The Challenge: All Stars 6- Pointless Early Speculation

I just want a Duel--winner is safe, winner votes in someone, that person can pick anyone to go against other than the person who won.  It's the only way "last not going in" makes any sense.

A team format is great in theory but we know it won't work in reality. 

Also, the format on S40 was actually pretty good--just sucks that Era 1 was so bad.

Also, the format on S40 was actually pretty good--just sucks that Era 1 was so bad.

No, it was terrible. It creates a rotation or volunteer system. I'm sick of people volunteering.

Also, the format on S40 was actually pretty good--just sucks that Era 1 was so bad.

No, it was terrible. It creates a rotation or volunteer system. I'm sick of people volunteering.

No one had to volunteer--the winner of elimination nominated people.  Blame the cast for not forcing them to make tough decisions not the format.

Cast better.

Stupid format. Boring results proved it. No drama proved it. Stale. Dry. Stupid. Much like you, so no wonder you liked it

It was terrible, most of the cast knew they where safe before every mission. There's no tension. What they should have done was not reveal who the person picked until after the mission. Not much better but it would help.

Stupid format. Boring results proved it. No drama proved it. Stale. Dry. Stupid. Much like you, so no wonder you liked it

Because the cast made it easy on others.  Literally only Josh wasn't willing to do that.

It was terrible, most of the cast knew they where safe before every mission. There's no tension. What they should have done was not reveal who the person picked until after the mission. Not much better but it would help.

You could add that twist but knowing who was nominated created strategy--as we saw with Laurel taking out Emily.   Not happy she did it but it was gameplay.

IMO even the best formats only last long enough to be interesting for 6 to 8 episodes. USA2 is S-Tier and it was getting boring by the midway point switch.

As long as we get a fantastic Team vs Team format for 8 episodes, with an entertaining cast that's playing hard, we'll be feasting.

Realistic Cast of 28 - Assuming Coral, Marie, Irulan etc. will continue to flake.

2 Teams of 14

No one from 41

Champs vs Contenders

I'm going with:

Teck isn't coming back. Dan isn't getting cast, it's already been said they think he looks too rough. No one wants Averey she is so boring. Melinda is a waste, she is bringing nothing. Nurys makes no sense with this cast. Jodi is another waste and total bore. There's not enough diversity. One black woman and one Dominican?

Teck isn't coming back. Dan isn't getting cast, it's already been said they think he looks too rough. No one wants Averey she is so boring. Melinda is a waste, she is bringing nothing. Nurys makes no sense with this cast. Jodi is another waste and total bore. There's not enough diversity. One black woman and one Dominican?

No diversity what? Nearly half the cast is POC!

To get cast on All Stars, I think you need to do/be one of the below, in order of importance:

1. A fan favorite

2. Bring drama

3. Funny/Rootable and Good in Confessionals

4. A Champ

5. Really, really good looking

Everyone above fits the criteria in one way or another. Would I put Coral, Marie, and Irulan on the cast? Sure. But they're not coming.

Fixing your decent cast, making it realistic, and that would appeal to current and OG fans.

Champs

Darrell

Frank

John

Kefla

Wes

Yes

Zach

Coral (Christena RR12 alt, Jonna 3rd)

Holly S

Julie

Veronica

Sarah

Susie

Kina (Tori H alt, Ashley M 3rd)

Contenders

Chadwick

Danny J 

Jeremy

Laterrian

Leroy

Marlon

Pete

Irulan 

Latoya

Marie

Mallory

Kailah

Nany

Tina

All Stars 6 getting greenlit?! AMAZING news

Hoping for some (aka ANY) of:

Kina / Julie / Ellen / Tori Hall / Susie / Mandi / Carley / Jenn / Emily B / Coral / Paula / Kim / Sandy / Kailah / Devyn / Cooke /  Nicole Ramos / Amber M

Eric Nies / Marlon / Hunter / Trey / Jamie Murray / Dan R / Frank R / Danny J / Davis / Dunbar / Pete / Dustin / Robb / Adam Kuhn / Chuck / Asaf

Would love to see All Star Vets vs Rookies

Vets

Darrell, Shane, Kefla, Steve, Brad, Syrus, Tony, Cohutta (alts Jay, LT)

Veronica, Tina, Roni, Ayanna, Kendal, Casey, Ashley M, Laurel (alts Katie, Ruthie)

Rookies

Abe, Antoine, Landon, Noor, CJ, David/Tokyo, Mike L, Zack (alt Issac, Chet)

Coral, Julie, Melissa, Brianna, Kim, Susie, Sarah, Angel (alts Cooke, Elka)

They cast Sam--they don't care about looks

Sam is a pretty girl just plus-sized. Dan looks like a 70 year old living on the streets since he was last on the Inferno 3.

Sam is a pretty girl just plus-sized. Dan looks like a 70 year old living on the streets since he was last on the Inferno 3.

She is not "a pretty girl" and never has been.  No clue what Dan looks like but we can't pretend looks are a deal breaker.   Wasn't he even an alternate?

I agree that Exes won't work for All-stars especially if producers are going to actually stick to Era 1-3 people. 

I think the format that caused the most drama was Ruins. They should bring that voting system back if they can get a cast of 28-32 people to do it.

Just some things I want to see:

Only Era 1-3 people. Minimal AYTO if they are going to cast any Era 3's. 

Hey rid of the dumb star system. Didn't like it on AS4 and AS5.

And they stop editing all the drama. We were promised AS4 was drama and they only showed a quarter of it.

Make the missions a good mix of Physical and Mental. I think AS2 has done this the best so far.

Sam is a pretty girl just plus-sized. Dan looks like a 70 year old living on the streets since he was last on the Inferno 3.

Dan looks ROUGH.  He was fun on Battle of the Sexes and Inferno 2.....bit I agree he is not going to look right on camera 

Sam looks like a typical. Not a bad thing but let's not be delusional.

Stupid format. Boring results proved it. No drama proved it. Stale. Dry. Stupid. Much like you, so no wonder you liked it

I liked season 40

The season 40 format should've been where guys target guys and girls target girls. Also ppl who weren't eager to volunteer were called a snake like Jonna. Fhuk era 3 for that

I want a team season so bad but they have to learn the art of sitting people out so that it's fair. I know they are really incompetent but that is just so basic.

you would think it would be easy. They could easily get drama off who they bench too. But nah production cant ever do it right

I agree that Exes won't work for All-stars especially if producers are going to actually stick to Era 1-3 people. 

I think the format that caused the most drama was Ruins. They should bring that voting system back if they can get a cast of 28-32 people to do it.

agreed. Exes is at least 15 years too late for the OGs. Exes is good for young and dumb people. Not for married people.

Stupid format. Boring results proved it. No drama proved it. Stale. Dry. Stupid. Much like you, so no wonder you liked it

I liked season 40

You didn't like 40. You liked seeing Rachel make it all the way to the end.

Mike Lewis keeps pushing Exes on twitter which could not be a worse choice.

Let'a be perfectly clear: an Exes with this casting pool will completely flop, there will be no drama, and All Stars will get cancelled.

It will be Jordan/Tori, Kaycee/Nany, Bananas/Moriah. Barf.

Mike Lewis keeps pushing Exes on twitter which could not be a worse choice.

Let'a be perfectly clear: an Exes with this casting pool will completely flop, there will be no drama, and All Stars will get cancelled.

It will be Jordan/Tori, Kaycee/Nany, Bananas/Moriah. Barf.

We dont get drama anyway

I'm anti-Exes but Rivals was used which rarely creates drama.   And, yes, if willing we'd get Jordan/Tori, John/Moriah, Kaycee/Nany but we might get them anyway.  

Maybe Zach/Jonna get paired together and he has to apologize all season to her lol.

Seriously hate the idea but it's no different than anything else.  All comes down to execution 

Kvm hates the idea because it'll remind him of how miserable and lonely his life is with his blowup doll from 2001 that looks like a winter wonderland because he's never bothered to wash her plastic áss, in an attempt to replicate the same lack of hygiene standards he lives by day in and day out. At nearly 50, of course he'd hate an Exes season.