Behind the Screen: The Challenge: What Ifs

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

Who are some names that never do a Challenge but would have probably become regulars if they accepted the call. Ashley from DC, and Joey from Hollywood...

— El Lobito

Who are some names that never do a Challenge but would have probably become regulars if they accepted the call...

— kvm1977

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: What Ifs with 6 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: What Ifs

El Lobito ·

Who are some names that never do a Challenge but would have probably become regulars if they accepted the call?

Ashley from DC, and Joey from Hollywood. Dione from Go Big would still be doing this if they called

People like CeeJai, Katrina and Will from Hollywood would've been on a couple of seasons idk if they would've stuck around for long enough to be considered regular.

Dylan from GBOGH is another big miss. Madison and Violetta from Skeletons, Ryan Leslie from NOLA2, Joey from Cancun, the veteran (also Ryan?) from Brooklyn, Mike from DC, Trisha from Sydney, Clint / Tovah / Dondre from Atlanta

6 Comments
El Lobito#2822

Who are some names that never do a Challenge but would have probably become regulars if they accepted the call?

Ashley from DC, and Joey from Hollywood. Dione from Go Big would still be doing this if they called

People like CeeJai, Katrina and Will from Hollywood would've been on a couple of seasons idk if they would've stuck around for long enough to be considered regular.

Dylan from GBOGH is another big miss. Madison and Violetta from Skeletons, Ryan Leslie from NOLA2, Joey from Cancun, the veteran (also Ryan?) from Brooklyn, Mike from DC, Trisha from Sydney, Clint / Tovah / Dondre from Atlanta

kvm1977#2823

Who are some names that never do a Challenge but would have probably become regulars if they accepted the call?

Dione

Who?

I misread the question i thought you were asking about real worlders that didn't do a season but would have been regulars if they did

That was his question lol.

It was the question...I dont recall that name...was it Explosion or something late?

kvm1977#2824

Who wins a final between G2 Rookies and G3 Rookies?

Alton, Landon, Jamie, MJ, Randy, Kina, Jodi, Susie, Ibis vs. Frank, Nehemiah, Tori, Jillian, Rachel, Johanna

Lolz

The G2 team wins easily.   Jillian, Tori and Nehemiah were solid plus Frank was great--the other two are arguably two of the worst winners ever.   Alton, Landon, MJ, Susie, Jamie and Jodi all won multiple seasons (only Tori did that for G3) plus Randy won his only season.   When Kina is arguably the second weakest person on your team you're in great shape.  Plus MJ and Randy could have carried Ibis.  Alton too.

Randy was on Sexes 2. I think G2 Rookies win easily. As far as the G3 Rookies go, I'd rank them first with Frank being the strongest, then Tori, Jillian, and Nehemiah. Rachel and Johanna got extremely lucky, I agree.

Good correction on Randy.   Johanna played a good social game a few times and had numbers but just sucked

kvm1977#2825

Who are some names that never do a Challenge but would have probably become regulars if they accepted the call?

Ashley from DC, and Joey from Hollywood. Dione from Go Big would still be doing this if they called

People like CeeJai, Katrina and Will from Hollywood would've been on a couple of seasons idk if they would've stuck around for long enough to be considered regular.

Dylan from GBOGH is another big miss. Madison and Violetta from Skeletons, Ryan Leslie from NOLA2, Joey from Cancun, the veteran (also Ryan?) from Brooklyn, Mike from DC, Trisha from Sydney, Clint / Tovah / Dondre from Atlanta

If we want to go old school Julie from NY would have been great on the show. Kyle from Chicago and Patrick from Xtreme.   More recent Ashlee from NOLA2 might have been an elite competitor

Psy4potato#2826

Agreed - OG Julie would have been amazing on the Challenge!

CosmicDiva#2827

I interviewed Msaada from RR Maximum Velocity in like 2006 when my teenage self tried creating a RW/RR blog. She said she had never been asked to do a Challenge, but had always been open to it. Never watched her season though tbh, lolll

Related Topics

The Challenge