The Challenge: Rivals - Evelyn Smith

Buck05;252118 wrote:
Aneesa is way more overrated than Evelyn (who I don't even feel is overrated). Evelyn would beat Aneesa by about 24 hours if they did a final like Duel 2 individually.

For one, Aneesa got caught in the current at the way beginning. Beside the point I was talking individually like a one on one duel. Aneesa would wipe the floor with Ev, that's for sure. How is Aneesa overrated?? Not many people seem to like her, and everyone always praises EV so obviously she is the overrated one -_-

AneesaOwnz;252165 wrote:
For one, Aneesa got caught in the current at the way beginning. Beside the point I was talking individually like a one on one duel. Aneesa would wipe the floor with Ev, that's for sure. How is Aneesa overrated?? Not many people seem to like her, and everyone always praises EV so obviously she is the overrated one -_-

Humor is reason gone mad. - Groucho Marx A day without laughter is a day wasted"- Charlie Chaplin I've been up fewer than 10 minutes this morning, and already you have made my day complete. Thank you!

AneesaOwnz;252165 wrote:
For one, Aneesa got caught in the current at the way beginning. Beside the point I was talking individually like a one on one duel. Aneesa would wipe the floor with Ev, that's for sure. How is Aneesa overrated?? Not many people seem to like her, and everyone always praises EV so obviously she is the overrated one -_-

Thats kind of an arguement against her, cause everyone else was able to make it.. Ev > Aneesa, the end.

V1man;252168 wrote:
Humor is reason gone mad. - Groucho Marx A day without laughter is a day wasted"- Charlie Chaplin I've been up fewer than 10 minutes this morning, and already you have made my day complete. Thank you!

You're very welcome, and you've made my day as well (:

Skeet;252170 wrote:
Thats kind of an arguement against her, cause everyone else was able to make it.. Ev > Aneesa, the end.

That's what you think, it's not like we got to see Ev do it so we don't know how she would have faired. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Sure maybe she'd do better in a final, but definately not one on on (:

AneesaOwnz;252173 wrote:
That's what you think, it's not like we got to see Ev do it so we don't know how she would have faired. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Sure maybe she'd do better in a final, but definately not one on on (:

I guess we'll just have to wait for the show to air.

If it came down to anything physical, like a 1 on 1 physical duel to determine strength, I have Aneessa beating almost any girl including Evelyn (I know she trains like hell, but some people are just born physically gifted). But if it was any other aspect of the game, I'm taking Evelyn on my team

McFly High;252183 wrote:
If it came down to anything physical, like a 1 on 1 physical duel to determine strength, I have Aneessa beating almost any girl including Evelyn (I know she trains like hell, but some people are just born physically gifted). But if it was any other aspect of the game, I'm taking Evelyn on my team

So you're saying you think Aneesa is physically gifted?

I really like Aneesa, and I think she'd have a good chance in a physical duel against Evelyn, and will definitely have a weight advantage, while Evelyn may have a strength advantage. I honestly think it'd be a good match-up to watch. However, after saying all that, I think Evelyn will beat Aneesa in anything agility/speed/stamina related, that's not even a question. I mean, Aneesa has her strengths... but long distance is not one of them it seems. And Evelyn is a beast (a pretty one, but a beast nonetheless), I'm not even a huge fan of Evelyn and I can admit that.

I don't understand why Evelyn is paired with that girl from Key West. I feel as though, she could have been paired with Susie, Tonya or Brooke.

Challenger6;252218 wrote:
I don't understand why Evelyn is paired with that girl from Key West. I feel as though, she could have been paired with Susie, Tonya or Brooke.

Paula. And they're paired mainly because of what happened on the Island. Like Paula said, Ev was never part of the alliance and was only allowed on the best boat and into Paula's original spot because she didn't take Johnny's key (and she's a better competitor than Paula). This didn't fare well with Paula obviously, and she even said in one of her confessionals how disgusted she was that Ev would go along with the whole thing. The tension was brought over to Fresh Meat 2 when Ev showed up late and Paula wanted nothing to do with her and barely greeted her into the house. Then Ev (and Luke) ended up sending Paula (and Jeff) home.

Challenger6;252218 wrote:
I don't understand why Evelyn is paired with that girl from Key West. I feel as though, she could have been paired with Susie, Tonya or Brooke.

Susie and Brooke were in grad school -- not something one leaves. Tonya is building a life for herself away from TV. Would not have happened.

cryssy19;252371 wrote:
(my bad) You're Your sarcasm needs work though.... :P and *woe* is me

Tis why I passed Literature with flying colours and almost failed English... smh

Challenger6;252373 wrote:
I'm sure it does, hon. I'll get started immediately.

Yay! :) On another note, I know it has probably been said already, but Evelyn really does look prettier than in previous challenges. I especially like the colour in her hair.

V1man;252292 wrote:
Susie and Brooke were in grad school -- not something one leaves. Tonya is building a life for herself away from TV. Would not have happened.

I thought Susie already had her PHD in religion. Did she go back? She would have been a great partner for Evelyn.

cryssy19;252390 wrote:
On another note, I know it has probably been said already, but Evelyn really does look prettier than in previous challenges. I especially like the colour in her hair.

I agree completely. Remembering how she looked on Fresh Meat, so young and somewhat fragile, to her visor wearing days,now she's a beautiful woman with a very strong competitive nature. I love seeing/meeting those kind of females, something about them is just refreshing. I'd put Emily (DC) in the same category.

"come on Barbie let's go party"-Aqua This is what I think of when I see this picture. Go Evelyn! I cannot wait to see her on June 22nd.

I hope no one takes this the wrong way, or is offended by it but, is Evelyn a lesbian? If so, she just broke my heart. I think she is gorgeous!

dmenage24;252409 wrote:
I hope no one takes this the wrong way, or is offended by it but, is Evelyn a lesbian? If so, she just broke my heart. I think she is gorgeous!

I'm pretty sure she is considering she has (on many occasions) made out with other females on the challenges and I know when she was on Fresh Meat she had a girlfriend. I'm not sure if she has/does date men though.

dmenage24;252409 wrote:
I hope no one takes this the wrong way, or is offended by it but, is Evelyn a lesbian? If so, she just broke my heart. I think she is gorgeous!

Yes she's a lesbian, though if you ask Johnny Bananas, he'll tell you otherwise (and no I don't mean that she's straight or bi).

Nightwolf;252419 wrote:
Yes she's a lesbian, though if you ask Johnny Bananas, he'll tell you otherwise (and no I don't mean that she's straight or bi).

Can you continue with this? What exactly would Johnny say?

dmenage24;252423 wrote:
Can you continue with this? What exactly would Johnny say?

Does it really matter? I was told by a friend that sexual orientation is a part of who you are not who you are completely. So, I think she should just be judged on her personallty and her athletic ability and not anything else.

dmenage24;252423 wrote:
Can you continue with this? What exactly would Johnny say?

On a couple of Derrick's podcasts, Johnny has made snarky comments about Evelyn being a guy.

dagr317;252437 wrote:
On a couple of Derrick's podcasts, Johnny has made snarky comments about Evelyn being a guy.

Yeah I find that weird that they always joke about that because she doesn't look all that manly at all, she's kinda short and not that bulky. She even cries on the show sometimes so I think they just say it as a rude compliment if that makes any sense. I swear it makes me think Johnny has a crush on Ev or something like that cause he seems to try and mention her name as much as possible on some of the podcasts.

Blue123;252489 wrote:
Yeah I find that weird that they always joke about that because she doesn't look all that manly at all, she's kinda short and not that bulky. She even cries on the show sometimes so I think they just say it as a rude compliment if that makes any sense. I swear it makes me think Johnny has a crush on Ev or something like that cause he seems to try and mention her name as much as possible on some of the podcasts.

Kind of like Angel and her "you're a transvestite!" to Kina.

dagr317;252437 wrote:
On a couple of Derrick's podcasts, Johnny has made snarky comments about Evelyn being a guy.

Now that i think about it, I remember him saying that quite a few times. HAHA. Johnny is jealous because Eve is stronger then him. ;)

El Scorcho;252488 wrote:
But somehow you can see Evelyn being teamed with Brooke who never had a rivalry

Brooke led her on during the Gauntlet III and then IIRC dated Evelyns ex after the show.

dagr317;252437 wrote:
On a couple of Derrick's podcasts, Johnny has made snarky comments about Evelyn being a guy.

Yeah haha, he sure did, and so did Coral and Evan. Although their ways of saying was much more humorous. Coral: I don't care how strong you are, or how much you bench press, or this big rumor about you having a *****... Evan: Brooke going home is the best thing that happened to this team. Now we have our 9th man, little Evelyn, pissed off.

molds13;252185 wrote:
So you're saying you think Aneesa is physically gifted?

well not particularly, but I don't think she has to train as hard as the other girls to be as physical. I honestly think she can beat almost anyone in a 1 on 1 elimination if it was anything physical. But anyways this thread is about Evelyn...I put her with Racheal as 1A and 1B. Paula is a solid player too so I think this pair can go far.

ILoveRW;252500 wrote:
Brooke led her on during the Gauntlet III and then IIRC dated Evelyns ex after the show.

Whatever happened with Brooke and Evelyn's ex happened outside the show where the majority of us don't know and don't care about it. From what the viewer of the show saw was Evelyn and Brooke hook up early in the show and in the after show Evelyn said that she wasn't with Brooke anymore. So I don't think that would be worthy enough of a rivalry to be on a challenge, considering its in their personal life, therefore the viewer (like me) doesn't know about it, because I don't stalk and follow these people on facebook and twitter. I watch the show and thats it, if its not said on the challenge or reunion, I don't know about it.

El Scorcho;252508 wrote:
Whatever happened with Brooke and Evelyn's ex happened outside the show where the majority of us don't know and don't care about it. From what the viewer of the show saw was Evelyn and Brooke hook up early in the show and in the after show Evelyn said that she wasn't with Brooke anymore. So I don't think that would be worthy enough of a rivalry to be on a challenge, considering its in their personal life, therefore the viewer (like me) doesn't know about it, because I don't stalk and follow these people on facebook and twitter. I watch the show and thats it, if its not said on the challenge or reunion, I don't know about it.

I agree Brooke and Evelyn as rivals is more laughable then Jenn and Mandi as Rivals