Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

depends, I would probably go with the challenge cast on ayto cuz they seem more chillhave a battle of the exes 3 season or a older vs younger season where the teams are 30+ and 29- (basically older te...

— TheNostalgiaGirl

depends, I would probably go with the challenge cast on ayto cuz they seem more chillhave a battle of the exes 3 season or a older vs younger season where the teams are 30+ and 29- (basically older te...

— torstar

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: This or That?

TheNostalgiaGirl ·

depends, I would probably go with the challenge cast on ayto cuz they seem more chill

have a battle of the exes 3 season or a older vs younger season where the teams are 30+ and 29- (basically older team is anyone aged 30 and above and younger is anyone aged 29 and younger)

30 Comments
TheNostalgiaGirl#392

depends, I would probably go with the challenge cast on ayto cuz they seem more chill

have a battle of the exes 3 season or a older vs younger season where the teams are 30+ and 29- (basically older team is anyone aged 30 and above and younger is anyone aged 29 and younger)

torstar#393
depends, I would probably go with the challenge cast on ayto cuz they seem more chillhave a battle of the exes 3 season or a older vs younger season where the teams are 30+ and 29- (basically older team is anyone aged 30 and above and younger is anyone aged 29 and younger)

battle of the exes 3 because I loved both the first and second BOTE and I think we now have so many messy ayto couples that would be great for it

BOTE 1 or 2 

TheNostalgiaGirl#394

bote 2

rivals 1 or rivals 3

torstar#395
bote 2rivals 1 or rivals 3

rivals 1 

Adam and Ct as rivals or Wes and Kenny 

TheNostalgiaGirl#396

adam and ct

evan or kenny

nevidcm#397

Wes and Kenny (I can't stand either Kenny or Adam, but Wes >>>>>>>>>> CT)

Favorite doormat: Jennifer or Jenna

nevidcm#398
adam and ctevan or kenny

evan for sureeee

torstar#399
Wes and Kenny (I can't stand either Kenny or Adam, but Wes >>>>>>>>>> CT)Favorite doormat: Jennifer or Jenna

Jenna

Skeletons or Explosions 

TheNostalgiaGirl#400

explosions

amber and ethan or taylor and andre

nevidcm#401

both annoying but if i had to choose, amber and ethan

favorite Nicole: Ramos or Zanatta

Daddy DAF#402

Ramos

Watch Bananas win another 2 seasons or be roommates with aryan mike and giotardo for 6 months

nevidcm#403
RamosWatch Bananas win another 2 seasons or be roommates with aryan mike and giotardo for 6 months

Even if the option was to watch Bananas win for 10 more seasons or live just a day with them two, I would still go with Bananas winning

idk what to ask

torstar#404
RamosWatch Bananas win another 2 seasons or be roommates with aryan mike and giotardo for 6 months

watch bananas win every single challenge to come over the latter

bloodlines or BOTS2 

Daddy DAF#405

bots2

be forced to watch camilas youre gonna die clip for 2 hours straight or be locked in a room with dione and chris from gbgh for 30 mins

torstar#406
bots2be forced to watch camilas youre gonna die clip for 2 hours straight or be locked in a room with dione and chris from gbgh for 30 mins

Camilas clip 

Gio's music or Andre's music 

TheNostalgiaGirl#407

be locked with camila

have brandon be your challenge partner or shavoun

Daddy DAF#408

andres

inferno 2 or gauntlet 2

Challengefan134#409

Gauntlet 2

fresh meat or bloodlines

Daddy DAF#410

fresh meat

Battle of the Sexes or Battle of the Seasons

rwportland2#411

Battle of the Sexes.

a full season of Brad/Tori storylines or a full season of Zach/Jenna storylines?

rwportland2#412
bots2be forced to watch camilas youre gonna die clip for 2 hours straight or be locked in a room with dione and chris from gbgh for 30 mins

this made me crack up

Daddy DAF#413
Battle of the Sexes.a full season of Brad/Tori storylines or a full season of Zach/Jenna storylines?

brad/tori. i cant stand both zach and jenna. brad at least i like him even if its with tori...

a season where cara mara victimizes herself every episode and makes the final or a season where bananas wins 

Challengefan134#414

Cara bein the victim...

susie/sarah or susie/cara

rwportland2#415

Susie/Cara cause I like Cara Z.

rwportland2#416

One season with your #1 favorite challenger and your #1 least favorite challenger or one season without either. 

So for example a Darrell/Evan casting in one season or neither. 

LucciVee#417

Biggest Doormat: Jenna or Jenn (Bad Blood)

KChallenge10#418
Biggest Doormat: Jenna or Jenn (Bad Blood)

\

Jenn by far. She's bad to the point where I wouldn't be shocked if Peter put his hands on her. 

rwportland2#419

For all the john and camila haters,

if you could go back in time, would you rather prevent Camila from ever doing Cutthroat and being associated with the challenge or having John get banned around the same time Evan and Kenny were?

AllHailKingNanners#420
xHollyangel wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

rideordie95 wrote: X Battle or Handcuffs? 

Handcuffs because there are more rounds and it allows for people to wrestle around more.The Duel format or Free Agents format?

Free Agents format since it doesn't allow as much of an alliance on an individual game as the Duel did(especially the Duel2)The Ruins (Champions vs Challengers) or Gauntlet 3 (Veterans vs Rookies)?

The Ruins. All day everyday. Kenny or Evan? 

Kenny, better competitor and funnier, miss the JEK days

HonestTea101#421
badladjj wrote:

xHollyangel wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:
rideordie95 wrote: X Battle or Handcuffs? 

Handcuffs because there are more rounds and it allows for people to wrestle around more.The Duel format or Free Agents format?

Free Agents format since it doesn't allow as much of an alliance on an individual game as the Duel did(especially the Duel2)The Ruins (Champions vs Challengers) or Gauntlet 3 (Veterans vs Rookies)?

The Ruins. All day everyday. Kenny or Evan? 

Kenny, better competitor and funnier, miss the JEK days

Related Topics

The ChallengeThe Amazing RaceCast Spoilers