Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Big Easy's beer gut or Evan's 'roid gut...

— MTV Junky

Big Easy's beer gut or Evan's 'roid gut. Evan's 'soid gut...

— Debut Album

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: This or That?

MTV Junky ·

Big Easy's beer gut or Evan's 'roid gut?

30 Comments
MTV Junky#182

Big Easy's beer gut or Evan's 'roid gut?

Debut Album#183
Big Easy's beer gut or Evan's 'roid gut?

Evan's 'soid gut.

San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

gr4pefruits#184
Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. Thomas

Danny or Tyrie? 

Debut Album#185
Debut Album wrote:

Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.

Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

LucciVee#186

Jenny or Robin. ❤

Euroslavia#187
gr4pefruits wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.

Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Debut Album#188
Jenny or Robin. ❤

Hard one..Jenny. 

Debut Album#189
Debut Album wrote:

gr4pefruits wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).

Katie or Camilla.

gr4pefruits#190
Euroslavia wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. 

CJ or Landon? 

MTV Junky#191
Debut Album wrote:

Euroslavia wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Lando Commando

Alton or Theo V.

TeamLandon#192
gr4pefruits wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

Euroslavia wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Lando CommandoAlton or Theo V.

Theo V... that was hard. 

Gauntlet Queens: Sarah G. or Kina

MTV Junky#193
MTV Junky wrote:

gr4pefruits wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
Euroslavia wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Lando CommandoAlton or Theo V.

Theo V... that was hard. Gauntlet Queens: Sarah G. or Kina

Has to be Sarah G. because no one wanted her there.

How about elimination King Derrick - Gauntlet or Wes - FM

Debut Album#194
Debut Album wrote:

Euroslavia wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Love CJ But gotta go with Landon.

Leroy or Darrell.

Debut Album#195
TeamLandon wrote:

MTV Junky wrote:

gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
Euroslavia wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Lando CommandoAlton or Theo V.

Theo V... that was hard. Gauntlet Queens: Sarah G. or Kina

Has to be Sarah G. because no one wanted her there.How about elimination King Derrick - Gauntlet or Wes - FM

Derrick-Gauntlet.

TeamLandon#196
gr4pefruits wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

Euroslavia wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Love CJ But gotta go with Landon.Leroy or Darrell.

Darrell

Best batch of Fresh Meat Newbs: FM1 or FM2 

richjoe92#197
Debut Album wrote:

gr4pefruits wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
Euroslavia wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Love CJ But gotta go with Landon.Leroy or Darrell.

DarrellBest batch of Fresh Meat Newbs: FM1 or FM2 

in terms of athletism FM1.

Pete or Noor?

anon3895345345345#198

Battle of the Seasons 1 or Battle of the Sexes 1 

MTV Junky#199
Battle of the Seasons 1 or Battle of the Sexes 1 

I have to go with Sexes on this one.  Both are top tier seasons.

Euroslavia#200
TeamLandon wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
Euroslavia wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Love CJ But gotta go with Landon.Leroy or Darrell.

DarrellBest batch of Fresh Meat Newbs: FM1 or FM2 

in terms of athletism FM1.Pete or Noor?

Definitely Noor.

Ayiiia or Jonna?

Debut Album#201
Debut Album wrote:

gr4pefruits wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
Euroslavia wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Love CJ But gotta go with Landon.Leroy or Darrell.

DarrellBest batch of Fresh Meat Newbs: FM1 or FM2 

Fresh Meat 2. They weren't as awful as the firs batch and didn't **** up this show like they did as well.

Debut Album#202
Battle of the Seasons 1 or Battle of the Sexes 1 

Damn..This is hard as both are good seasons..Sexes 1.

Debut Album#203
richjoe92 wrote:

TeamLandon wrote:

Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
Euroslavia wrote:
Debut Album wrote:
gr4pefruits wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Evan's 'soid gut.San Diego 2 or St Thomas.

St. ThomasDanny or Tyrie? 

Danny.Challenge Locations: Mexico or Thailand.

Mexico.Tara (Northern Trail) or Holly S?

Holly(Latin America).Katie or Camilla.

Katie all day. CJ or Landon? 

Love CJ But gotta go with Landon.Leroy or Darrell.

DarrellBest batch of Fresh Meat Newbs: FM1 or FM2 

in terms of athletism FM1.Pete or Noor?

Definitely Noor.Ayiiia or Jonna?

Jonna.

Thomas or Tony.

AlwaysAMess#204
Thomas or Tony.

Tony. Thomas is boring.

Emily S. or Cooke?

LucciVee#205
Debut Album wrote:

Thomas or Tony.

Tony. Thomas is boring.Emily S. or Cooke?

Cooke. 

Whose more entertaining on this show the Boys or Girls? :)

Debut Album#206
Debut Album wrote:

Thomas or Tony.

Tony. Thomas is boring.Emily S. or Cooke?

Cooke all the way baby!

Devyn or Brooke.

Debut Album#207
AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Thomas or Tony.

Tony. Thomas is boring.Emily S. or Cooke?

Cooke. Whose more entertaining on this show the Boys or Girls? :)

Boys.

Laurel or Cara Maria.

richjoe92#208
LucciVee wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Thomas or Tony.

Tony. Thomas is boring.Emily S. or Cooke?

Cooke. Whose more entertaining on this show the Boys or Girls? :)

Boys.Laurel or Cara Maria.

Currently, Guys, but before, Girls used to rule.

Laurel, she's competition drama.

TeamLandon#209
AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Thomas or Tony.

Tony. Thomas is boring.Emily S. or Cooke?

Cooke all the way baby!Devyn or Brooke.

Brooke

Best Rivalry: Coral/Trishelle or Veronica/Katie 

richjoe92#210
Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Thomas or Tony.

Tony. Thomas is boring.Emily S. or Cooke?

Cooke all the way baby!Devyn or Brooke.

BrookeBest Rivalry: Coral/Trishelle or Veronica/Katie 

mmm... Trashelle or Verontula? I think Verontula and Katie's cause of that blow out scene in the Inferno.

LucciVee#211
Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Thomas or Tony.

Tony. Thomas is boring.Emily S. or Cooke?

Cooke all the way baby!Devyn or Brooke.

BrookeBest Rivalry: Coral/Trishelle or Veronica/Katie 

Coral/Trishelle by a long shot.

Best Commentary: Wes or Bananas 

Related Topics

The Challenge