Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Emily & PaulaAll Winners season or Old School vs New School...

— aura

Emily & PaulaAll Winners season or Old School vs New School...

— FromTheNorth

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: This or That?

aura ·

Emily & Paula

All Winners season or Old School vs New School?

30 Comments
aura#482

Emily & Paula

All Winners season or Old School vs New School?

FromTheNorth#483

Ninja or Nicole Zanatta?

Idris or Jozea?

Nicole.

Inferno 1 or Inferno 2

2, just take a look at the females on the ****** team Most Iconic cast ever

FromTheNorth#484

Emily & Paula

All Winners season or Old School vs New School?

Old Scool Vs. New, no way they could pull off a good cast for winners atm

FromTheNorth#485

Theo or Paulie, who's winning first?

anon23423234ffs...#486

Theo or Paulie, who's winning first?

Theo would win first. Paulie is more likely to go full on CT and punch someone in the face than to win a challenge.

rideordie95#487

Nicole Bass or Zahida?

Zahida

FromTheNorth#488

Theo or Paulie, who's winning first?

Theo would win first. Paulie is more likely to go full on CT and punch someone in the face than to win a challenge.

I think he's pretty self aware on the show, he wants to fight as much as possible for screentime and callbacks, but would never get himself kicked off 

Psy4potato#489

Theo or Paulie, who's winning first?

hopefully neither but I'll go with Theo.

Fresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

richjoe92#490

Theo or Paulie, who's winning first?

hopefully neither but I'll go with Theo.

Fresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 2 cause I love me some Landon and Pete.

anon23423234ffs...#491

Theo or Paulie, who's winning first?

hopefully neither but I'll go with Theo.

Fresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 2 cause I love me some Landon and Pete.

But Fresh Meat 2 gave us Cara Maria

Challengefan134#492

Cara Maria on every season from now on or Laurel

Me personally I am going with Laurel

richjoe92#493

Theo or Paulie, who's winning first?

hopefully neither but I'll go with Theo.

Fresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 2 cause I love me some Landon and Pete.

But Fresh Meat 2 gave us Cara Maria

But Fresh Meat 1 gave us rapists. 

aura#494

OOP

anon23423234ffs...#495

Theo or Paulie, who's winning first?

hopefully neither but I'll go with Theo.

Fresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 2 cause I love me some Landon and Pete.

But Fresh Meat 2 gave us Cara Maria

But Fresh Meat 1 gave us rapists. 

Fair point. Cara Maria > Evan and Kenny.

Psy4potato#496

Cara Maria on every season from now on or Laurel

Me personally I am going with Laurel

Laurel <3

which one hit wonder would you have liked to see again: 

Brittini from RW Hollywood or Kendal from RR Campus Crawl

Challengefan134#497

I loved both but probably Kendal

anon333334#498

Cara Maria on every season from now on or Laurel

Me personally I am going with Laurel

Laurel <3

which one hit wonder would you have liked to see again: 

Brittini from RW Hollywood or Kendal from RR Campus Crawl

Legend Sherrod

Debut Album#499

Have Cara cast on every season and Bananas never comes back on or Have Camila return for 2 seasons and never see CT and Bananas again.

I can deal with that hell ***** back if it meant never seeing Backpack's worthless *** ever again so I'll take the latter option

Debut Album#500

Emily & Paula

All Winners season or Old School vs New School?

Old Vs New. I don't even think they could get enough people for an all winners season honestly. 

Debut Album#501

Theo or Paulie, who's winning first?

Love Paulie but I see Theo winning before him given that he seems more of a complete competitor. 

Psy4potato#502

War of the Worlds 1 or War of the Worlds 2?

FromTheNorth#503

War of the Worlds 1 or War of the Worlds 2?

1 easy. Bunch of good rookies and solid theme. Only real issues being Paulie and dragging out the end when it got individual. They totally should have made individual eliminations with the winners forming a team though. 2 was painful to watch my favs be on the bottom of the numbers all season

Debut Album#504

War of the Worlds 1 or War of the Worlds 2?

First One. Easy.

Psy4potato#505

more surprising of a return:

Veronica on Dirty 30 or Trishelle on Battle of the Seasons day 

wutzrenzi#506

WOTW1 was so good and refreshing. I just wished they remained teams for a bit or just entirely and also upset Davonne was eliminated via mission at the end. Other than it was a HIT honestly.

Trishelle coming back was a shocker but never in my life would I think Veronica would be coming back.  Shane or Darrell.

Psy4potato#507

WOTW1 was so good and refreshing. I just wished they remained teams for a bit or just entirely and also upset Davonne was eliminated via mission at the end. Other than it was a HIT honestly.

Trishelle coming back was a shocker but never in my life would I think Veronica would be coming back.  Shane or Darrell.

i'd day Shane. Darrell seemed more likely since he was on the show semi recently compared to Shane.

Brad or Derrick - more surprising of a return

FromTheNorth#508

WOTW1 was so good and refreshing. I just wished they remained teams for a bit or just entirely and also upset Davonne was eliminated via mission at the end. Other than it was a HIT honestly.

Trishelle coming back was a shocker but never in my life would I think Veronica would be coming back.  Shane or Darrell.

i'd day Shane. Darrell seemed more likely since he was on the show semi recently compared to Shane.

Brad or Derrick - more surprising of a return

Probably Brad, I remember Derrick's seemed like it was coming after his divorce when he started posting about the show constantly, was he an alt on Invasion? can't remember. Brad's may have been a bit forecasted too if I'm remembering right, but still more of a surprise

TeamLandon#509

Favorite challenge duo: Kam/Cara or Laural/Nany

richjoe92#510

Favorite challenge duo: Kam/Cara or Laural/Nany

Kam/Cam, cause I don't really remember Nany/Laurel interactions. 

anon333334#511

Queen Kam & Cara are more of an actual pair that can help each other out..... GonFlopez can't do shit for Laurel.

Related Topics

The ChallengeCast Spoilers