The Challenge: This or That?

nevidcm · 2026-03-21

Thread with 31 posts about The Challenge: This or That?. Topics: Cara, Emily, Would, Seasons, Cutthroat. Part of the Vevmo community archive.

Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2...

— nevidcm

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: This or That? with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

Cara for sure, she's hilarious

Fresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

30 Comments

nevidcm#32

June 15, 2016 - 6:06pm

Cara for sure, she's hilarious

Fresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

nevidcm#33

June 15, 2016 - 6:06pm

torstar wrote:

RobbKingo wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Cutthroat or The Ruins?

CutthroatEmily S. or Laurel?

Emily S. No Contest.Battle of the Seasons(2002) or Battle of the Seasons(2012)?

BOTS 2002.Paula or Svetlana for a partner?

Svetlana. Loved her. Who would you rather see back?Cara or Susie?

Cara. Susie can stay home.Inferno 1 or Inferno 2?

Ugh though one but Inferno 1

Debut Album#34

June 15, 2016 - 6:09pm

Cara for sure, she's hilariousFresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 2.

Gauntlet 3 or Inferno 3?

xHollyangel#35

June 15, 2016 - 6:13pm

RobbKingo wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Cutthroat or The Ruins?

CutthroatEmily S. or Laurel?

Emily S. No Contest.Battle of the Seasons(2002) or Battle of the Seasons(2012)?

BOTS 2002.Paula or Svetlana for a partner?

Svetlana. Loved her. Who would you rather see back?Cara or Susie?

Would rather see Cara cuz she was hot but game wise Susie would be cool to see how can she hang.

Most shocking -> CT punching Adam.K on Duel 2 or Brad going at it with Darrell at Ruins?

anon333334#36

June 15, 2016 - 6:14pm

I honestly preferred Oppenheimer lol

Emily Bailey or Emily Schromm?

Debut Album#37

June 15, 2016 - 6:16pm

torstar wrote:

RobbKingo wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Cutthroat or The Ruins?

CutthroatEmily S. or Laurel?

Emily S. No Contest.Battle of the Seasons(2002) or Battle of the Seasons(2012)?

BOTS 2002.Paula or Svetlana for a partner?

Svetlana. Loved her. Who would you rather see back?Cara or Susie?

Would rather see Cara cuz she was hot but game wise Susie would be cool to see how can she hang.Most shocking -> CT punching Adam.K on Duel 2 or Brad going at it with Darrell at Ruins?

Brad/Darrell. Darrell has gotten into it with people on this show before but I never thought he would actually beat someone's *** like that.

Gauntlet 1 or Gauntlet 2.

Debut Album#38

June 15, 2016 - 6:17pm

I honestly preferred Oppenheimer lolEmily Bailey or Emily Schromm?

Emily S. Bailey was a huge *****(but entertaining though).

anon333334#39

June 15, 2016 - 6:19pm

xHollyangel wrote:

torstar wrote:

RobbKingo wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Cutthroat or The Ruins?

CutthroatEmily S. or Laurel?

Emily S. No Contest.Battle of the Seasons(2002) or Battle of the Seasons(2012)?

BOTS 2002.Paula or Svetlana for a partner?

Svetlana. Loved her. Who would you rather see back?Cara or Susie?

Would rather see Cara cuz she was hot but game wise Susie would be cool to see how can she hang.Most shocking -> CT punching Adam.K on Duel 2 or Brad going at it with Darrell at Ruins?

Brad/Darrell. Darrell has gotten into it with people on this show before but I never thought he would actually beat someone's *** like that.Gauntlet 1 or Gauntlet 2.

That one is hard. I'll roll with Gauntlet......1.

AlwaysAMess#40

June 15, 2016 - 6:46pm

How about Nia or Coral?

Nia. Coral is cool too, though.

Bananas or Vince?

hardbitten#41

June 15, 2016 - 6:49pm

Who would you rather have on your team? Danny (X-treme) or Danny (Austin)

Austin-Danny

hardbitten#42

June 15, 2016 - 6:49pm

Bananas or Vince?

Suicide.

hardbitten#43

June 15, 2016 - 6:50pm

Emily Bailey or Emily Schromm?

May have to say Emily B. on this one. I like Scromm, but Bailey seems like she'd be the easiest to work with.

Debut Album#44

June 15, 2016 - 6:51pm

LucciVee wrote:

How about Nia or Coral?

Nia. Coral is cool too, though.Bananas or Vince?

Vince. He's the lesser of two evils.

Mark Long or Eric Nies?

hardbitten#45

June 15, 2016 - 6:51pm

Fresh Meat 1 or Fresh Meat 2

Fresh Meat 1

hardbitten#46

June 15, 2016 - 6:52pm

Mark Long or Eric Nies?

Eric Nies

Adam R. or Adam K.

Debut Album#47

June 15, 2016 - 6:54pm

Debut Album wrote:

Mark Long or Eric Nies?

Eric NiesAdam R. or Adam K.

Adam R.

Marie or Latoya?

nevidcm#48

June 15, 2016 - 6:54pm

Debut Album wrote:

Mark Long or Eric Nies?

Eric NiesAdam R. or Adam K.

Adam R and is no contest

Veronica or Katie

nevidcm#49

June 15, 2016 - 6:54pm

hardbitten wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Mark Long or Eric Nies?

Eric NiesAdam R. or Adam K.

Adam R.Marie or Latoya?

I love me some Latoya, but have to go with Marie

hardbitten#50

June 15, 2016 - 6:56pm

hardbitten wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Mark Long or Eric Nies?

Eric NiesAdam R. or Adam K.

Adam R.Marie or Latoya?

LaToya

AlwaysAMess#51

June 15, 2016 - 6:56pm

Adam R. or Adam K.

Adam R. He was crazy, but entertaining. The only things memorable about Adam K. were his stripping and tiny hands lmao.

Rivals 2 or Rivals 3?

hardbitten#52

June 15, 2016 - 6:56pm

hardbitten wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Mark Long or Eric Nies?

Eric NiesAdam R. or Adam K.

Adam R and is no contestVeronica or Katie

Katie

Battle of the Sexes 1 or Battle of the Sexes 2

hardbitten#53

June 15, 2016 - 6:57pm

hardbitten wrote:

Adam R. or Adam K.

Adam R. He was crazy, but entertaining. The only things memorable about Adam K. were his stripping and tiny hands lmao.Rivals 2 or Rivals 3?

Dead. I probably should have said Adam King.

Rivals 2. Hands down.

hardbitten#54

June 15, 2016 - 7:00pm

Brandon Nelson or Brandon Swift

nevidcm#55

June 15, 2016 - 7:01pm

nevidcm wrote:

hardbitten wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Mark Long or Eric Nies?

Eric NiesAdam R. or Adam K.

Adam R and is no contestVeronica or Katie

KatieBattle of the Sexes 1 or Battle of the Sexes 2

Battle of the Sexes 1 cause of Queen Ellen

Camila or Theresa

nevidcm#56

June 15, 2016 - 7:01pm

Brandon Nelson or Brandon Swift

None of the above

AlwaysAMess#57

June 15, 2016 - 7:06pm

Camila or Theresa

Hmm, this is tough because I didn't love Theresa as much as I should've until Exes 2. I feel Camila's appearances have been more consistent, so I guess her. Theresa is still a queen, though!

Cooke & Cara or Emily & Paula?

AlwaysAMess#58

June 15, 2016 - 7:09pm

AlwaysAMess wrote:

hardbitten wrote:Adam R. or Adam K.

Adam R. He was crazy, but entertaining. The only things memorable about Adam K. were his stripping and tiny hands lmao.Rivals 2 or Rivals 3?

Dead. I probably should have said Adam King. Rivals 2. Hands down.

LMAOOO I thought you meant Adam Kuhn's ***** ***. Adam King is forgettable too, though.

hardbitten#59

June 15, 2016 - 7:13pm

hardbitten wrote:

Brandon Nelson or Brandon Swift

None of the above

Ima kick you in that jaw

hardbitten#60

June 15, 2016 - 7:14pm

Camila or Theresa

Camila

hardbitten#61

June 15, 2016 - 7:14pm

Cooke & Cara or Emily & Paula?

Emily & Paula

Behind the Screen: The Challenge: This or That?

Thread Summary

Related Topics