Behind the Screen: Survivor Fantasy casts

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Survivor: Costa Rica (Brains vs...

— nevidcm

Survivor: Costa Rica (Brains vs...

— Challenge 17

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about Survivor Fantasy casts with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

Survivor Fantasy casts

nevidcm ·

Survivor: Costa Rica (Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty 2)

Brains: 

Josh Canfield (San Juan del Sur)

Rob Cesternino (The Amazon)

Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins)

Kim Spradlin (One World)

Eliza Orlins (Vanuatu)

Cirie Fields (Exile Island)

Brawn: 

Ozzy Lusth (Cook Islands)

Jeremy Collins (San Juan del Sur)

Terry Deitz (Exile Island)

RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)

Laura Morrett (Samoa)

Kelly Wiglesworth (Borneo)

Beauty: 

Jay Byars (One World)

Hayden Moss (Blood vs. Water)

Reynold Toepfer (Caramoan)

Elisabeth Filarski (The Australian Outback)

Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)

Heidi Strobel (The Amazon)

Boot order: 

18th: Rob Cesternino

17th: Cirie Fields

16th: Jeremy Collins

15th: Jay Byars

14th: Elisabeth Filarski

13th: Eliza Orlins

12th: RC Saint-Amour

11th: Ozzy Lusth

10th: Josh Canfield

9th: Brenda Lowe

8th: Reynold Toepfer

7th: Kim Spradlin

6th: Laura Morrett

5th: Terry Deitz

4th: Kelly Wiglesworth

3rd: Stephen Fishbach

2nd: Heidi Strobel

Winner: Hayden Moss

Great job and cast, what do you think of my skeleton coast cast?

I actually really liked your cast, definitely no duds, I love Baylor, Ciera, Hayden and Spencer. BTW, which Natalie is it, Anderson, Bolton, White, Tenerelli? (wow there have been a lot of Natalies)

Anderson, she's grown on me so much . Also about those other Natalie's they all made the final 4 which is pretty cool IMO. I hope she keeps the tradition.

I hated the twinnies on The Amazing Race, but Natalie has grown on me sooo much this season. I don't think she'll be going home next week, but sadly I don't see her in the final 4 (I hope I'm wrong though). 

30 Comments
nevidcm#152

Survivor: Costa Rica (Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty 2)

Brains: 

Josh Canfield (San Juan del Sur)

Rob Cesternino (The Amazon)

Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins)

Kim Spradlin (One World)

Eliza Orlins (Vanuatu)

Cirie Fields (Exile Island)

Brawn: 

Ozzy Lusth (Cook Islands)

Jeremy Collins (San Juan del Sur)

Terry Deitz (Exile Island)

RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)

Laura Morrett (Samoa)

Kelly Wiglesworth (Borneo)

Beauty: 

Jay Byars (One World)

Hayden Moss (Blood vs. Water)

Reynold Toepfer (Caramoan)

Elisabeth Filarski (The Australian Outback)

Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)

Heidi Strobel (The Amazon)

Boot order: 

18th: Rob Cesternino

17th: Cirie Fields

16th: Jeremy Collins

15th: Jay Byars

14th: Elisabeth Filarski

13th: Eliza Orlins

12th: RC Saint-Amour

11th: Ozzy Lusth

10th: Josh Canfield

9th: Brenda Lowe

8th: Reynold Toepfer

7th: Kim Spradlin

6th: Laura Morrett

5th: Terry Deitz

4th: Kelly Wiglesworth

3rd: Stephen Fishbach

2nd: Heidi Strobel

Winner: Hayden Moss

Great job and cast, what do you think of my skeleton coast cast?

I actually really liked your cast, definitely no duds, I love Baylor, Ciera, Hayden and Spencer. BTW, which Natalie is it, Anderson, Bolton, White, Tenerelli? (wow there have been a lot of Natalies)

Anderson, she's grown on me so much . Also about those other Natalie's they all made the final 4 which is pretty cool IMO. I hope she keeps the tradition.

I hated the twinnies on The Amazing Race, but Natalie has grown on me sooo much this season. I don't think she'll be going home next week, but sadly I don't see her in the final 4 (I hope I'm wrong though). 

Challenge 17#153

Survivor: Costa Rica (Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty 2)

Brains: 

Josh Canfield (San Juan del Sur)

Rob Cesternino (The Amazon)

Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins)

Kim Spradlin (One World)

Eliza Orlins (Vanuatu)

Cirie Fields (Exile Island)

Brawn: 

Ozzy Lusth (Cook Islands)

Jeremy Collins (San Juan del Sur)

Terry Deitz (Exile Island)

RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)

Laura Morrett (Samoa)

Kelly Wiglesworth (Borneo)

Beauty: 

Jay Byars (One World)

Hayden Moss (Blood vs. Water)

Reynold Toepfer (Caramoan)

Elisabeth Filarski (The Australian Outback)

Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)

Heidi Strobel (The Amazon)

Boot order: 

18th: Rob Cesternino

17th: Cirie Fields

16th: Jeremy Collins

15th: Jay Byars

14th: Elisabeth Filarski

13th: Eliza Orlins

12th: RC Saint-Amour

11th: Ozzy Lusth

10th: Josh Canfield

9th: Brenda Lowe

8th: Reynold Toepfer

7th: Kim Spradlin

6th: Laura Morrett

5th: Terry Deitz

4th: Kelly Wiglesworth

3rd: Stephen Fishbach

2nd: Heidi Strobel

Winner: Hayden Moss

Great job and cast, what do you think of my skeleton coast cast?

I actually really liked your cast, definitely no duds, I love Baylor, Ciera, Hayden and Spencer. BTW, which Natalie is it, Anderson, Bolton, White, Tenerelli? (wow there have been a lot of Natalies)

Anderson, she's grown on me so much . Also about those other Natalie's they all made the final 4 which is pretty cool IMO. I hope she keeps the tradition.

I hated the twinnies on The Amazing Race, but Natalie has grown on me sooo much this season. I don't think she'll be going home next week, but sadly I don't see her in the final 4 (I hope I'm wrong though). 


Ikr I guess they are only horrible together lol.
melm3#154

Survivor: Costa Rica (Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty 2)

Brains: 

Josh Canfield (San Juan del Sur)

Rob Cesternino (The Amazon)

Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins)

Kim Spradlin (One World)

Eliza Orlins (Vanuatu)

Cirie Fields (Exile Island)

Brawn: 

Ozzy Lusth (Cook Islands)

Jeremy Collins (San Juan del Sur)

Terry Deitz (Exile Island)

RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)

Laura Morrett (Samoa)

Kelly Wiglesworth (Borneo)

Beauty: 

Jay Byars (One World)

Hayden Moss (Blood vs. Water)

Reynold Toepfer (Caramoan)

Elisabeth Filarski (The Australian Outback)

Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)

Heidi Strobel (The Amazon)

Boot order: 

18th: Rob Cesternino

17th: Cirie Fields

16th: Jeremy Collins

15th: Jay Byars

14th: Elisabeth Filarski

13th: Eliza Orlins

12th: RC Saint-Amour

11th: Ozzy Lusth

10th: Josh Canfield

9th: Brenda Lowe

8th: Reynold Toepfer

7th: Kim Spradlin

6th: Laura Morrett

5th: Terry Deitz

4th: Kelly Wiglesworth

3rd: Stephen Fishbach

2nd: Heidi Strobel

Winner: Hayden Moss

Great job and cast, what do you think of my skeleton coast cast?

I actually really liked your cast, definitely no duds, I love Baylor, Ciera, Hayden and Spencer. BTW, which Natalie is it, Anderson, Bolton, White, Tenerelli? (wow there have been a lot of Natalies)

Anderson, she's grown on me so much . Also about those other Natalie's they all made the final 4 which is pretty cool IMO. I hope she keeps the tradition.

I hated the twinnies on The Amazing Race, but Natalie has grown on me sooo much this season. I don't think she'll be going home next week, but sadly I don't see her in the final 4 (I hope I'm wrong though). 

Ikr I guess they are only horrible together lol.

I knew people were going to like at least one of the twinnies and be rooting for them.

melm3#155

Survivor Greece: Heroes vs Villains 2

Location: Anafi Island

Olympus Tribe:(Heroes)

Jeremy Collins(San Juan del Sur)

Malcolm Freberg(Philippines)

Terry Deitz(Panama)

Spencer Bledsoe(Cagayan)

Hayden Moss(Blood vs Water)

Ciera Eastin(Blood vs Water)

Tasha Fox(Cagayan)

Holly Hoffman(Nicaragua)

Kim Spradlin(One World)

Lisa Welchel(Philippines)

Alternates: Woo Hwang(Cagayan), Jane Bright(Nicaragua)

Underworld Tribe:(Villains)

Josh Canfield(San Juan del Sur)

Shane Powers(Panama)

Tony Vlachos(Cagayan)

Marty Piombo(Nicaragua)

Brad Culpepper(Blood vs Water)

Abi-Maria Gomes(Philippines)

Corrine Kaplan(Gabon)

Twila Tanner(Vanuatu)

Kass McQuillen(Cagayan)

Baylor Wilson(San Juan del Sur)

Alternates: Pete Yurkowski(Philippines), Dawn Meehan(South Pacific)

And I know the the tribe names are kind of cheesy. Lol

JamieFire#156

I like the tribe names!!!! Haha I would love to see how Baylor and Josh interact !!

anon4981298798#157

Those tribe names are epic!!

melm3#158

Thanks guys! 

nevidcm#159
I like the tribe names!!!! Haha I would love to see how Baylor and Josh interact !!

I could see them working together again tbh, but I wouldn't trust Baylor. 

infamous#160

If only Kim would come back... not likely.

Though another HvV or All Winners (if Sandra is coming back) would be a good incentive.

anon4981298798#161

I don't see the appeal with Kim. I mean she did play a good game, but you also have to consider that she was playing with a bunch of idiots. Troyzan and Colton were her only competition. 

Give her spot to Kelly Wiglesworth.

melm3#162

The only reason I want to see Kim back is because she played with a bunch of nincompoops on her season so I want to see how she does with better players.

Challenge 17#163

I don't see the appeal with Kim. I mean she did play a good game, but you also have to consider that she was playing with a bunch of idiots. Troyzan and Colton were her only competition. 

Give her spot to Kelly Wiglesworth.


Ugh Colton sucks he was never truly competition, he had power for a little while then karma came back and bit him in the appendix.
I want to see Kim back because she was strong and I want to know how she'd stack up with veterans of the game who know what to do.
nevidcm#164

Survivor: Canary Islands

Bulevi Tribe: (Old School)

Rob Cesternino (The Amazon)

Shane Powers (Exile Island)

Richard Hatch (Borneo)

Burton Roberts (Pearl Islands)

Chris Daugherty (Vanuatu)

Heidi Strobel (The Amazon)

Kelly Goldsmith (Africa)

Twila Tanner (Vanuatu)

Elisabeth Filarski (The Australian Outback)

Helen Glover (Thailand)

Pinono Tribe: (New School)

Troyzan Robertson (One World)

Vytas Baskauskas (Blood vs. Water)

Reynold Toepfer (Caramoan)

Jeremy Collins (San Juan del Sur)

Malcolm Freberg (Philippines)

Ciera Eastin (Blood vs. Water)

Shambo Waters (Samoa)

Kass McQuillen (Cagayan)

Natalie Anderson (San Juan del Sur)

Stephanie Valencia (Redemption Island)

Merged Tribe

Fresh Meat#165

I don't see the appeal with Kim. I mean she did play a good game, but you also have to consider that she was playing with a bunch of idiots. Troyzan and Colton were her only competition. 

Give her spot to Kelly Wiglesworth.

I actually love Kelly, but she's kind of boring....like I appreciate how iconic she is as the first person to flip on her alliance and dominate challenges, but she has a very monotone voice and was a bad player to boot. Kim is probably one of the most dominant winners ever and I'd love to see her play with Tony, Denise, Sophie, Hayden, etc.

Challenge 17#166

Survivor Amazing Race
Each leg is a place survivors been
Leg 1 USA-Fiji
Leg 2 Fiji-Australia
Leg 3 Australia-Philippines
Leg 4 Philippines
Leg 5 Philippines-China
Leg 6 China- Kenya
Leg 7 Kenya-Gabon
Leg 8-Gabon- Brazil
Leg 9 Brazil
Leg 10 Brazil-Panama
Leg 11 Panama-Guatemala
Leg 12 Guatemala-USA

Abi Maria & Pete
Aras & Vytus
Brad & Monica
Cliff & Woo
Erik & Jamie
Jon & Jaclyn
Keith & Wes
Kim & Kat
Laura & Ciera
Missy & Baylor
Todd & Courtney

Challenge 17#167

Survivor Peru
Brains vs Brawn vs beauty
I added some San Juan del sur players in.
Loreto Tribe(Brains)
Jon
Tony
Rob c
Kim
Cierra
Natalie

Piura Tribe(brawn)
Brad
Malcolm
Terry
Andrea
Tasha
Denise

Junin Tribe(beauty)
Fabio
Hayden
Jay
Brenda
Jaclyn
Parvati

Challenge 17#168

Survivor Congo
All stars 2
Sangha Tribe
Eddie
Jon
Spenser
Terry
Tony
Baylor
Brenda
Corrine
Denise
Kim
Niari Tribe
Fabio
Hayden
Jeremy
Malcolm
Matty
Ciera
Jane
Natalie
Sophie
Tasha

Merged tribe

nevidcm#169
Survivor: Mongolia (Rivals)
Jon & Natalie (San Juan del Sur)
Corinne & Sugar (Gabon)
Aras & Terry (Exile Island)
Tyson & Sierra (Tocantins)
RC & Abi Maria (Philippines)
Tony & Kass (Cagayan)
Bobby Jon & Jamie (Guatemala)
Laura & Shambo (Samoa)
Shane & Courtney (Exile Island)
Dreamz & Yau Man (Fiji)
Mukaku Tribe: 
Jon Misch
Aras Baskauskas
Tony Vlachos
Jamie Newton
Dreamz Herd
Corinne Kaplan
Sierra Reed
RC Saint-Amour
Courtney Marit
Shambo Waters
Bonat Tribe: 
Terry Deitz
Tyson Apostol
Shane Powers
Bobby Jon Drinkard
Yau Man Chan
Natalie Anderson
Sugar Kiper
Abi Maria Gomes
Kass McQuillen
Laura Morrett
Merged Tribe
Fresh Meat#170

I feel like Spencer and Kass are stronger rivals, but solid cast.

anon4981298798#171
I feel like Spencer and Kass are stronger rivals, but solid cast.

Kass has so many options it's not even funny.

nevidcm#172
I feel like Spencer and Kass are stronger rivals, but solid cast.

You know, it never crossed my mind putting Spencer/Kass though which is weird since I really like him. I thought about Sarah/Kass, Trish/Kass, Morgan/Kass, basically everyone except for him. 

nevidcm#173

Cagayan had sooo many great rivalries: 

Lindsey vs. Trish

Kass vs. Trish

Tony vs. Kass

Spencer vs. Kass

Sarah vs. Kass

Morgan vs. Kass

J'Tia vs. the rice

And probably some more I can't remember. 

Fresh Meat#174

Yeah Kass fought with almost everyone there and she occasionally claims she may have taken Tony just to let the season end with a HEATED FTC haha fireworks would have happened with a Kass/Tony FTC.

I feel like her strongest rival is Spencer since she constantly screwed him--second Brains TC, the merge, f6 vote. Haha it's funny because apparently Kass was so evil she'd tell Spencer she's voting with him just to see his face when she blindsides him AGAIN, fully knowing she was never going with him. God, Kass is probably the best female villain in such a long time. Shes up there with Fairplay, Russell, and Jerri imo.

Challenge 17#175

Survivor Madagascar
Old vs young
Alaotra Tribe(old)
Brad
Keith
Terry
Tony
Troyzan
Denise
Jane
Kass
Missy
Shambo

Kinkony Tribe(young)
Hayden
Jeremy
Malcolm
Matty
Spenser
Cierra
Brenda
Corrine
Jefra
Natalie

Challenge 17#176

Survivor India
Champions vs challengers
Marwar Tribe(champions)
Arass
Fabio
Tony
Tyson
Richard
Denise
Jenna
Kim
Natalie
Sophie
Chota Tribe (challengers)
Brad
Hayden
Jeremy
Malcolm
Spenser
Brenda
Corrine
Ciera
Jaclyn
Tasha

nevidcm#177

Survivor: Mongolia

Bantal Tribe: (Old Tribe)

Keith (San Juan del Sur)

Marty (Nicaragua)

Troyzan (One World)

Penner (Cook Islands)

Dale (San Juan del Sur)

Lisa (Philippines)

Kathy (Marquesas)

Shambo (Samoa)

Ami (Vanuatu)

Kass (Cagayan)

Pirulo Tribe: (Young Tribe)

Jay (One World)

Hayden (Bloos vs. Water)

Reynold (Caramoan)

Malcolm (Philippines)

Dreamz (Fiji)

Stephanie (Redemption Island)

Marissa (Blood vs. Water)

Heidi (The Amazon)

Baylor (San Juan del Sur)

Erinn (Tocantins)

Merged Tribe

Challenge 17#178

Survivor Madagascar
worlds apart 2
Massif Tribe (WhiteCollar)
Brad
Marcus
Stephen
Abi Maria
Brenda
Tasha

Altora Tribe(Blue collar)
Matty
Jeremy
Tony
Corrine
Denise
Stephanie

Kinkony Tribe (No Collar)
Fabio
Malcolm
Woo
Andrea
Jane
Morgan

nevidcm#179
Survivor Madagascar worlds apart 2 Massif Tribe (WhiteCollar) Brad Marcus Stephen Abi Maria Brenda Tasha Altora Tribe(Blue collar) Matty Jeremy Tony Corrine Denise Stephanie Kinkony Tribe (No Collar) Fabio Malcolm Woo Andrea Jane Morgan

I think I'm in love with this cast, between Stephanie, Morgan, Stephen, Abi and Corinne, this cast is almost perfect. 

Challenge 17#180
Survivor Madagascar worlds apart 2 Massif Tribe (WhiteCollar) Brad Marcus Stephen Abi Maria Brenda Tasha Altora Tribe(Blue collar) Matty Jeremy Tony Corrine Denise Stephanie Kinkony Tribe (No Collar) Fabio Malcolm Woo Andrea Jane Morgan

I think I'm in love with this cast, between Stephanie, Morgan, Stephen, Abi and Corinne, this cast is almost perfect. 


Thanks, I think it would be a great season, the tribes are pretty even .
I originally had Kass on white collar but I switched her with Tasha to even up the teams.
anon4981298798#181

Corinne would cry if she were on Blue Collar, lmao! Good cast though.

Related Topics

The ChallengeSurvivorCast Spoilers