The Challenge: All Stars 6 - Preseason Useless Speculation Thread

In the bringing up of Mallory, Ellen, and others.

I realized looking at wikipedia we have so many people who played only one time that easily should have been brough back.Belou (RR Europe), Kameelah (Boston), Sharon (RW London), Stephen (RW Seattle), Chadwick (RR Australia), Josh (RR Latin America), Tara (RR Northern Trail), Linette (Fresh Meat), Sandy (Fresh Meat 2), Angel (RR Viewers Revenge), Brittani (RW Hollywood)

Belou was my profile pic on Vevmo for the longest time. Love my female Dutch rapper.

Mark is saying that Mallory is down for All Stars 6.

They'll cast Zara instead.

Which would be a better choice.

You're an idiot. Like why are you even in the All-Star thread?

Who are you coughing at? Lmao

Mallory sucked competitively and was devoid of a personality , yes I'd rather see Zara get a spot over her. Some OGs just sucked. There's multiple other women I'd rather be on here.

She was a D1 soccer player that would gave been the face of the show had she been a regular but she was successful as a model and moved on. 

She didn't do well in the actual challenges on the show. There's maybe one I remember she did decent in. 

Her background didn't translate well on her first season. Competitively she was a flop.

She didn't do well in the actual challenges on the show. There's maybe one I remember she did decent in.  Her background didn't translate well on her first season. Competitively she was a flop.

Maybe she's trained in transferring chicken feed by mouth since then.

Mallory is absolutely welcome back. Same with Tara, Dan, Genesis, Cooke, and a few other mfs.

She didn't do well in the actual challenges on the show. There's maybe one I remember she did decent in.  Her background didn't translate well on her first season. Competitively she was a flop.

Maybe she's trained in transferring chicken feed by mouth since then.

lol I legit laughed reading this - you win for best comment 

In the bringing up of Mallory, Ellen, and others.

I realized looking at wikipedia we have so many people who played only one time that easily should have been brough back.Belou (RR Europe), Kameelah (Boston), Sharon (RW London), Stephen (RW Seattle), Chadwick (RR Australia), Josh (RR Latin America), Tara (RR Northern Trail), Linette (Fresh Meat), Sandy (Fresh Meat 2), Angel (RR Viewers Revenge), Brittani (RW Hollywood)

Irulan Wilson Lori Trespicio Rachel Braband...a lot of women were under utilized 

Mark is saying that Mallory is down for All Stars 6.

They'll cast Zara instead.

Which would be a better choice.

You're an idiot. Like why are you even in the All-Star thread?

Who are you coughing at? Lmao

Mallory sucked competitively and was devoid of a personality , yes I'd rather see Zara get a spot over her. Some OGs just sucked. There's multiple other women I'd rather be on here.

She was a D1 soccer player that would gave been the face of the show had she been a regular but she was successful as a model and moved on. 

She didn't do well in the actual challenges on the show. There's maybe one I remember she did decent in. 

Her background didn't translate well on her first season. Competitively she was a flop.

She did well in the challenges...very well. Rewatch the episodes starting with the climbing one. She was disappointed because she wanted to be better than everyone even the guys which she wasn't but she has the potential to do so.  I don't even think she was 21 when that season filmed. 

She was not that good in challenges I just rewatched it last year and my first thought about her was how underwhelming she was to be that tall with that athletic of a background.

Youre free to rewatch but I know what im talking about. 

There's at least 5 girls off the top of my head I could safely put over Mallory and everyone else I'm just largely forgetting. Even Katie had her moments since she was there so long.

There's at least 5 girls off the top of my head I could safely put over Mallory and everyone else I'm just largely forgetting. Even Katie had her moments since she was there so long.

Lol

Mallory was a basic blue eye brunette white girl with no personality. She would have MEGA simps for no reason if she debuted today 

Not sure who the strongest real world woman on the inferno 1 was. Mallory did nothing to stand out among the others. She was definitely one of their strongest women but was pretty much on the same level as Julie or even Coral. That being said, would've been nice for her to have done at least another season or two. I welcome her to all stars anyday AND she isn't that big of a deal either. Both things can be true.

They weren't lifting weights or doing pushups. They were transferring bird feed in bird outfits, parking cars, eating cookies, and selling items on the streets of Mexico. So you can't argue who was great and who wasn't. You don't like her. She won't be on. Keep it moving.

I wouldn't mind her back - who woudl have guessed Steve would have came back and been invited to multiple seasons and do well. She's an OG - I'd prefer her over people like Big T, Fessy, Corey, Turbo, etc on all stars. 

Ok so in that case we shouldn't discuss who was or wasn't good that season or era at all.

They did do physical stuff, she was lackluster. Idk why we're up in arms over that. They would show the  times of the entire cast this isn't hidden information.

I mean if Leah came back there's no reason why Mallory can't. Seems like OGs had a better chance at being cast on All Stars 1 & 2 though. Clearly it changed starting All Stars 3 when they decided to put Tara and Dan as alts and All Stars 4 with Genesis.

Who were the alts for AS5?

Mallory was a basic blue eye brunette white girl with no personality. She would have MEGA simps for no reason if she debuted today 

Malloy was basic? Lol.  The fact anyone thinks not being an idiot means you don't have a personality is absurd.  Mallory Holly S Christena and Rachel B were all relatively quiet on The Challenge but great additions that needed more opportunity.  People creating fake drama or crying every 30 second doesn't give them a personality.  It's like saying Kaycee doesn't have a personality. 

Mallory was a basic blue eye brunette white girl with no personality. She would have MEGA simps for no reason if she debuted today 

Malloy was basic? Lol.  The fact anyone thinks not being an idiot means you don't have a personality is absurd.  Mallory Holly S Christena and Rachel B were all relatively quiet on The Challenge but great additions that needed more opportunity.  People creating fake drama or crying every 30 second doesn't give them a personality.  It's like saying Kaycee doesn't have a personality. 

This man is literally in one thread trying to save Marie had no impact on The Challenge but them in another trying to act like Mallory, Rachel B, Christena, and Kasey had an impact. It's scary how dumb this idiot is but thinks he is always right. Sociopathic behavior. Hide yalls wives and kids, KVDahmer is coming for you! 

Mallory was a basic blue eye brunette white girl with no personality. She would have MEGA simps for no reason if she debuted today 

Malloy was basic? Lol.  The fact anyone thinks not being an idiot means you don't have a personality is absurd.  Mallory Holly S Christena and Rachel B were all relatively quiet on The Challenge but great additions that needed more opportunity.  People creating fake drama or crying every 30 second doesn't give them a personality.  It's like saying Kaycee doesn't have a personality. 

This man is literally in one thread trying to save Marie had no impact on The Challenge but them in another trying to act like Mallory, Rachel B, Christena, and Kasey had an impact. It's scary how dumb this idiot is but thinks he is always right. Sociopathic behavior. Hide yalls wives and kids, KVDahmer is coming for you! 

Marie > Christena > Rachel B > Mallory > > > > > > > Kaycee

Mallory was a basic blue eye brunette white girl with no personality. She would have MEGA simps for no reason if she debuted today 

 I wonder if she replaced Parvati when she dropped from RW Paris last minute.

I always think about how different it would have been if Parvati was a challenger instead of a survivor

Mallory was a basic blue eye brunette white girl with no personality. She would have MEGA simps for no reason if she debuted today 

 I wonder if she replaced Parvati when she dropped from RW Paris last minute.

I always think about how different it would have been if Parvati was a challenger instead of a survivor

thats funny, I didnt know that about Parv but I do think they look very similar so I could see that being the case.  

honestly Parv got the better hand (I think). Never watched survivor but I heard about her gameplay for decades. I dont think that happens with any challengers.

I loved watching Mallory and Christena's friendship during The Inferno.

Mallory was a basic blue eye brunette white girl with no personality. She would have MEGA simps for no reason if she debuted today 

Malloy was basic? Lol.  The fact anyone thinks not being an idiot means you don't have a personality is absurd.  Mallory Holly S Christena and Rachel B were all relatively quiet on The Challenge but great additions that needed more opportunity.  People creating fake drama or crying every 30 second doesn't give them a personality.  It's like saying Kaycee doesn't have a personality. 

This man is literally in one thread trying to save Marie had no impact on The Challenge but them in another trying to act like Mallory, Rachel B, Christena, and Kasey had an impact. It's scary how dumb this idiot is but thinks he is always right. Sociopathic behavior. Hide yalls wives and kids, KVDahmer is coming for you! 

Where did I say they had impact?   They were underutilized while Marie was overused. 

Rachel B was great on the Gauntlet - I loved her friendship with Sarah G.  I was sad neither ever came back. 

I mean if Leah came back there's no reason why Mallory can't. Seems like OGs had a better chance at being cast on All Stars 1 & 2 though. Clearly it changed starting All Stars 3 when they decided to put Tara and Dan as alts and All Stars 4 with Genesis.

Who were the alts for AS5?

every time I remember those three names as ALTS I get mad.  And good call - did we ever find out who was alts for Season 5?

Jenn and Tyri were dropped for AS5, idk if they were made alts.

I don't recall any other names being stated.

Jenn and Tyri were dropped for AS5, idk if they were made alts.

I don't recall any other names being stated.

Were they supposed to be rivals?  Or they were just names up for it at some point?  Would have loved to see Jenn back in the mix again, it's been a long time. 

Trishelle and Steven were a pair at some point.

Were they supposed to be rivals?  Or they were just names up for it at some point?  Would have loved to see Jenn back in the mix again, it's been a long time. 

Yes I remember it was stated they were intended to be a pair.