Todrick was great tonight. I don't know why Tim Urban is still around.

Wow im so happy Andrew made it. I was nervous. he has to step it up from now on. I cant believe Paige and Tim are still there they both suck. Todrick should still be there.

So Todrick is the first one gone tonight? Have they announced the second person yet? Paige is still around?!? That is the biggest ***!

tatertots;161043 wrote:
So Todrick is the first one gone tonight? Have they announced the second person yet? Paige is still around?!? That is the biggest ***!

Todrick, Alex and Kaetlyn are all gone. its down to katie and lilly for the last spot

Lionsfan780;161046 wrote:
Todrick, Alex and Kaetlyn are all gone. its down to katie and lilly for the last spot

Alex? That's too bad, I liked him. His nerves got the best of him but I liked his voice a lot. I'm pretty surprised about Kaetlyn, thought she had more fans. Probably a result of being so-so and forgotten, while Paige seems to have enough fans voting for her (ie: Vote for the Worst) that got her by. It should be Katie going home over Lilly!

Omg. BOMB!! I can't believe Katie beat her!!!!

Lilly is gone. Im suprised i thought it would be Katie, but i like Katie so im glad she is still around. Lilly should be there instead of Paige or Lacey.

Insider;161050 wrote:
Omg. BOMB!! I can't believe Katie beat her!!!!

Le WHAT? Lilly is gone! That is craziness!

Ok, what did I miss? I just tuned in a little before 9 and just heard Katie singing Wild Horses. Who else has sung and what Rolling Stones song did they do?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_idol_season_9 it has it listed there at the bottom.

thanks! just found it on VFTW's site too.

VFTW, how I loathe thee. I was just telling my friend that that site needs to be taken down.

I absolutely ADORE Siobhan! Just throwing that out there (;

Right now, Siobhan and Crystal are way above anyone else for me. They both seem really comfortable on stage and have consistently picked good sings that suit them well. Siobhan has been a little better at picking less expected songs though. Big Mike was fine, he does have a good falsetto, but I was really put off by the fact that it seemed like he was trying to make the Stones turn into a Michael Jackson take. What was with that? He was even doing all the "EE! OOh!" stuff! R&B does not always have to be MJ. And I agree with Simon, his dancing and mugging to the camera was corny. Tim Urban really needs to go. Why, oh why would you ever think to turn the Stones, and "Under My Thumb" especially, into a lame spring break reggae version? Not good at all. So confused.

To me right now Big Mike and Siobhan are the front runners. Mike has a great voice and i am more impressed by Siobhan every week. Andrew is still my favorite, i think he did pretty well last night. But i think he screwed himself by doing straight up so well, because the judges expect him to be perfect every week. I like all of the guys except Tim. Didi is my favorite girl and i like Katie and Siobhan. For some reason i just dont like Crystal. Either Tim, Paige or Lacey should be gone tonight. But i have a bad feeling it will be Andrew.

i DONT REALLY remember Shiobhan's performances just that she has a funny name.