Behind the Screen: The Challenge: What Ifs

For over two decades, MTV's The Challenge has been the proving ground where reality TV's fiercest competitors come to cement their legacies. What started as a Real World/Road Rules spinoff has evolved into one of the most physically and mentally demanding competition series on television.

The franchise's expansion — with spinoffs in the USA, UK, Argentina, and Australia — speaks to a global appetite for the brand of cutthroat competition and alliance-driven gameplay that Vevmo's community has been tracking since 2007.

i think tonya wins the ruins if toothbrush never happened...

— flyguy

If every season after Fresh Meat 2 had exile eliminations and no viewers. I wonder if that changes anything...

— Chicken_breast

Thread Summary

Discussion thread about The Challenge: What Ifs with 30 replies from the Vevmo community.

The Challenge: What Ifs

flyguy ·

i think tonya wins the ruins if toothbrush never happened 

30 Comments
flyguy#2672

i think tonya wins the ruins if toothbrush never happened 

Chicken_breast#2673

If every season after Fresh Meat 2 had exile eliminations and no viewers? I wonder if that changes anything.

flyguy#2674

If every season after Fresh Meat 2 had exile eliminations and no viewers? I wonder if that changes anything.

obviously lmao

RobbioRobbio#2675

What if Karamo and CT did a Rivals season together

GoldenRing#2676

What if Karamo and CT did a Rivals season together

CT gets topped.

CosmicDiva#2677

What if BMP actually gave a **** about their show and its fans 

Tvandcoffee#2678

What if BMP actually gave a **** about their show and its fans 

entrepreneur#2679

What if Karamo and CT did a Rivals season together

CT gets topped.

hmmm...interesting 

Coralfan#2680

What if Karamo and CT did a Rivals season together

I don't see them doing well. Lol.

anon12423452355...#2681

What if BMP actually gave a **** about their show and its fans 

Anon23432534534...#2682

What if Ayanna was on the main show currently?

Flopnanas#2683

does nany finally win if shes paired with ct on any season?

Coralfan#2684

What if Ayanna was on the main show currently?

She would actually bring entertainment and make the show way more watchable than it is now.

Hauserman#2685

What if Ayanna was on the main show currently?

She would actually bring entertainment and make the show way more watchable than it is now.

Anon23432534534...#2686

What if Ayanna was on the main show currently?

She would actually bring entertainment and make the show way more watchable than it is now.

i agree.

CosmicDiva#2687

I've *been* saying that about Ayanna but y'all will ignore a diva till the end of days on earth.

kvm1977#2688

i think tonya wins the ruins if toothbrush never happened 

She'd have been in every elimination to save Johanna and Susie. Not sure how she'd make a final.  And they would have sent her in against KA until she lost. 

GoldenRing#2689

If I said Tonya could've beaten KA in an elimination then what?

flyguy#2690

I might get beat up but I think Sarah was just as good, if not better than KA on the ruins. I could See Tonya beating Sarah at hog tie tho.

Hauserman#2691

Didn't Tonya start working out and take The Challenge seriously going into Fresh Meat and after?

kvm1977#2692

If I said Tonya could've beaten KA in an elimination then what?

Tonya still would have needed to win 2-3 more eliminations to make the final

Her only win that season was against Diem who threw it because she had to go

kvm1977#2693

Didn't Tonya start working out and take The Challenge seriously going into Fresh Meat and after?

She was drunk almost constantly on the Island and Ruins so not sure how that's "taking it seriously"

RobbioRobbio#2694

Tonya was in peak shape during Inferno 3 (which she won).  After that it went downhill

Coralfan#2695

Didn't Tonya start working out and take The Challenge seriously going into Fresh Meat and after?

She was drunk almost constantly on the Island and Ruins so not sure how that's "taking it seriously"

Miss Tonya should have been in therapy not the Ruins. 

JustQR#2696

What if Bananas drowned in key west during Katrina?

entrepreneur#2697

What if Bananas drowned in key west during Katrina?

we probably don't see many Key West people on the challenge, he probably gets a tribute special.

JustQR#2698

What if Bananas drowned in key west during Katrina?

we probably don't see many Key West people on the challenge, he probably gets a tribute special.

The face of the challenge is forever different. Wes, CT, Jordan all linked to Bananas. Those 3 may not have the careers they did either.

CosmicDiva#2699

I would've been a lesbian like Negrotti.

GoldenRing#2700

What if Bananas drowned in key west during Katrina?

we probably don't see many Key West people on the challenge, he probably gets a tribute special.

The face of the challenge is forever different. Wes, CT, Jordan all linked to Bananas. Those 3 may not have the careers they did either.

CT and Wes have plenty of non-Bananas moments.

kvm1977#2701

What if Bananas drowned in key west during Katrina?

we probably don't see many Key West people on the challenge, he probably gets a tribute special.

The face of the challenge is forever different. Wes, CT, Jordan all linked to Bananas. Those 3 may not have the careers they did either.

It was Wes vs Kenny long before John

CT still had Diem

Wes and CT had each other.

Jordan would have just had conflict with someone else. 

Related Topics

The ChallengeElimination Spoilers