Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Which drama-magnet non-finalist challenger* do you prefer/think is supreme. Amanda Garcia or Theresa Gonzalez-JonesBoth have so/so elimination records, have had messy/dramatic comeback seasons, and ac...

— TheKonquerer

Which drama-magnet non-finalist challenger* do you prefer/think is supreme. Amanda Garcia or Theresa Gonzalez-JonesBoth have so/so elimination records, have had messy/dramatic comeback seasons, and ac...

— lavendarveto

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: This or That?

kvm1977 ·

Who's Taking It?

Cara v Tori in... Balls In?

Cara v. Tori in ... Pole Wrestle?

Cara v. Tori in .... Hall Brawl?

Cara v. Tori in... Knot So Fast?

Cara v. Tori in .... Looper?

Today...Tori in all but Knot So Fast

30 Comments
kvm1977#572

Who's Taking It?

Cara v Tori in... Balls In?

Cara v. Tori in ... Pole Wrestle?

Cara v. Tori in .... Hall Brawl?

Cara v. Tori in... Knot So Fast?

Cara v. Tori in .... Looper?

Today...Tori in all but Knot So Fast

kvm1977#573

Who do you like more?

Tori or Aneesa?

John or Fessy?

Moriah or Olivia?

Colleen or Analyse?

Laurel or Michele?

Bettina or Tracy?

Tacha or Berna?

Big T or Amber?

Kiki or Emily?

Claudia or Jujuy?

Kaz or Zara?

Tori Fessy Olivia Meh on both Laurel neither Berna Amber Emily No clue Kaz

TheKonquerer#574

Who's Taking It?

Cara v Tori in... Balls In?

Cara v. Tori in ... Pole Wrestle?

Cara v. Tori in .... Hall Brawl?

Cara v. Tori in... Knot So Fast?

Cara v. Tori in .... Looper?

Tbh. I don't think Tori wants to see Cara in anything honestly. 

TheKonquerer#575

Who do you like more?

Tori or Aneesa?

John or Fessy?

Moriah or Olivia?

Colleen or Analyse?

Laurel or Michele?

Bettina or Tracy?

Tacha or Berna?

Big T or Amber?

Kiki or Emily?

Claudia or Jujuy?

Kaz or Zara?

Tori , Fessy , Moriah , Analyse , Laurel , Bettina , Tacha , Tula , Emily , Jujuy, Zara. 

TheKonquerer#576

Which drama-magnet non-finalist challenger* do you prefer/think is supreme?

Amanda Garcia or Theresa Gonzalez-Jones

Both have so/so elimination records, have had messy/dramatic comeback seasons, and actually aren't terrible at daily missions. 

*I know Theresa technically made it to the final on BOTE2 but that was just due to Nia's disqualification... should that not have happened she technically hasn't qualified. 

Theresa is more likely to stick around , I'll say Theresa. My only quarrel with Theresa is that she can be a bit of a crybaby and I like my villains heartless and ready to eat at any given point. 

lavendarveto#577

Who do you like more?

Cara Z or Susie?

Trishelle or Katie?

Mallory or Christena?

Veronica, Rachel or Tina?

Johanna or Melinda?

Marie or Latoya?

Ashley Mitchell or Amanda?

Paulie or Cara Maria?

Jenna, Nany or Kailah?

Cory or Nelson?

cara, trishelle, christena, veronica, melinda, marie, ashley, cara, kailah, cory

lavendarveto#578

Who's Taking It?

Cara v Tori in... Balls In?

Cara v. Tori in ... Pole Wrestle?

Cara v. Tori in .... Hall Brawl?

Cara v. Tori in... Knot So Fast?

Cara v. Tori in .... Looper?

the only one tory is winning is hall brawl

lavendarveto#579

Who do you like more?

Tori or Aneesa?

John or Fessy?

Moriah or Olivia?

Colleen or Analyse?

Laurel or Michele?

Bettina or Tracy?

Tacha or Berna?

Big T or Amber?

Kiki or Emily?

Claudia or Jujuy?

Kaz or Zara?

aneesa, fessy, moriah, colleen, laurel, tracy, tacha, amber, claudia, zara

lavendarveto#580

Which drama-magnet non-finalist challenger* do you prefer/think is supreme?

Amanda Garcia or Theresa Gonzalez-Jones

Both have so/so elimination records, have had messy/dramatic comeback seasons, and actually aren't terrible at daily missions. 

*I know Theresa technically made it to the final on BOTE2 but that was just due to Nia's disqualification... should that not have happened she technically hasn't qualified. 

theresa is definitely the better competitor. as a reality tv character i prefer amanda but i love theresa too

kvm1977#581

Which drama-magnet non-finalist challenger* do you prefer/think is supreme?

Amanda Garcia or Theresa Gonzalez-Jones

Both have so/so elimination records, have had messy/dramatic comeback seasons, and actually aren't terrible at daily missions. 

*I know Theresa technically made it to the final on BOTE2 but that was just due to Nia's disqualification... should that not have happened she technically hasn't qualified. 

Theresa is more likely to stick around , I'll say Theresa. My only quarrel with Theresa is that she can be a bit of a crybaby and I like my villains heartless and ready to eat at any given point. 

If Theresa comes back she needs to play the game.  She always played safe and did stupid throwaway votes.  Theresa is better than her elimination record but had potential to be great.  Infinitely better than Amanda though.

AshtonMartin#582

Who do you like more?

Tori or Aneesa?

John or Fessy?

Moriah or Olivia?

Colleen or Analyse?

Laurel or Michele?

Bettina or Tracy?

Tacha or Berna?

Big T or Amber?

Kiki or Emily?

Claudia or Jujuy?

Kaz or Zara?

Aneesa, Fessy, Olivia, Analyse, Laurel, Bettina, Tacha, Amber, Kiki, Jujuy, Zara

Anon23432534534...#583

Kvm or oldschooler

anon12423452355...#584

Kvm or oldschooler

I hate you lol. 

anon12423452355...#585

Who do you like more?

Cara Z or Susie? CARA 

Trishelle or Katie? KATIE

Mallory or Christena? MALLORY

Veronica, Rachel or Tina? TINA

Johanna or Melinda? JOHANNA

Marie or Latoya? TIE

Ashley Mitchell or Amanda? AMANDA

Paulie or Cara Maria? CARA

Jenna, Nany or Kailah? KAILAH

Cory or Nelson? CORY

AshtonMartin#586

Sarah Rice or Tori Deal?

anon12423452355...#587

Sarah Rice or Tori Deal?

I don't even like Sarah Rice but you are comparing a nice filet to literal dog śhît. 

AshtonMartin#588

Sarah Rice or Tori Deal?

I don't even like Sarah Rice but you are comparing a nice filet to literal dog śhît. 

Sarah is miles better imo but I feel like casting wise they fill the same role. I wonder what production would say?

anon12423452355...#589

Production would kill their first born for Tory. Look at the decisions made, they are idiots.

AshtonMartin#590

Kill Card or Double Cross?

Hauserman#591

Double Cross, let's see people capitalize on that power to make a move.

kvm1977#592

Double Cross, let's see people capitalize on that power to make a move.

Agreed there's advantages to both though.  We didn't see a lot of big moves with the Double Cross but in theory that should be better. 

entrepreneur#593

Battle of the Exiled or Redemption?

AshtonMartin#594

Battle of the Exiled or Redemption?

Exiled i think if your eliminated earlier you should have to fight harder to get back in. Only winning 1 or 2 challenges isn't enough.

AshtonMartin#595

Dirty 30 or Cutthroat?

killakashhh#596

Dirty 30 or Cutthroat?

cutthroat

killakashhh#597

Inferno III or Rivals II

AshtonMartin#598

Inferno III or Rivals II

Rivals II 

entrepreneur#599

Road Rules or Are You The One?

killakashhh#600

Road Rules or Are You The One?

AYTO

OS Kajun#601

Road Rules or Are You The One?

Is this a serious question lol?

Related Topics

The Challenge