Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Let's try to play this game again:Brits or Big Brother...

— Psy4potato

Let's try to play this game again:Brits or Big BrotherBrits 1000%...

— deeper

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: This or That?

Psy4potato ·

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

30 Comments
Psy4potato#452

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

deeper#453

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

anon23423234ffs...#454

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

But the Brits are trash as well. Esther, Idris, Nicole Bass, Sean, and Zahida were horrific, Jenny and Joss are probably done since they're boring, Kyle should be done since he has no more storylines, and Melissa won't be on next season. In my opinion, only Ashley Cain, Bear, Big T, Georgia, Kayleigh, Rogan, and Theo will probably do another season. That's under half of the Brits that have done this show.

FromTheNorth#455

Brits have done more so far but I expect Big Brother to contribute more in the future, especially with this solid crop of prospects this season. Although the 2 year CBS contracts could impact that

deeper#456

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

But the Brits are trash as well. Esther, Idris, Nicole Bass, Sean, and Zahida were horrific, Jenny and Joss are probably done since they're boring, Kyle should be done since he has no more storylines, and Melissa won't be on next season. In my opinion, only Ashley Cain, Bear, Big T, Georgia, Kayleigh, Rogan, and Theo will probably do another season. That's under half of the Brits that have done this show.

joss will be back before Ashley Cain or Kayleigh imo. Just from a competitive standpoint and because of "Jogan" they would bring him back whereas they paid Ashley dust and Kayleigh they gave her a ghost/villain/bad competitor edit so she's not likely to be back 

deeper#457

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

But the Brits are trash as well. Esther, Idris, Nicole Bass, Sean, and Zahida were horrific, Jenny and Joss are probably done since they're boring, Kyle should be done since he has no more storylines, and Melissa won't be on next season. In my opinion, only Ashley Cain, Bear, Big T, Georgia, Kayleigh, Rogan, and Theo will probably do another season. That's under half of the Brits that have done this show.

joss will be back before Ashley Cain or Kayleigh imo. Just from a competitive standpoint and because of "Jogan" they would bring him back whereas they paid Ashley dust and Kayleigh they gave her a ghost/villain/bad competitor edit so she's not likely to be back 

anon23423234ffs...#458

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

But the Brits are trash as well. Esther, Idris, Nicole Bass, Sean, and Zahida were horrific, Jenny and Joss are probably done since they're boring, Kyle should be done since he has no more storylines, and Melissa won't be on next season. In my opinion, only Ashley Cain, Bear, Big T, Georgia, Kayleigh, Rogan, and Theo will probably do another season. That's under half of the Brits that have done this show.

joss will be back before Ashley Cain or Kayleigh imo. Just from a competitive standpoint and because of "Jogan" they would bring him back whereas they paid Ashley dust and Kayleigh they gave her a ghost/villain/bad competitor edit so she's not likely to be back 

Yeah but he's super boring. I don't remember if it was Pink or someone else, but someone here said that getting dropped from WOTW should've been a wake up call for him to start contributing from a drama standpoint.

deeper#459

As of now, I say brits cause they've given us many potential or already regulars: rogan, Theo, bear, Georgia, Kyle(unfortunately), big T, Jenny, and joss.  

BB has given us Davonne who is now over the show, Paulie who is the absolute worst thing to happen to the Challenge in a long time, and potentially 3-4 good rookies but Fessy is basically the BB Joss from the looks of it, and KC is basically the BB Jenny. Bayleigh and Swaggy we'll see how they do but I'm sure they'll be given the villain edit with how people talk about them already. 

deeper#460

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

But the Brits are trash as well. Esther, Idris, Nicole Bass, Sean, and Zahida were horrific, Jenny and Joss are probably done since they're boring, Kyle should be done since he has no more storylines, and Melissa won't be on next season. In my opinion, only Ashley Cain, Bear, Big T, Georgia, Kayleigh, Rogan, and Theo will probably do another season. That's under half of the Brits that have done this show.

joss will be back before Ashley Cain or Kayleigh imo. Just from a competitive standpoint and because of "Jogan" they would bring him back whereas they paid Ashley dust and Kayleigh they gave her a ghost/villain/bad competitor edit so she's not likely to be back 

Yeah but he's super boring. I don't remember if it was Pink or someone else, but someone here said that getting dropped from WOTW should've been a wake up call for him to start contributing from a drama standpoint.

i don't disagree, he's boring, but I think he'll be back before the others just from a competitive standpoint and that he's Rogan's right hand man and Rogan is becoming a central character 

FromTheNorth#461

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

But the Brits are trash as well. Esther, Idris, Nicole Bass, Sean, and Zahida were horrific, Jenny and Joss are probably done since they're boring, Kyle should be done since he has no more storylines, and Melissa won't be on next season. In my opinion, only Ashley Cain, Bear, Big T, Georgia, Kayleigh, Rogan, and Theo will probably do another season. That's under half of the Brits that have done this show.

joss will be back before Ashley Cain or Kayleigh imo. Just from a competitive standpoint and because of "Jogan" they would bring him back whereas they paid Ashley dust and Kayleigh they gave her a ghost/villain/bad competitor edit so she's not likely to be back 

Yeah but he's super boring. I don't remember if it was Pink or someone else, but someone here said that getting dropped from WOTW should've been a wake up call for him to start contributing from a drama standpoint.

i don't disagree, he's boring, but I think he'll be back before the others just from a competitive standpoint and that he's Rogan's right hand man and Rogan is becoming a central character 

There's plenty of competition on the male side though, Joss isn't needed. An equally boring female like Jenny is much more likely to keep coming back than him just because she's a girl

FromTheNorth#462

The Circle or Love is Blind?

Which is going to have someone cast first?

Which would you rather see players cast from?

Haven't seen the latter so I googled a couple, holy shit some of them have millions of followers

deeper#463

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

But the Brits are trash as well. Esther, Idris, Nicole Bass, Sean, and Zahida were horrific, Jenny and Joss are probably done since they're boring, Kyle should be done since he has no more storylines, and Melissa won't be on next season. In my opinion, only Ashley Cain, Bear, Big T, Georgia, Kayleigh, Rogan, and Theo will probably do another season. That's under half of the Brits that have done this show.

joss will be back before Ashley Cain or Kayleigh imo. Just from a competitive standpoint and because of "Jogan" they would bring him back whereas they paid Ashley dust and Kayleigh they gave her a ghost/villain/bad competitor edit so she's not likely to be back 

Yeah but he's super boring. I don't remember if it was Pink or someone else, but someone here said that getting dropped from WOTW should've been a wake up call for him to start contributing from a drama standpoint.

i don't disagree, he's boring, but I think he'll be back before the others just from a competitive standpoint and that he's Rogan's right hand man and Rogan is becoming a central character 

There's plenty of competition on the male side though, Joss isn't needed. An equally boring female like Jenny is much more likely to keep coming back than him just because she's a girl

again, I don't disagree, but don't be shocked when you see joss on the cast list for 36 or 37 cause we all know casting doesn't make sense sometimes 

FromTheNorth#464

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

But the Brits are trash as well. Esther, Idris, Nicole Bass, Sean, and Zahida were horrific, Jenny and Joss are probably done since they're boring, Kyle should be done since he has no more storylines, and Melissa won't be on next season. In my opinion, only Ashley Cain, Bear, Big T, Georgia, Kayleigh, Rogan, and Theo will probably do another season. That's under half of the Brits that have done this show.

joss will be back before Ashley Cain or Kayleigh imo. Just from a competitive standpoint and because of "Jogan" they would bring him back whereas they paid Ashley dust and Kayleigh they gave her a ghost/villain/bad competitor edit so she's not likely to be back 

Yeah but he's super boring. I don't remember if it was Pink or someone else, but someone here said that getting dropped from WOTW should've been a wake up call for him to start contributing from a drama standpoint.

i don't disagree, he's boring, but I think he'll be back before the others just from a competitive standpoint and that he's Rogan's right hand man and Rogan is becoming a central character 

There's plenty of competition on the male side though, Joss isn't needed. An equally boring female like Jenny is much more likely to keep coming back than him just because she's a girl

again, I don't disagree, but don't be shocked when you see joss on the cast list for 36 or 37 cause we all know casting doesn't make sense sometimes 

You're probably right. Personally I'd rather they bring back Darrell, Brad or even Derrick if they want to bring back a strong male 

deeper#465

I'm bored. Let's try to play this game again:

Brits or Big Brother 

Brits 1000%. The only big brother person worth a damn so far was Davonne. Natalie sucked, Long hair guy sucked, Jozea sucked, Paulie is quite literally the most annoying person to ever be on the show. Haven't seen enough of the BB rookies this year, I like fessy, swaggy, and bayleigh so far.  

Theo, Georgia, Bear, and Rogan are all huge characters on every season they're on and bring competition and drama. Joss brings competition too. 

But the Brits are trash as well. Esther, Idris, Nicole Bass, Sean, and Zahida were horrific, Jenny and Joss are probably done since they're boring, Kyle should be done since he has no more storylines, and Melissa won't be on next season. In my opinion, only Ashley Cain, Bear, Big T, Georgia, Kayleigh, Rogan, and Theo will probably do another season. That's under half of the Brits that have done this show.

joss will be back before Ashley Cain or Kayleigh imo. Just from a competitive standpoint and because of "Jogan" they would bring him back whereas they paid Ashley dust and Kayleigh they gave her a ghost/villain/bad competitor edit so she's not likely to be back 

Yeah but he's super boring. I don't remember if it was Pink or someone else, but someone here said that getting dropped from WOTW should've been a wake up call for him to start contributing from a drama standpoint.

i don't disagree, he's boring, but I think he'll be back before the others just from a competitive standpoint and that he's Rogan's right hand man and Rogan is becoming a central character 

There's plenty of competition on the male side though, Joss isn't needed. An equally boring female like Jenny is much more likely to keep coming back than him just because she's a girl

again, I don't disagree, but don't be shocked when you see joss on the cast list for 36 or 37 cause we all know casting doesn't make sense sometimes 

You're probably right. Personally I'd rather they bring back Darrell, Brad or even Derrick if they want to bring back a strong male 

Darrell yes, a million times yes. Brad announced his official retirement so doubt we'll see him and Derrick is the absolute worst so hard pass lol

AshtonMartin#466

Have Cara cast on every season and Bananas never comes back on or Have Camila return for 2 seasons and never see CT and Bananas again.

AshtonMartin#467

Imma do another too lmao

Have Landon, Abram , Coral, and Theresa return or Darrell, Frank S, Cooke, and Nia return

FromTheNorth#468

Have Cara cast on every season and Bananas never comes back on or Have Camila return for 2 seasons and never see CT and Bananas again.

Easy, Camila back and the old men gone. I'd rather have Camila then Cara on at this point so this is a no brainer

FromTheNorth#469

Imma do another too lmao

Have Landon, Abram , Coral, and Theresa return or Darrell, Frank S, Cooke, and Nia return

This ones harder, I'd kill for all 8 to come back. Second one though since all four can bring it and Frank, Cooke & Nia were just getting warmed up

deeper#470

Have Cara cast on every season and Bananas never comes back on or Have Camila return for 2 seasons and never see CT and Bananas again.

camila for 2 seasons 

deeper#471

Imma do another too lmao

Have Landon, Abram , Coral, and Theresa return or Darrell, Frank S, Cooke, and Nia return

im gonna go with Darrell, frank, Cooke, and nia. 

Psy4potato#472

Imma do another too lmao

Have Landon, Abram , Coral, and Theresa return or Darrell, Frank S, Cooke, and Nia return

first group, though I would swap In Darrell for Theresa.

Funnier worst speech ever: Ayanna on Sexes 2 or Amazing Race Jenn on TM

anon333334#473

Legend Ayanna who slept in her uniform last night cause she wanted to win today >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

dylan76#474

Ayanna's iconic speech for sure!!!  Jenn's little rambling was just painful to watch.

rideordie95#475

Ninja or Nicole Zanatta?

Idris or Jozea?

Psy4potato#476

Legend Ayanna who slept in her uniform last night cause she wanted to win today >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

lol yessssss

Psy4potato#477

Ninja or Nicole Zanatta?

Idris or Jozea?

Nicole.

Inferno 1 or Inferno 2

anon333334#478

Ninja or Nicole Zanatta?

Idris or Jozea?

Ninja & Idris

anon23423234ffs...#479

Ninja or Nicole Zanatta?

Idris or Jozea?

Is there a none option I can choose?

aura#480

Nicole Bass or Zahida?

anon23423234ffs...#481

Ninja or Nicole Zanatta?

Idris or Jozea?

Nicole.

Inferno 1 or Inferno 2

Inferno 2

Evelyn & Paula or Emily & Paula?

Related Topics

The ChallengeBig Brother