The Challenge: Create Your Own

A concept I will try for the challenges will be Old School VS New School Here is how it works... There will be 2 teams, one with 14 Old school cast members and the other with 14 New school cast members. In every episode there will be a male and female elimination day. For that mission one person will be selected to be captain. Whichever team wins, the captain of the winning team will be save and then he/she will pick one of the opposite team member to be in the elimination round. Then the losing team will discuss who to send to face the other member in the elimination round. Old School will be from Real World 1 -Real World 10 / Road Rules 1 - Road Rules 8 New School will be Real World 11 - Real World 20 / Road Rules 9 - Road Rules 14 Old School Coral RW10, Julie RW09, Ruthie RW08, Beth RW02, Veronica RR8, Holly RR7, Emily RR 8. Syrus RW06, Colin RW08, Nathan RW07, Matt RW09, Mark RR 01, Dan RR05, Timmy RW02 New School Aneesa RW11, Kelly Anne RW19, Svetie RW17, Rachel RR11, Kina RR13, Tori RR14, Katie RR10 Frank RW12, Brad RW14, Davis RW19, CT RW13, David RR14, Theo RR09, Darrell RR11

How about a Real World vs. Road Rules challenge? Haven't seen one of those in awhile. A new host would be nice too.

I always thought it would be fun to group them by the area they were from. Get them all together and make sure there is a mix of vets and n00bs. Then when they are all together, have a map of the United States and tell them to go stand on the state where they are from. Those are your teams. Get teams for the midwest, northeast, south, california, etc.

I'd like to see Solitary with all real world/road rules alum. That would help satisfy my long growing sadistic desires with some these cast members. :D

I don't find "Solitary" as enthralling as the challenge but, like you, the sadist in me would enjoy to see some unfavorable cast members in "Solitary"

HHHTheGame;42504 wrote:
I always thought it would be fun to group them by the area they were from. Get them all together and make sure there is a mix of vets and n00bs. Then when they are all together, have a map of the United States and tell them to go stand on the state where they are from. Those are your teams. Get teams for the midwest, northeast, south, california, etc.

But aren't like, 80% of them from California? LoL

OtherPplsDrama;42524 wrote:
But aren't like, 80% of them from California? LoL

Yeah, forreal, it sure seems like it

I'd like to see a challenge called Haze Wars. 20 RW/RR/FM Alumni live in a house very close to the next season of the Real World (for example Real World Washington if they have it). Two teams: the skinny guys and the fat *****. The first few episodes each alumni team has to pull pranks or complete missions involving the house the RW: Washington people live in without them knowing whats going on. When its down to the final 8, they reveal themselves to the 8 cast members (assuming there is 8) and have to perform challenges against the current real world cast. Either the 8 remaining members win 300,000 or the 8 cast members win the money.

Battle of the seasons 2: 4 members on each team. -The team that comes in first place on a mission can pick any team to go into the duel/inferno. -the team going into the duel/inferno can pick their challenger. -Then the next challenge if one of the 2 teams win they can replace themselves with any other team except the team that won the last challenge. Duel/Inferno-A running race: Run 1 mile to puzzle or challenge (push boulder 100 yds, Sliders, Carry logs to finish, etc.) TEAMS: RW:SD Brad Randy Robin Jamie RW:Aus Danny Nehemiah Johanna Melinda RW:Kw Johnny Zach Paula Janelle RW:Benver Davis Alex Jenn Colie RR:13 Derrick Patrick Kina Jillian RR:VR Dan Derek Tori Angel FM Evan Ryan Diem Evelyn RW:Old School Syrus David (seattle) Elka Ruthie RR:Old School Blair Theo Katie Susie

I like the Amazing Race/original road rules format, they could just stay in the US or one country though versus traveling around the world. Instead of pairing off like in AR, they could be in their two teams traveling in rock of love style tour buses (I'd be up for another Battle of the Sexes so I would do the males against the females). They have race to each destination based on clues and missions. First team to the destination picks from the losing team one person up for elimination and one person they choose to save, then the losing team votes in a person to go against the person the winning team selected. Final team to get to the ultimate destination gets the grand prize. 8 or 10 on each team Dream cast: Males David (Seattle) Teck (Hawaii) Alton (Las Vegas) Theo (RR Max Vel) CT (Paris - he's a ****** but he's always interesting) Adam (RR Quest) Yes (RR Semester at Sea) Kenny (I don't know where he came from but he's funny) Abram (RR) Abe (RR Latin America) Females Coral (B2NY I just love her) Emily (RR) Kameelah (Boston) Elka (Boston) Veronica (RR SaS) Ruthie (Hawaii) Katie (RR Quest) Ellen (RR Quest) Pua (RR SaS) Sarah (RR Campus Crawl) Have no clue whether this would actually work, but it sounded good in my head.

In my opinion, as long as the people in my list are in a challenge, I could care less about the format: -Rachel (RR:Campus Crawl) -Veronica (RR:Semester at Sea) -Tina (RR) -Shane (RR:Campus Crawl) -Coral (RW:B2NY) -Mark (RR 1) -Brianna (RW:Hollywood) -Devyn (RW:Brooklyn) -Svetlana (RW:Key west) -Eric and his Jump rope (RW:NY) As long as the people on the list are in the challenge, I will be extremely happy. I would watch this challenge, and buy it on iTunes. I'm still optimistic that eventually, I will see the majority do a new challenge.

producer88;45514 wrote:
In my opinion, as long as the people in my list are in a challenge, I could care less about the format: -Rachel (RR:Campus Crawl) -Veronica (RR:Semester at Sea) -Tina (RR) -Shane (RR:Campus Crawl) -Coral (RW:B2NY) -Mark (RR 1) -Brianna (RW:Hollywood) -Devyn (RW:Brooklyn) -Svetlana (RW:Key west) -Eric and his Jump rope (RW:NY) As long as the people on the list are in the challenge, I will be extremely happy. I would watch this challenge, and buy it on iTunes. I'm still optimistic that eventually, I will see the majority do a new challenge.

I like this list :).

In this challenge it is most of the cast of the inferno 3 against gauntlet 3 cast. If people were on both challenges they are on the team in which they lasted longer in the challenge. -The rules are like the gauntlet 1 but the gauntlets are male v male or fem v fem Inferno 3 RW:12 Alton-Captain RW:13 Ace RW:17 Johnny RW:18 Davis RR:2 Timmy RR:12 Abe RR:13 Derrick RW:11 Tonya RW:11 Aneesa RW:17 Janelle RW:18 Jenn RW:18 Colie RR:7 Susie RR:12 Cara Gauntlet 3 RW:12 Frank RW:13 Adam RW:14 Brad RW:16 Nehemiah RR:14 Derek FM Evan-Captain FM Kenny RW:10 Coral RW:14 Robin RW:16 Johanna RW:17 Paula RR:10 Katie RR:14 Tori FM Ev

ballinbroken;46134 wrote:
In this challenge it is most of the cast of the inferno 3 against gauntlet 3 cast. If people were on both challenges they are on the team in which they lasted longer in the challenge. -The rules are like the gauntlet 1 but the gauntlets are male v male or fem v fem Inferno 3 RW:12 Alton-Captain RW:13 Ace RW:17 Johnny RW:18 Davis RR:2 Timmy RR:12 Abe RR:13 Derrick RW:11 Tonya RW:11 Aneesa RW:17 Janelle RW:18 Jenn RW:18 Colie RR:7 Susie RR:12 Cara Gauntlet 3 RW:12 Frank RW:13 Adam RW:14 Brad RW:16 Nehemiah RR:14 Derek FM Evan-Captain FM Kenny RW:10 Coral RW:14 Robin RW:16 Johanna RW:17 Paula RR:10 Katie RR:14 Tori FM Ev

that actually sounds pretty cool, except according to your rules Kenny should be on the I3 team since he won that challenge but lost G3. CT could replace him for the G3 cast, and Kenny could replace Davis since he is useless on challenges

ballinbroken;46134 wrote:
In this challenge it is most of the cast of the inferno 3 against gauntlet 3 cast. If people were on both challenges they are on the team in which they lasted longer in the challenge. -The rules are like the gauntlet 1 but the gauntlets are male v male or fem v fem Inferno 3 RW:12 Alton-Captain RW:13 Ace RW:17 Johnny RW:18 Davis RR:2 Timmy RR:12 Abe RR:13 Derrick RW:11 Tonya RW:11 Aneesa RW:17 Janelle RW:18 Jenn RW:18 Colie RR:7 Susie RR:12 Cara Gauntlet 3 RW:12 Frank RW:13 Adam RW:14 Brad RW:16 Nehemiah RR:14 Derek FM Evan-Captain FM Kenny RW:10 Coral RW:14 Robin RW:16 Johanna RW:17 Paula RR:10 Katie RR:14 Tori FM Ev

The I3 guys would be alot stronger but the G3 girls would be stronger than I3 girls.

mattyw66;46147 wrote:
CT could replace him for the G3 cast, and Kenny could replace Davis since he is useless on challenges

CT would be a great captain. I really don't think Davis is useless on challenges. He did moderate on I3 and he also sent home Danny. I think he's a better competitor/athlete than Ryan.

dplayer18;46148 wrote:
The I3 guys would be alot stronger but the G3 girls would be stronger than I3 girls. CT would be a great captain. I really don't think Davis is useless on challenges. He did moderate on I3 and he also sent home Danny. I think he's a better competitor/athlete than Ryan.

I think Danny's been shafted on the few challenges he's been on. Fresh Meat he got the boot cause of the reliance on Ev, I really think had it been a foot race with baggage between him and Wes he would have won. And I3 they weren't allowed physical contact during the ladder race with Davis, if he was allowed to punch/kick Davis, no question Davis would have lost that inferno, but it was a simple race. As for G3, I have to give props to Adam since with contact allowed he still beat Danny. In the end I guess I agree Davis is somewhat a good competitor at team challenges, but he'd be gone in the Duel before week one was over

Just a quick thank you to all who include Colie on their dream teams.

mattyw66;46786 wrote:
I think Danny's been shafted on the few challenges he's been on. Fresh Meat he got the boot cause of the reliance on Ev, I really think had it been a foot race with baggage between him and Wes he would have won. And I3 they weren't allowed physical contact during the ladder race with Davis, if he was allowed to punch/kick Davis, no question Davis would have lost that inferno, but it was a simple race. As for G3, I have to give props to Adam since with contact allowed he still beat Danny. In the end I guess I agree Davis is somewhat a good competitor at team challenges, but he'd be gone in the Duel before week one was over

Danny gets no pass from me for his Fresh Meat performance. The veteran cast who were there clearly knew that is was Danny who failed miserably. With nearly anyone else, Evelyn would have probably lasted much longer.

I agree - him relying on Ev wasn't the reason they lost, though he sure could have done a better job of helping out. He and only he should get blame in that part. However, you must remember that they would have had a struggle anyway because Danny's luggage weighed a lot due to him carrying a lot of Melinda's possessions. I can't remember exactly how the I3 match up went, but why should he have been allowed to punch or kick Davis? Was it something Davis got to do but not him? Sounds like Danny getting beat was just Danny getting beat, in each situation. I think if he could have been considered shafted, many people could make the same argument. You have to be able to do a variety of things. You don't get the elimination to be suited just to your strengths. Unless it was something like Captain's or Challenger's Choice on G2. But still, it was just picking what you would be closer in doing a good job in - no competitors got to make up the elimination rounds. For creating a challenge? I'd like to see them do a challenge in Europe or Asia, since they have been traveling around a little more recently. I'd like to see a new RW vs. RR challenge. Don't quite have a good idea for a format, yet.

The challenges the have been to Africia, Australia,North America, South America. Why not Europe or Asia??? V1?

RMD1;46804 wrote:
The challenges the have been to Africia, Australia,North America, South America. Why not Europe or Asia??? V1?

You're asking me? LOL Money, money, money... and the ease of production.

V1man;46807 wrote:
You're asking me? LOL Money, money, money... and the ease of production.

LOL I can see your point there. Europe is the most expensive.

RMD1;46804 wrote:
The challenges the have been to Africia, Australia,North America, South America. Why not Europe or Asia??? V1?

One of the old school ones, the Extreme Challenge with James, Emily, Julie, Syrus, Susie, Ayanna etc., was an RV tour that took place partially through Europe if I remember correctly. I think the first half was in the US and then they moved on to Europe.

Challenge_Fan;42525 wrote:
Yeah, forreal, it sure seems like it

and even if that isnt the case originally, they all tend to move to LA haha

ssseeeaaann;46809 wrote:
One of the old school ones, the Extreme Challenge with James, Emily, Julie, Syrus, Susie, Ayanna etc., was an RV tour that took place partially through Europe if I remember correctly. I think the first half was in the US and then they moved on to Europe.

I remember someone said something about one of the earlier ones being in Europe for a part of a challenge. It would be cool to have a full challenge in Europe, though. And I don't think they've been to Asia before, so it would be really neat to see challenges on those continents. They did start branching out a bit when they Australia, Trinidad & Tobago, and Brazil, so I think it would be great if they someday did a challenge in Asia and Europe. I've seen them all, but really can't remember a whole bunch about the earlier ones. Those are the ones I need to see the most again.

I was watching I Love Money 2 and I realized that only 2 people form last season came back. I would love if the RW/RR Challenge was like that. And I also notice that they haven't done a challenge where they get the alumni to pick the teams. Just invite about 28 alumni, have a challenge. Last two people standing get to pick the teams for the rest of the challenge. I know thats what they do on ILM2 but they basically stole the RW/RR Challenge concept anyways.

Seannnn;47010 wrote:
I was watching I Love Money 2 and I realized that only 2 people form last season came back. I would love if the RW/RR Challenge was like that. And I also notice that they haven't done a challenge where they get the alumni to pick the teams. Just invite about 28 alumni, have a challenge. Last two people standing get to pick the teams for the rest of the challenge. I know thats what they do on ILM2 but they basically stole the RW/RR Challenge concept anyways.

ILM (or any love show on vh1) is more like comedy reality TV. Its supposed to be funny. No love show (or even ILM) on that channel even remotely compares to Real World or the Challenges.

JustinMG;42350 wrote:
How about a Real World vs. Road Rules challenge? Haven't seen one of those in awhile. A new host would be nice too.

They would need to Bring back Road Rules for that wouldn't they?

Debut Album;54712 wrote:
They would need to Bring back Road Rules for that wouldn't they?

Either that or make some phone calls to some old vets ;)

ballinbroken;45218 wrote:
Battle of the seasons 2: 4 members on each team. -The team that comes in first place on a mission can pick any team to go into the duel/inferno. -the team going into the duel/inferno can pick their challenger. -Then the next challenge if one of the 2 teams win they can replace themselves with any other team except the team that won the last challenge. Duel/Inferno-A running race: Run 1 mile to puzzle or challenge (push boulder 100 yds, Sliders, Carry logs to finish, etc.) TEAMS: RW:SD Brad Randy Robin Jamie RW:Aus Danny Nehemiah Johanna Melinda RW:Kw Johnny Zach Paula Janelle RW:Benver Davis Alex Jenn Colie RR:13 Derrick Patrick Kina Jillian RR:VR Dan Derek Tori Angel FM Evan Ryan Diem Evelyn RW:Old School Syrus David (seattle) Elka Ruthie RR:Old School Blair Theo Katie Susie

I like this Idea.