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Jay or Brandon(AYTO)

Jay. He’s a cutie and at least he didn’t quit for a stupid reason.Cara Maria or Camila?

Good Lord. That's like Choosing between Herpes and the clap.Cara Maria.Derrik(X-TREME) or Derek(Viewer's Revenge)

Derrick in every aspect lol. Cohutta or Ace?  

Ace. Love Cohutta but Ace was the first so gotta give it to him.Evelyn or Laurel.

Definitely Laurel. Evelyn hair was always stale to me.

Best Interviews: Devyn or Wes

richjoe92#262

Laurel. I would much rather look at her perpetually emotionless face than Evelyn's smug face.

whose competitively worse in their respective genders, Danny or Melinda?

richjoe92#263

Devyn the girl? or AYTO?

rwportland2#264

Laurel. She's just a little more likeable than Ev.

Devyn (Brooklyn) had better interviews than Wes. 

Melinda was worse than Danny. Can't believe she considered herself a good competitor on the Gauntlet 3.

richjoe92#265
Laurel. She's just a little more likeable than Ev.Devyn (Brooklyn) had better interviews than Wes. Melinda was worse than Danny. Can't believe she considered herself a good competitor on the Gauntlet 3. 

oh. I think collectively, I liked Wes' interviews more than Devyn's. Simply because on FA, she came off as ingeniune and really pushing hard to be the funny one. But I loved her in BoTS2.

anon23423234235#266
Laurel. She's just a little more likeable than Ev.Devyn (Brooklyn) had better interviews than Wes. Melinda was worse than Danny. Can't believe she considered herself a good competitor on the Gauntlet 3. 

Melinda isn't a terrible competitor. i mean she was better than some people. Johanna, and Rachel and Brooke. she might have even been better than Angel. 

LucciVee#267
Laurel. I would much rather look at her perpetually emotionless face than Evelyn's smug face.whose competitively worse in their respective genders, Danny or Melinda?

Melinda was never horrid for me, it was always Danny who made it intolerable. So definitely Danny. 

Best Crazy ***: Julie or Camila 

HonestTea101#268
richjoe92 wrote:

Laurel. I would much rather look at her perpetually emotionless face than Evelyn's smug face.whose competitively worse in their respective genders, Danny or Melinda?

Melinda was never horrid for me, it was always Danny who made it intolerable. So definitely Danny. Best Crazy ***: Julie or Camila 

Julie because she was the OG  crazy ***** 

rwportland2#269

Julie because she was constantly entertaining. Camila is just hard to watch now

anon333334#270

Julie was also completely oblivious to it all, like she had no idea why everybody thought she was so crazy lmaooo

Coral or Aneesa?

rwportland2#271

Coral. 

Who's better at being all bark and no bite: Tina or Jenn.

Related Topics

The ChallengeThe Amazing Race