Behind the Screen: Survivor Fantasy casts

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Survivor Kenya: All StarsLocation: Tsavo East National ParkTembo(Elephant):Brad Culpepper (BloodvsWater)Marty Piombo (Nicaragua)Andrea Boehlke (Redemption Island)Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)Vifaru(Rhinocer...

— melm3

Survivor Madagascarworlds apart 2Massif Tribe (WhiteCollar)BradStephenShaneAbi MariaCorrineTashaAltora Tribe(Blue collar)HaydenJeremyTonyCieraDeniseStephanieKinkony Tribe (No Collar)FabioKenMalcolmAnd...

— Challenge 17

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about Survivor Fantasy casts with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

Survivor Fantasy casts

melm3 ·

Survivor Kenya: All Stars

Location: Tsavo East National Park
Tembo(Elephant):
Brad Culpepper (BloodvsWater)
Marty Piombo (Nicaragua)
Andrea Boehlke (Redemption Island)
Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)
Vifaru(Rhinoceros):
Jeremey Collins (San Juan del Sur)
Malcolm Freberg (Philippines)
Baylor Wilson (San Juan del Sur)
Jane Bright (Nicaragua)
Nyati(Buffalo):
Hayden Moss (BloodvsWater)
Troyzan Robertson (One World)
Abi-Maria Gomes (Philippines)
Kass McQuillen (Cagayan)
Simba(Lion):
Josh Canfield (San Juan del Sur)
Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)
Ciera Eastin (BloodvsWater)
Kim Spradlin (One World)
Chui(Leopard):
Spencer Bledsoe (Cagayan)
Jon Misch (San Juan del Sur)
RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)
Tasha Fox (Cagayan)
I only chose contestants from seasons 21 - 29. I didn't include any Worlds Apart because it's too early to tell who the standouts are going to be. I just randomized the players into the tribes.
This season starts off with 5 tribes of 4. Each tribe is named after the big five game of Africa. The 5 tribes will become 2 tribes after the 2nd tribal council. Tribe swap after 7th tribal council. Merge after 9th tribal council. 9 person jury. Final 3.
30 Comments
melm3#212

Survivor Kenya: All Stars

Location: Tsavo East National Park
Tembo(Elephant):
Brad Culpepper (BloodvsWater)
Marty Piombo (Nicaragua)
Andrea Boehlke (Redemption Island)
Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)
Vifaru(Rhinoceros):
Jeremey Collins (San Juan del Sur)
Malcolm Freberg (Philippines)
Baylor Wilson (San Juan del Sur)
Jane Bright (Nicaragua)
Nyati(Buffalo):
Hayden Moss (BloodvsWater)
Troyzan Robertson (One World)
Abi-Maria Gomes (Philippines)
Kass McQuillen (Cagayan)
Simba(Lion):
Josh Canfield (San Juan del Sur)
Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)
Ciera Eastin (BloodvsWater)
Kim Spradlin (One World)
Chui(Leopard):
Spencer Bledsoe (Cagayan)
Jon Misch (San Juan del Sur)
RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)
Tasha Fox (Cagayan)
I only chose contestants from seasons 21 - 29. I didn't include any Worlds Apart because it's too early to tell who the standouts are going to be. I just randomized the players into the tribes.
This season starts off with 5 tribes of 4. Each tribe is named after the big five game of Africa. The 5 tribes will become 2 tribes after the 2nd tribal council. Tribe swap after 7th tribal council. Merge after 9th tribal council. 9 person jury. Final 3.
Challenge 17#213

Survivor Madagascar
worlds apart 2
Massif Tribe (WhiteCollar)
Brad
Stephen
Shane
Abi Maria
Corrine
Tasha
Altora Tribe(Blue collar)
Hayden
Jeremy
Tony
Ciera
Denise
Stephanie
Kinkony Tribe (No Collar)
Fabio
Ken
Malcolm
Andrea
Morgan
Shambo

Fresh Meat#214

A dream Favorites tribe (not necessary for huge All Star seasons, but still love to see them back):

Spencer (Cagayan)
Erinn (Tocantins)
Ian (Palau)
Natalie (Samoa)
Todd (China)
Katie (Palau)
Marty (Nicaragua)
Twila (Vanuatu)
Jon (SJDS)
Courtney (China)

I love just about every person on this tribe <333

melm3#215
A dream Favorites tribe (not necessary for huge All Star seasons, but still love to see them back): Spencer (Cagayan) Erinn (Tocantins) Ian (Palau) Natalie (Samoa) Todd (China) Katie (Palau) Marty (Nicaragua) Twila (Vanuatu) Jon (SJDS) Courtney (China) I love just about every person on this tribe <333

You liked Katie from Palau?!

Fresh Meat#216

Loved her! I think she's an extremely charismatic girl who had a very intriguing storyline. I think her ftc showed she isn't really a shitty person or anything. Also listening to a podcast, it's cool to see how she prepared herself out there.

alaskak94#217

Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains 2

Heroes
Ian Rosenberger - Survivor: Palau
Yul Kwon - Survivor: Cook Islands
Michelle Yi - Survivor: Fiji
Brett Clouser - Survivor: Samoa
Chelsea Meissner - Survivor: One World
Lisa Whelchel - Survivor: Philippines
Hayden Moss - Survivor: Blood vs. Water
Spencer Bledsoe - Survivor: Cagayan
Jaclyn Schultz - Survivor: San Juan del Sur
Hali Ford - Survivor: Worlds Apart
Villains
Todd Herzog - Survivor: China
Natalie Bolton - Survivor: Micronesia
John Fincher - Survivor: Samoa
Ashley Underwood - Survivor: Redemption Island
Albert Destrade - Survivor: South Pacific
Kim Spradlin - Survivor: One World
Abi-Maria Gomes - Survivor: Philippines
Pete Yurkowski - Survivor: Philippines
Ciera Eastin - Survivor: Blood vs. Water
Reed Kelly - Survivor: San Juan del Sur
RGS#218

Not quite sure where I want the season to be yet, but I would like a Fans V.S Favorites. I would also like to see the following people:

John Cochran, Parvati Shallow, Malcom Freberg, Edward Fox and Reynold Toepfer. 

I really like them all, and I think it would be interesting to have them on another season. 

Gucci Mane#219

You lost me at Cochran.

Debut Album#220
You lost me at Cochran.

Parvati too. No need for her to return.
RealityShow Lover#221

Tony, Brenda, Malcolm, and Cochran for sure. They all make for a good survivor season.

infamous#222
You lost me at Cochran.
Parvati too. No need for her to return.

It's a good thing she said she doesn't want to. Unless it's All Winners, but that theme has been out the window for 10 seasons.

nevidcm#223
You lost me at Cochran.

My thoughts exactly

nevidcm#224

Give me Abi, Shane, Peih-Gee, Erinn and Kass and I'm good. 

anon4981298798#225

Cochroach is truly god awful, and nauseating to watch on TV. The entire Worlds Apart cast is also approaching his level as well.

anon4981298798#226

Give me Abi, Shane, Peih-Gee, Erinn and Kass and I'm good. 

And Kelly Wiglesworth.

Gucci Mane#227

I hated Kass and Abi with a passion, but they brung the entertainment and were a big part of why their respective seasons were hits.

nevidcm#228

I'm just glad that there's no RC on the ballot

Challenge 17#229
Cochroach is truly god awful, and nauseating to watch on TV. The entire Worlds Apart cast is also approaching his level as well.

No just Dan Mike and Will are nauseating IMO.
Challenge 17#230
Cochroach is truly god awful, and nauseating to watch on TV. The entire Worlds Apart cast is also approaching his level as well.

No just Dan Mike and Will are nauseating IMO.
Fresh Meat#231
Cochroach is truly god awful, and nauseating to watch on TV. The entire Worlds Apart cast is also approaching his level as well.

No just Dan Mike and Will are nauseating IMO.

Eh Will at least only has one episode of awfulness. No one else on this season is nearly as bad as Cochran though seeing as they're not developed enough to be that awful. That's really a problem imo with Carolyn, Tyler, Sierra, and Will.
anon4981298798#232

I'm just glad that there's no RC on the ballot

Speaking of the ballot...

It will be released this upcoming week. The results will be revealed at the finale, where the 20 chosen contestants will be in their in-game clothes ready to depart to Cambodia.

So, what that means is that if they're still on the island after Wednesday's episode, they are NOT eligible for season 30. Pretty much confirms this week's boot. Wink

gamer73#233

Season 31:

Males:

Greg

Jeff

Shane

Stephen

Jim

Troyzan

Hayden

John

Spencer

Jeremey

Females:

Kelley

Kimmi

Peih Gee

Stephanie

Sabrina

Abi Maria

Ciera

Tasha

Kass

So

GDInstall#234

I'm just glad that there's no RC on the ballot

Speaking of the ballot...

It will be released this upcoming week. The results will be revealed at the finale, where the 20 chosen contestants will be in their in-game clothes ready to depart to Cambodia.

So, what that means is that if they're still on the island after Wednesday's episode, they are NOT eligible for season 30. Pretty much confirms this week's boot. Wink

I'm not seeing this confirmation. I would really appreciate if you would tell me this via PM Wink
I mean they could still use them in the poll and say IF he/she does not win.

Challenge 17#235

Survivor Congo
winners vs post merge vs pre merge
Sangha Tribe(winners)
Fabio
Mike
Tony
Denise
Kim
Natalie A
Malebo Tribe(post merge)
Hayden
Malcolm
Shane
Corrine
Jenn
Morgan
Niari Tribe(pre merge)
Ace
Brad
Cliff
Alexis
So
Stephanie

Challenge 17#236

Survivor Australia
islands vs mainland, Australia because it could be considered both
Tarkine Tribe(Islands)
Carter
Eddie
Hayden
Richard
Tony
Chelsea
Denise
Morgan
Sophie
Twila
Bogong Tribe(Mainland)
Jon
JT
Mike
Rob C
Shane
Carolyn
Corrine
Natalie A
Stephanie
Theresa

alaskak94#237

Survivor: HvV 2: Power Pairs

Heroes
Aras Baskauskas
Becky Lee
Chelsea Meissner
Cirie Fields
Colby Donaldson
Ian Rosenberger
Kim Spradlin
Tina Wesson
Tom Westman
Yul Kwon
Villains
Abi-Maria Gomes
Brenda Lowe
Burton Roberts
Courtney Yates
Danielle DiLorenzo
Jon Dalton
Parvati Shallow
Pete Yurkowski
Sash Lenahan
Todd Herzog
CMJ#238

Heroes vs. Villains 2

Heroes

Mike Holloway (Worlds Apart)

Yul Kwon (Cook Islands)

Terry Dietz (Panama)

Jeremy Collins (San Juan Del Sur)

Spencer Bledsoe (Cagayan)

Tasha Fox (Cagayan)

Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)

Danni Boatwright (Guatemala)

Monica Culpepper (Blood vs. Water)

Andrea Boehike (Redemption Island)

Villains 

Rodney LaVoie Jr. (Worlds Apart)

Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)

Phillip Sheppard (Redemption Island)

Brian Heidik (Thailand)

Brad Culpepper (Blood vs. Water)

Abi Maria Gomes (Phillipines)

Kass McQuillen (Cagayan)

NaOnka Mixon (Nicaragua)

Corrine Kaplan (Gabon)

Natalie Bolton (Micronesia)

anon4981298798#239

Yessssssssssss at Monica! I loved her on Blood vs Water. She deserved way more than a single jury vote.

CMJ#240
Yessssssssssss at Monica! I loved her on Blood vs Water. She deserved way more than a single jury vote.

I love Monica! I really wanted her to win Blood vs. Water. I hope she comes back to play one more time. Her direct-to-camera interviews where unintentionally hilarious

Also, just saw this on youtube. 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hHeRWVbk9lE

CMJ#241

Survivor 2nd Chance

Tribes separated by age

50s

Carolyn Rivera (Worlds Apart)

Trish Hegarty (Cagayan)

Susie Smith (Gabon)

Troy "Troyzan" Robertson (One World)

Dale Wentworth (San Juan Del Sur)

40s

Brad Culpepper (Blood vs. Water)

Shane Powers (Panama)

Burton Roberts (Pearl Islands)

Tamara "Taj" Johnson-George (Tocantins)

Missy Payne (San Juan del Sur)

30s

Reed Kelly (San Juan Del Sur)

Adam Gentry (Cook Islands)

Stephanie Valencia (Redemption Island)

Sarah Lacina (Cagayan)

NaOnka Mixon (Nicaragua)

20s

Ken Hoang (Gabon)

Rodney LaVoie Jr. (Worlds Apart)

Carter Williams (Philippines)

Alicia Rosa (One World)

Sierra Reed (Tocantins)

Related Topics

The ChallengeSurvivorThe Amazing Race