Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

The two time champ and future two time champ :)...

— Anon23432534534...

Best chance at being a champion: Bear or Josh...

— TeamLandon

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: This or That?

Anon23432534534... ·

The two time champ and future two time champ :) 

30 Comments
Anon23432534534...#512

The two time champ and future two time champ :) 

TeamLandon#513

Best chance at being a champion: Bear or Josh?

Anon23432534534...#514

I'll say bear. But I think it's going to take him a while maybe like 6-8 ssns in. Josh I think will always go deeper but never win. 

Chicken_breast#515

Vince or Bananas

Me personally I like Vince he's not extra and annoying like Bananas. Plus he's better looking.

Psy4potato#516

don't care for either...lol maybe Bananas? Vince didn't do much but creep out Jenna, at least he split the money though. 

Team Laurel or Team Ninja 

(I'm totally 100% team Laurel just curious on how this will be answered lol)

Chicken_breast#517

Laurel all the way. No questions asked. Lol 

Team Challenge format or Individual Challenge format

Debut Album#518

more surprising of a return:

Veronica on Dirty 30 or Trishelle on Battle of the Seasons day 

Trishelle. I feel like we'd see V back eventually but I never thought we'd see Trishelle back.

richjoe92#519

more surprising of a return:

Veronica on Dirty 30 or Trishelle on Battle of the Seasons day 

Trishelle. I feel like we'd see V back eventually but I never thought we'd see Trishelle back.

Trishelle, cause she provided more tv in her short 2 seasons stint than V did. 

Anon23432534534...#520

Ashley/Cara/Wes getting a third win or Nany/Tori/Leroy getting their first 

richjoe92#521

Ashley/Cara/Wes getting a third win or Nany/Tori/Leroy getting their first 

I can see any of Ash or Cara getting a third win over the other three getting their first win.

Psy4potato#522

Laurel all the way. No questions asked. Lol 

Team Challenge format or Individual Challenge format

No one answered this one so I'll answer it and start a new one lol:

I like both, but I'd go for team I think. As long as there are no purges and more winners are possible. Unlike last season.

Battle of the Sexes 1 or Battle of the Sexes 2

Debut Album#523

Laurel all the way. No questions asked. Lol 

Team Challenge format or Individual Challenge format

No one answered this one so I'll answer it and start a new one lol:

I like both, but I'd go for team I think. As long as there are no purges and more winners are possible. Unlike last season.

Battle of the Sexes 1 or Battle of the Sexes 2

Sexes 1 hands down. That was honestly one of the best challenges ever created IMO.

Inferno 1 or Inferno 2?

Challengefan134#524

Thats tough. I liked watching Inferno 1 more however Inferno 2's cast was legendary

anon23423234ffs...#525

Big Easy or Tyrie?

entrepreneur#526

Tyrie at least could defend himself

"*****. get over.  yourself."

Ruins or Bloody Hell?

Psy4potato#527

Tyrie at least could defend himself

"*****. get over.  yourself."

Ruins or Bloody Hell?

Ruins. Besides JEK the cast was fantastic and a lot of RW rookies that were great.

Bigger surprise:

Beth taking out Ruthie on Gauntlet 2 or Rachel getting voted off of Sexes 2

entrepreneur#528

Beth taking out Ruthie...Rachel screwed herself by saying Katie would be going home and Katie rightfully stepped tf down...had rachel shut up katie wouldve blindly been voted out...

Better era 

Rivals 2/Free Agents/ Battle of the Exes 2 vs.

Rivals 3/Invasion of the Champions/Dirty 30

LucciVee#529

Beth taking out Ruthie...Rachel screwed herself by saying Katie would be going home and Katie rightfully stepped tf down...had rachel shut up katie wouldve blindly been voted out...

Better era 

Rivals 2/Free Agents/ Battle of the Exes 2 vs.

Rivals 3/Invasion of the Champions/Dirty 30

Probably the latter because it felt more open for casting and a lot of suprises casting wise came in those seasons. 

Which pair would be a better fit for the show: 

Jonitta & Nurys or Kenya & Bria

rideordie95#530

Kaycee or Nicole Z?

Tbh I have to choose Nicole Z. As much she is the worst & insufferable, she at least she brings drama and isn't boring. 

ohhaiii#531

Kaycee or Nicole Z?

Tbh I have to choose Nicole Z. As much she is the worst & insufferable, she at least she brings drama and isn't boring. 

Depending on the cast id most likely rather see Kaycee since at least shes wall paper and we dont see boring and cringey story lines from her.  At least the drama Kaycee has caused is focused on more interesting people and not a cringey "i can have anyone watch me eat peanut butter" 

wutzrenzi#532

Kaycee or Nicole Z?

Tbh I have to choose Nicole Z. As much she is the worst & insufferable, she at least she brings drama and isn't boring. 

'

I guess I'm homophobic

Psy4potato#533

I'm bored.  Anyone wanna play? lol

Better Original Non RW/RR  British Female Addition to the Show:Melissa or Kayleigh 

(my vote Is Melissa lol)

RealityFanForever#534

I'm bored.  Anyone wanna play? lol

Better Original Non RW/RR  British Female Addition to the Show:Melissa or Kayleigh 

(my vote Is Melissa lol)

So hard to choose but I would also go with Melissa. She has been very entertaining in the few seasons she's been on, but I also adore Kayleigh. These two are definitely great representation for the UK and paved the way for more Brits to come on.

anon23423234ffs...#535

I'm bored.  Anyone wanna play? lol

Better Original Non RW/RR  British Female Addition to the Show:Melissa or Kayleigh 

(my vote Is Melissa lol)

So hard to choose but I would also go with Melissa. She has been very entertaining in the few seasons she's been on, but I also adore Kayleigh. These two are definitely great representation for the UK and paved the way for more Brits to come on.

Same here. I also think both are very hot.

AshtonMartin#536

I'm bored.  Anyone wanna play? lol

Better Original Non RW/RR  British Female Addition to the Show:Melissa or Kayleigh 

(my vote Is Melissa lol)

Melissa, she has a better energy about her imo

AshtonMartin#537

Popular Real World Debuts: 

CeeJai or Katrina

dylan76#538

I think Katrina would have been more impressive as a competitor.

LucciVee#539

I think Katrina would have been more impressive as a competitor.

I could see her rubbing people the wrong way but competition could be up in the air for her. 

El Lobito#540

Popular Real World Debuts: 

CeeJai or Katrina

por qué no los dos ?

Coralfan#541

Popular Real World Debuts: 

CeeJai or Katrina

Ceejai!!!  Though both should be on the challenge.

Related Topics

The Challenge